Mary Mac's Tea Room is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Atlanta.

1. Mary Mac's Tea Room

8.6
224 Ponce de Leon Ave NE, Atlanta, GA
Southern Food Restaurant · Midtown · 302 tips and reviews

favthingsatlfavthingsatl: 1st time visitors get a comp pot likker. Mac + Cheese, tomatoe pie and the chicken and dumplings are a MUST! Come hungry bc they don't skimp on the portions.

Stephanie P.Stephanie Page: Try the Cheese & Vegetable Souffle' or the tomato pie...both are sooooo good!!

DeepDeep: Try the Fried Pork Chops - With Tomato Pie & Squash Soufflè. Crispy yet tender...Could care less about the difribulator for dessert.

Fox Bros. Bar-B-Q is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Atlanta.

2. Fox Bros. Bar-B-Q

9.2
1238 Dekalb Ave NE (at Elmira Pl NE), Atlanta, GA
BBQ Joint · Candler Park · 406 tips and reviews

SEGASEGA: You can't go wrong with anything at Fox Bros. Definitely try the brisket, pork, tomminator, frito pie and fox-a-roni. - Kate, Assistant Community Manager

Angela J.Angela JorshaqvShoppe: Fried pickles, texas fries, smoked wings, frito pies...it's all good!

Rob L.Rob Lee: Lovin it all: ribs, pulled pork, chicken and the pecan pie! All served up by sweet Marissa

The Varsity is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Atlanta.

3. The Varsity

8.0
61 North Ave NW (at Spring St NW), Atlanta, GA
Hot Dog Joint · Midtown · 363 tips and reviews

Kendall G.Kendall G: Chilli Cheese Dogs & fresh fried Peach Pie

Christopher C.Christopher Collins: #1 with pimento cheese and slaw, onion rings, an orange drink and a fried peach pie.

Keith B.Keith B.: Kids like the hot dogs. Get the fried peach pie for desert!

Panbury's Double Crust Pies is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Atlanta.

4. Panbury's Double Crust Pies

8.4
209 Edgewood Ave SE Ste 104, Atlanta, GA
English Restaurant · Georgia State University · 14 tips and reviews

Andrew W.Andrew Watson: The cracked pepper beef pie should be the basis of a new religious movement, it's that good. Also. Get an Apple turnover. It will change your world view.

Christine C.Christine Carolan: Chicken and mushroom pie is good!

Creative Loafing AtlantaCreative Loafing Atlanta: Fresh thyme and rosemary complement the already robust flavor of thick-cut beef chunks in the Steak and Stout pie. A subtle onion and mushroom combo confirms it: this pie is comfort-food central. Read more.

Fat Matt's Rib Shack is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Atlanta.

5. Fat Matt's Rib Shack

9.1
1811 Piedmont Ave NE (at Montgomery Ferry Dr NE), Atlanta, GA
BBQ Joint · Morningside - Lenox Park · 211 tips and reviews

Joaquin A.Joaquin Armonic: Order the Sweet Potato Pie. They have each slice neatly wrapped for you to grab. It is too good.

Jonathan S.Jonathan S: I'm always skeptical any place with lots of hype but this was the real deal. I wasn't even hungry and went back for a second half slab after a 1/4 combo. Sweet potato pie was awesome!

Elizabeth C.Elizabeth Choi: My new favorite BBQ place in Atlanta! Rum baked beans are sweet and savory and the pulled pork sandwich is to die for! And make sure you save some room for dessert-- the pies are amazing!

Morelli's Gourmet Ice Cream is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Atlanta.

6. Morelli's Gourmet Ice Cream

9.1
749 Moreland Ave SE (at Ormewood Ave. SE), Atlanta, GA
Ice Cream Parlor · Ormewood Park · 92 tips and reviews

James H.James Hsiao: If you're here on a weekend, see if they have a special flavor crafted by Chef Kevin Gillespie. Previous flavors include Bourbon Peach Fried Pie and Mexican Cinnamon Toast.

Adam M.Adam Moss: The banana cream pie is ridiculous!

JoshuaJoshua: Rabbi's Wisdom: Sweet Potato Pie is a cool taste of Southern roots

OK Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Atlanta.

7. OK Cafe

8.5
1284 W Paces Ferry Rd NW (at Northside Pkwy NW), Atlanta, GA
Diner · West Paces Ferry · 144 tips and reviews

WadeWade: The Peacan pie at OK Cafe is a weekly tradition. Just absolute love, especially with coffee in the morning.

Mark C.Mark C: Don't get the iced coffee, it's too weak. Do eat the corn muffin, mac and cheese, and pecan pie! Shakes come in 2 vessels.

LeonLeon: pot pie is awesome...roasted chicken salad sandwich is amazing

King of Pops is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Atlanta.

