Island Creamery
Ice Cream Parlor and Dessert Shop$$$$
Chincoteague Island
"Marsh Mud is for the chocolate lovers"(11 Tips)
"Yes!!!! Get the Java Jolt!!!!!!"(6 Tips)
"You have to try a waffle cone or waffle bowl!!"(9 Tips)
"Great ice cream (especially Pony Tracks!)"(3 Tips)
68 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- ice cream
- java jolt
- marsh mud
- waffle cones
- pony tracks
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Michelle UngerAugust 16, 2012Amazing!nBest time to go is in the afternoon to avoid the mile long lines. The employees move fast and line moves quickly. We had waffle bowl sundaes and they were wonderful. They also do kiddie cones
Jessica GillSeptember 17, 2015Awesome flavors! Be advised the one scoop is HUGE. Watch other patrons' servings so you know what you are getting yourself into!
Christina Tyler WenksNovember 20, 2017Marsh mud, pony tracks, and rocket fuel are our faves. When it was 28 degrees F outside at noon last weekend, this ice cream shop had a line into the parking lot. Think about THAT. Great ice cream.- Christina Tyler WenksMay 26, 2017Inventive flavors and heart go into every cone. We drive hours for "rocket fuel" and "marsh mud" -- and the ocean, too.
When the line is out the door, down the steps and spilling into the parking lot to the point where you're at the sidewalk, watch out for the dopes that will still try to pull in right there.
LOVE the banana milkshakes (vanilla ice cream, milk and a whole banana... a little touch of rum would push it over the top).
Brent GNovember 1, 2014While all of the flavors that I have tried are top notch, the Java Jolt is by far the best.
Kiersten DennisJune 2, 2013Amazing as always! Great service, and the waffle cone is a MUST. Freshly made right in front of you!
DirkJuly 4, 2017Great homemade ice cream and waffle cones! Awesome selection of one-of-a-kind flavors.
Terry SimmsJune 17, 2017The butter pecan was terrific! Loaded with pecans and a rich buttery flavor. The scoops are very generous.
Probably the best ice cream I've ever had in my entire life. Great portion sizes for the price.
ChristeenyJune 27, 2012Marsh Mud and/or Pony Tracks ice cream FTW! Or if you've come for the 3rd day in a row, switch it up and get fudge & espresso instead.
Colin WallsJune 16, 2012The 2 scoop waffle cones have a lot more ice cream than they show in the picture. Enough for two people!
Patrick KaineJuly 16, 2012Homemade waffle cones and bowls! The girl who makes them said they go thru 1,500 per day!
Corrine TownsendMay 19, 2012Waffle Cone is a must. Best I have ever had. Strawberry ice cream is very refreshing.
Ellie PinesAugust 29, 2014Second only to Mister Whippy in terms of dessert options nearby, but that's only because their line is usually longer.
Mark BurfordAugust 27, 2013Marsh Mud Malt. Maybe best Malt I've ever had. If you are in Chincoteague you have to stop here.
- Diana BAugust 8, 2011The line will be long but moves quickly. You have to try a waffle cone or waffle bowl!!
Online ProducerApril 4, 2014As you pay, grab a bag of waffle-cone pieces near the register. They're sweet and crunchy and reason enough to stop.
Rebekah BridgersAugust 8, 2012Best cake batter ive ever had! Totally worth the wait in a line down the street!!!
Elaine ZimmermannSeptember 9, 2013Java Jolt so delicious, pieces of brownie and chocolate covered coffee beans
SageJune 22, 2010This place is the best, but portions are huge. Be sure to try a flavor before getting the whole thing.
Dave TonnesenApril 23, 2011Lids under 8 get free sprinkles! Marsh mud is the choice for chocolate lovers!
- MayaAugust 15, 2010Great ice cream (especially Pony Tracks!), but bring bug spray for the long outdoor line.
Black Raspberry is the best ice cream in Virginia.
141 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
When you're on Chincoteague Island looking for a delicious frozen treat, there's one place locals will tell you is not to be missed. All you need to do is head down Maddox Blvd. until you come to the lighthouse, and we'll be there, eager to serve you our delicious homemade ice cream...
Closed until 11:00 AM tomorrow (Show more)
- Mon–Thu, Sun
- 11:00 AM–9:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
(757) 336-6236
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
Free
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Parking
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Dessert
See More
You might also like
- 8.1
"Great place to stop on the way back from the beach... ESP since they have a drive through. Their potions are huge and their prices are very reasonable!!!"
Michelle Unger - 8.3
"Fudgy brownie with vanilla ice cream and caramel - perfect"
Tim Male - 6.3
"Extremely limited lunch menu. Good for ice cream though."
Jackie Barry
Places people like to go after Island Creamery
- 8.4
"From the Atlantic at Assateague National Seashore, Tom’s Cove, grassy estuaries, and oyster beds, the water and its life are incredible."
Christina Tyler Wenks - 8.6
"Beautiful ocean. Beautiful sand. Horses are entertaining. Loved it."
Amy Grant - 8.4
"Brand new asphalt and lots of shade. Great trail for a summer bike ride!"
Zach Frailey
Appears on 46 lists
30 Places to Eat in Virginia Before You Die
Created by Online Producer
30 items • 62 followers
Created by Steve Hess
105 items • 5 followers
The Best Ice Cream in Every Single State
Created by PureWow
51 items • 236 followers