"flat bread pizza to die for!"(5 Tips)
"Their menu is unique and their desserts are wonderful."(2 Tips)
"Try the pasta fagiole soup 🍜 and Chicken francaise!"(2 Tips)
"their flatbread brickoven pizza"(2 Tips)
19 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- good for dates
- desserts
- chicken francaise
- polenta
- bread pudding
- (5 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Carol EganDecember 23, 2014Gluten free pizza crust is one of the best ever and we are from Brooklyn, the land of gluten free. Restaurant is absolutely beautiful and staff is great. We will be back again and again and again...
JT TeranMarch 15, 2016Cosimo's is known for their flatbread brickoven pizza which is out of this world. Their bar is pretty big and all the staff is very friendly. Definitely worth checking out.
Everything! From the amazing rice balls to that melt in your melt sea bass to all their desserts! And their drinks are my favorite!! I absolutely love this place!
LmtMay 13, 2018Respectful of allergies. Wood fired red snapper very tasty... Brussels sprouts very soft/ overcooked. They also take away plates before all are finished & leave messy table between courses
Joe ConteJanuary 29, 2016there's nothing on this menu that you wont like. try the polenta, or the calamari, and the nonna meatballs are killer!!!- Angela M. KancelerApril 27, 2013Never had a bad meal there. Friendly staff makes you feel like family. Their menu is unique and their desserts are wonderful.
- Try the pasta fagiole soup 🍜 and Chicken francaise! Excellent 👍🏾👍🏾
Jason SifreJune 15, 2011Cosimo's is bomb! You can't go wrong with just about anything on the menu. Free app with a check-in with 3 friends!
Amy ParkerOctober 28, 2013Friendly atmosphere - closes at 11, which is late for this area. Red pasta sauce is VERY salty. Food is mediocre for being all "fresh" and "made in-house." Way too expensive for what you're getting.
Em MarshJuly 27, 2014They've changed the formula for the broccoli rabe w/sausage. Now, it tastes like chode and canned sausage. Sat us directly under air conditioner in near empty restaurant. Ugh.
Dianna JohnsonJuly 7, 2015The food isn't bad, but it used to be better. I've had just about everything on the menu.
41 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Open until 10:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- 11:30 AM–10:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 11:30 AM–11:00 PM
- Sun
- Noon–10:00 PM
(845) 485-7172
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Dinner
Drinks
Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 7.5
"Our waiter, Randy, was great and made us feel comfortable. He was on top of serving us our refills on the soda we ordered. He frequently checked on us. He was friendly. We never had to ask for refills"
DeAnna Mandigo - 8.2
"Same old amazing stephanos portions, delicious food, and generous wine glasses! The best around! Beautiful historic charm and their service has improved considerably. Best Italian cuisine around."
Nicky Smirnoff - 7.4
"Try the whole wheat veggie pizza, delicious!"
Caralyn Serignese
Places people like to go after Cosimo's
- 9.2
"The scenic view of the hudson. Great relaxing walk as well."
Andrew Rodie - 6.9
"Cell Ace, Little Tokyo, and Sicilian Delight are excellent! Great food and great accessories❤️😁The employees are wonderful. Mall is clean and Spacious. Bathrooms are clean too👍🏼👍🏼Love Mr Smoothie"
DeAnna Mandigo - 7.7
"Go with the unsalted popcorn. It's fantastic. Great to have a healthier choice."
Christopher Beaumont
Appears on 16 lists
Created by Vassar College
13 items • 11 followersCreated by Christian Golden
15 items • 1 followerCreated by Audrey Aponte
44 items • 1 follower