See all
347 photos

Tibby's New Orleans Kitchen

Cajun and Creole Restaurant and American Restaurant$$$$

Winter Park

Save

8.7^/10

323

ratings

"Their beignets are to die for and the best Amaretto Sours ever!"(13 Tips)
"Shrimp and grits was great!"(5 Tips)
"Alligator Cheesesteak and Chicken 'n Waffles Po' Boy is amazing"(11 Tips)
"Shrimp and alligator cheesecake"(3 Tips)

128 Tips and reviews

Filter:

grits
po' boys
gumbo
bread pudding
alligator cheesecake
good for groups
crawfish
casual
trendy
good for dates
chicken
happy hour
great value
fried green tomatoes
live music
bar
Amaretto
eggplant
étouffée
dinner
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

S TzMarch 8, 2015
As the spouse of a New Orleanian... It's legit. The rice and beans, beignets, chicory, cafe au lait, grits and shrimp... Can't go wrong. Also the muffuletta is huge- share it!
Beth MacSwainMay 20, 2013
Omg. Such great food. Big portions at very reasonable prices. Got enough to go food to eat supper for the week. Can't wait to come back. Felt like I was back in NOLA.
Patty BOctober 9, 2018
Been here 10+ times
I love all the dishes I’ve eaten here. Favorites are the shrimp & grits, chicken ponchatrain. Drink a hurricane or 2 or 3...
danyia marieMay 2, 2015
OHH WOW... the alligator cheesecake was SPLENDID✨👌 as was the BREADPUDDING😊. REMARKABLE staff, right on spot!
Jay SchneiderOctober 14, 2016
was just there last night....fun place especially if you are from New Orleansdecorated very Mardi Gras likeseafood platter was shared not greasy, well breaded, BIG catfishbeignets were perfect
AC SommersOctober 30, 2012
Been here 5+ times
Heck yes! I'm not a huge grits fan but They do them right; so creamy and cheesy! BBQ shrimp app and seafood gumbo is delish. Last night I had a fried roast beef sandwich; I was in heaven, huge portion
Carole KJuly 6, 2014
Been here 5+ times
Walter's po'boy. Lightly fried chicken br. tossed in Louisiana Gold hot sauce, topped with crispy peppered bacon and pepper jack cheese on warm crispy French bread with all the trimmings
Melanie @DoverwoodCommApril 24, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Love this place! Rita's chicken is our favorite. FYI: They let you select another side if you don't want dirty rice ... Big portion ... bring half of it home! Oh, the beignets are really amazing!
AC SommersOctober 31, 2012
Been here 5+ times
Holy moly! Went two days in a row! Shrimp and alligator cheesecake is like a big Cajun Crabcake so yummy!! Chicken Rita is el esposo's favorite chicken in town now. wishes he a had a microwave at work
DarbyAugust 3, 2012
Everything was so good!...alligator and shrimp cheesecake, the crawfish étouffée was the bomb..add some hot sauce to it..& the shrimp po boy with cheese grits was delicious!! Can't wait to go back
Jeanette FonsecaAugust 28, 2015
Bread pudding was amazing . And I don't even like bread pudding. Jambalaya was off the chain!
Vanessa Acosta de RiveraApril 30, 2013
Been going here since they opened. Best shrimp and andouille grits ever! Their beignets are to die for and the best Amaretto Sours ever! A must go!
Landen AngelineMarch 31, 2011
From a true cajun, this place is legitimate. Whatever you do don't leave without getting some grits. The catfish po- boy was better than most places I get at home, and the try test, Gumbo, was slammin
Pasquale P.April 11, 2011
Amazing po-boys, grits, gumbo, jambalaya and service. Surprised to find out it was owned by same owners of Tijuana Flats bit those guys already know how to succeed in the restaurant biz. Check this!!!
Rebecca RaiaMarch 17, 2017
I love Tibby's! Everything I've ever tried was delicious. Save room for beignets, they're worth it.
Erin DodichJuly 25, 2018
Étouffée is delicious, and the debris gravy is perfect on the fries. Bread pudding is awesome!
Heather ReynoldsJanuary 8, 2012
Rita's chicken cutlets very yummy but rich & filling... Chicken pontchartrain a yummy lighter alternative, try w/spinach. Hurricanes are authentic! No skimping on the liquor.
Scott FornwallSeptember 13, 2014
Been here 5+ times
This place is amazing! No matter how full you get from your meal...you MUST get the bread pudding. You're welcone.
Ryan FoxMarch 17, 2011
Been here 100+ times