8. King of Pops

8.9
1079 North Ave NE (at N Highland Ave), Atlanta, GA
Dessert Shop · Poncey-Highland · 57 tips and reviews

sarevie m.sarevie mischievie: lemon ricotta. chocolate sea salt. key lime pie. anything with basil in it. it's ALL good.

JaymaJayma: Key. Lime. Pie!!!!!

Monica Z.Monica Zarate: I could eat a popsicle a day!! I love the key lime pie, the thai tea, the blackberry ginger, the raspberry...AND they do free Yoga on Tuesday nights on the beltline...now that's rad!

Panbury's Pie Café is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Atlanta.

9. Panbury's Pie Café

8.2
231 Peachtree St NE (John Portman Blvd), Atlanta, GA
Café · Downtown Atlanta · 3 tips and reviews

Lindy F.Lindy Frank: Mini Apple pie

Ron H.Ron Ha-Mercy: These pies are the bomb! I eat 6 🥧's every two week and get my 7th 🥧 FREE!

Panbury'sPanbury's: Check in on Yelp, Facebook or Foursquare and receive a FREE mini sausage roll!

The Optimist is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Atlanta.

10. The Optimist

9.4
914 Howell Mill Rd NW (9th St NW), Atlanta, GA
Seafood Restaurant · 212 tips and reviews

Fernanda D.Fernanda Di Giaimo: One of the best seafood places ever! World class cook and service (ask for Christopher, such a nice waiter)! Tender Octopus as a starter, Scallops with potatoes and asparagus for entre and Boston pie.

ALESHA B.ALESHA BELL: The best desert is the upside down apply pie w/cinnamon ice cream

Nikki E.Nikki Elle: The key line pie is delish!

South City Kitchen is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Atlanta.

11. South City Kitchen

9.1
1144 Crescent Ave NE (at 14th Street), Atlanta, GA
Southern Food Restaurant · Midtown · 200 tips and reviews

Dave B.Dave Blohm: Food was mediocre at best. Had shrimp and grits. It was OK. But at $40 per plate, I expect my food to be significantly more than OK. Apple cobbler was little more than apple pie filling in a bowl.

Stephen B.Stephen Bullard: Best Pecan Pie ever!!!

KatKat: The Chocolate Pecan pie is delicious!

Agave is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Atlanta.

12. Agave

8.7
242 Boulevard SE (at Carroll St), Atlanta, GA
Mexican Restaurant · Cabbagetown · 103 tips and reviews

GPNAGPNA: Local Lust: Everything is great! Keep coming back until you have eaten everything on the menu at least once. Always finish with Peanut Butter Pie. It's got a kick!

Sara M.Sara McGlothlin: Get: meatloaf, peanut butter pie. Don't get: guacamole, mango margarita.

GPNAGPNA: Everything is great! Keep coming back until you have eaten everything on the menu at least once. Always finish with Peanut Butter Pie. It's got a kick!

Edgewood Speakeasy is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Atlanta.

13. Edgewood Speakeasy

7.5
327 Edgewood Ave SE (Hilliard Street SE), Atlanta, GA
Speakeasy · Sweet Auburn · 15 tips and reviews

MayaMaya: Angel and the staff will treat you right. Try one of the signature cocktails or a secret shot of Apple Pie moonshine. Weekly events include Wed movie night and Saturday night sounds by DJ Ryan Baker.

CandiceCandice: That Old Smoky Apple pie Moonshine is delicious.

Methuzulah G.Methuzulah Gem: Got to try the "Smokey's Apple Pie Moonshine"!!! It's a must, if your drinking? Packs a punch, with a tasty sweet but balanced flare #daredevil

Chops Lobster Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Atlanta.

14. Chops Lobster Bar

9.0
70 West Paces Ferry Rd, Atlanta, GA
Steakhouse · Buckhead · 56 tips and reviews

Nick C.Nick Carter: Lobster bisque, Kobe steak, cream spinach, corn mash, and white chocolate banana cream pie. Yum.

DeeniDeeni: Steak to die for, good red w selection, loved the bananana cream pie. Service is exceptional. Those lobster tails r hugee-just meat!

Amy S.Amy Snyder: Ribeye and fried lobster tail - fantastic as expected. For sides - if you like corn at all - get the corn mash. HOLY MOTHER OF GOD!!!! And ask for Harland. Exceptional service!!!

InterContinental Buckhead Atlanta is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Atlanta.

15. InterContinental Buckhead Atlanta

8.7
3315 Peachtree Rd NE, Atlanta, GA
Hotel · Buckhead · 67 tips and reviews

Mari M.Mari Moreno: The best banana cream pie ever!!!

Aurielle N.Aurielle Neal: The pecan pie at southern art is to die for!!!!

Jacob D.Jacob Drake: It was a great experience. Hotel staff extremely friendly and we took advantage of the courtesy shuttle to get around locally in Buckhead. I would definitely stay here again.