- cocktails
- good for dates
- dandy riot
- pickle plate
- live jazz
- (15 more)
- Popular
- Recent
- Such good drinks. Dandy Riot. Honey Pot. Need to eat here properly. Would skip the apps - truffle fries are decent. The brandies cherries are delicious just by themselves.
- Wilson ZhouJuly 4, 2015Cozy speakeasy, good to chill with friend with a good cocktail. This drink is Dr. who, bourbon with egg white.
- Jay MandelOctober 20, 2013The pickle plate had a surrise in every bite. Each vegetable was pickled in a different brine. It included egg, cauliflower, carrots, beats and many other fresh pickled vegetables.
- Andrew COctober 17, 2017It is hidden away, upstairs + dimly lit!!! Sticking to the name, it's generally quiet and peaceful... food is spectacular and cocktails were amazing, bartender helped curate non-menu drinks!!
- Ms HeleneApril 20, 2018Book ahead as every table and the bar was full on a show night. Brussel sprouts side,mussels appetizer and roasted beet with goats cheese salad were all good
- Talia FisherNovember 22, 2014Get the farmers cheese and sesame crackers and French fries for bar snacks. The Shrubs are super drinkable but I also really like the drink with the egg white.
- Todd BraceyMarch 14, 2019My first thought was “uh-oh, looks pricy & pretentious.” It was actually very welcoming, good and not too expensive. Our host was bland, but beautiful & efficient. Good booze!
- The Wall Street JournalJanuary 24, 2013Options include the pickle plate and marinated olives, as well as peekytoe crab rolls, which are more like sliders, and ruby red shrimp tacos. Read more
- Serious EatsMarch 11, 2013Solid menu of American classics and excellent cocktails; a great bet for a pre- or post-show meal.
- Mark BMarch 3, 2017Went here during Restaurant Week. Great food. Terrific wine list. Super friendly & knowledgeable staff. Definitely going back!
- Josephine SonMay 29, 2013Great spot to take a date. Good drinks and upscale bar food. Shrimp tacos are the bomb. Pulled pork sandwich and fries are also great.
- Maxwell ZOctober 21, 2012When you enter the lobby of The Public Theater, hang a left and go up the stairs. At the end of the staircase you'll find this hidden Andrew Carmellini restaurant.
- Francesca TMarch 12, 2013The ambiance is amazing. Get the burger! Steak menu on Mondays and live jazz music! Service was also incredible.
- TingNovember 8, 2015Beautiful huge space on the second floor of the Public Theatre with well done cocktails.
- Mike StrockoJanuary 29, 2013Joe's Burger: a blend of brisket and chuck, topped with bacon, cheddar, and caramelized onions.
- Adrienne CooperDecember 6, 2013Skip the burger, go for the more special dishes like the cauliflower casoulet or the potato & pumpkin pierogis. That's where they really shine.
- SiovonneAugust 26, 2014Great place for cocktails. Food was great, and the design of dining in a library is even better.
- Jonathan KaczynskiJanuary 18, 2015A lovely little spot, above Joe's pub. There's always something interesting on the menu.
- Ellen ManuszakJanuary 24, 2013Nice cocktails--enjoyed the Dandy Riot. Prices on par with other upscale cocktail bars in the neighborhood.
- Simran JaisingJanuary 27, 2013lovely place to converse with a friend. comfortable. rigatoni and hot toddy's were solid, but not spectacular.
- Lella CirAugust 13, 2016Go for the atmosphere and innovative cocktails only. Lobster rolls and hanger steak was overpriced for the mediocrity. I don't recommend food except for the french fries, which were worth every penny!
- Awesome cocktails and French fries, plus it rarely gets crowded.
- MichelleMarch 4, 2015I only got drinks. Based on the reviews I was expecting tasty, multi dimensional cocktails but instead I found pretentious drinks with very few understandable ingredients.
- Trae FApril 2, 2017Is it me or is this place a bit of a hidden treasure? John Leguizamo seems to think so!
- Cara AranetaJanuary 1, 2013New year price fixed meal- same price as a two star Michelin and not as good as a one star. Totally overrated. Regretting my nye meal here