Onion Rings are my favorite apps. The Jambalaya, Chicken Gumbo, Fried Shrimp Po Boy, and Country Fried Steak are my favorite entree dishes. Close it out with bread pudding!
Dave RichardMay 2, 2015
Great happy hour. I love the jambalaya too... Bands that play here can be a little too loud though
Gina WoodSeptember 14, 2013
Been here 10+ times
One of the best restaurants in Winter Park . Best food & atmosphere!!! Wait the best restaurant in winter park !!!!'
matt caronOctober 22, 2013
Staff was super friendly and accommodating, and the food is excellent. Don't leave without having the beignets!
April Stanfill MarsagliaMarch 4, 2013
Wonderful New Orleans cuisine. Great atmosphere. Friendly staff. Had a great time!
Gina WoodAugust 4, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Great place for family & friends to gather! We r here for my husbands birthday ... Every thing here is really authentic & taste really good!!!
Ariana VoyerMay 8, 2018
Shrimp and grits was great! Live music can get quite loud.
TristinAugust 27, 2012
The eggplant tchoupitoulas is amazing! It's eggplant lasagna with creole sauce! And it's the perfect portion.
Heather JenkinsNovember 17, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Cold Abita beer, fantastic étouffée, fun NOLA atmosphere.
Mike EdgecombeJune 20, 2017
The server we had did not exhibit any energy at all. The wings that I order were precooked. That location was the one in Winter Park. We're going to the Altamonte Springs location the next time.
Ryan FoxFebruary 28, 2012
Been here 100+ times
Mayors suggestion: start with BBQ Shrimp, advance to the Rita's Lemon Chicken, finish with either dessert (both are excellent).
danyia marieMay 2, 2015
Alligator cheesecake ROCKS, OHH and MUST try the BREAD PUDDING... WOWW✨👌
Scott FornwallAugust 9, 2014
Been here 5+ times
Everything is awesome! Great food, great atmosphere! I highly recommend Tibby's.
Elizabeth BaranikMarch 3, 2013
The étouffée was awesome! Great portion & delicious!
Heather ReynoldsDecember 13, 2011
Tibby Style fried oyster po-boy even if you don't like oysters = ZOMG (I had the half size with cheddar grits...mmm)
Javier YatacoMay 6, 2012
Oh my god, get The Ritas with Shrimp, its not on the menu. Its to die for!! My favorite dish yet.
Lee StoneNovember 7, 2014
I had the eggplant parmigiano poboy and the grits. Spectacular! !!
Alina DelCampoSeptember 1, 2013
Shrimp and grits. OMG. Definitely a must have! Service and food was great.
Dean WayeDecember 30, 2011
Unlike most places, you need to have dessert. Order the beignet and cafe au lait, or the bread pudding.
Erik NicholsonMarch 16, 2012
Been here 5+ times
Authentic cajun food..def recommend the po-boys and a pint of purple haze, an authentic Louisiana beer.
ᴡ MNovember 9, 2012
Michelle is a fantastic server! Get the shrimp and grits. Beignets are perfection.
Laura HarringtonJune 24, 2013
Shrimp and cheese grits...do it. Seasoned to perfection. So so good. And beignets, obviously.
Brian AverySeptember 14, 2011
Great food and service. Could use some Dixie beer. Place is a little small---go early to avoid a long wait.
Kj NanaFebruary 21, 2014
Beignets and coffee. I'm back in New Orleans sitting at Cafe Du Monde. Good Times!!!!!!!
Kate OlsenMay 21, 2013
Food is authentic and delicious! Ask for Nate, the bartender. He is awesome!
neesh CApril 29, 2012
You have to get the blackened chicken and grits. I hate grits and it was AMAZING!
Carole KJuly 6, 2014
Been here 5+ times
Started with shrimp & alligator cheesecake, onion ring stack and Blue Max punch.
Elizabeth KozupOctober 18, 2011
They have side pricing for just about everything. Easy to mix and match a great dinner.
Holly YonJune 17, 2012
Everything is really good! My favs are the dirty rice, & catfish PO boy
iKerochu PupachuNovember 6, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Alligator Cheesesteak and Chicken 'n Waffles Po' Boy is amazing
Dayna PriestJune 9, 2014
I agree with Landen. Get a poboy. I like their beignets, too.
J. R.August 20, 2014
Been here 5+ times
Get the fried pickles. Eggplant po'boy is a good vegetarian option.

1 2 3

347 Photos

Planning a trip to Orlando?

Foursquare can help you find the best places to go to.

Tibby's New Orleans Kitchen

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Tibby's New Orleans Kitchen

Appears on 89 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.