1. Dépanneur
8.8
242 Wythe Ave (at N 3rd), Brooklyn, NY
Deli · Williamsburg · 104 tips and reviews
Jeffrey Allen: Excellent sandwiches, including the #4 (smoked turkey, onions, manchego, harissa mayo & peppadews) & the BLT special. Not cheap, but very tasty.
Cooper Smith: Awesome little Williamsburg bodega of local products. The #4 turkey sandwich, with peppadews, Manchego, arugula, and a spicy Harissa mayo is one of the best sandwiches in the hood.
Sabrina Majeed: My go-to is the #4 - Turkey, manchego, harissa mayo... omg it's perfection. The #5 with prosciutto, fig jam, and mozzerella is a close second. They also have gluten-free bread!
3. Red Hook Lobster Pound
8.9
284 Van Brunt St (btwn Verona St & Visitation Pl), Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Red Hook · 171 tips and reviews
Tasting Table: Try the Maine-style lobster roll, highlighting fresh lobster lightly seasoned with homemade mayo and a touch of lemon, served on a split J.J. Nissen bun. A contender in our 2012 Lobster Roll Rumble: Read more.
Karan Tamhane: This place has the best lobster roll ever! My favorite is the Maine style. Tons of fresh lobster meat, on a perfectly grilled roll with a touch of mayo.
Michael Chang: Craving a lobster roll, but can't make it to Maine? You won't be disappointed with the Maine (house-made mayo) or Connecticut (butter) lobster rolls made with a 1/4 lb of fresh knuckle and claw meat!
5. Court Street Grocers
9.2
485 Court St (btwn Nelson and Huntington St), Brooklyn, NY
Food and Beverage Retail · Carroll Gardens · 157 tips and reviews
J Crowley: Turkey sandwich is ridiculously good. Combo of dark and white meat. 3 slices of bread - inside slice nice and crispy toasted. Outside slices soft. Tell them to go light on the mayo.
Anna Potter: Calling all North Carolinians: you can get Cheerwine and Duke's Real Mayonnaise here. This is proof that God loves us.
Jeffrey: The Mother In Law - braised beef short rib, mother-in-law's kim chi, roast broccoli, mayo, on garlic bread - overloaded with no structure.
6. Choice Market
8.2
318 Lafayette Ave (at Grand Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Café · Clinton Hill · 130 tips and reviews
Michael Zucchi: BLT is a must here. Mayo makes it.
Food Network: Ted Allen, of Food Network's The Best Thing I Ever Ate, recommends Choice Market, a neighborhood institution serving an awesome BLT with Rosemary Mayonnaise. Find more tips at FN Local. Read more.
Abby H.: Get the orange chocolate scone, the pear brûlée cheesecake, a tart, and/or the steak panini with chipotle mayo.
7. Chavela's
8.9
736 Franklin Ave (at Sterling Pl), Brooklyn, NY
Mexican Restaurant · Crown Heights · 291 tips and reviews
Julie F: Try the Elotes Callejeros - Grilled corn with chipotle mayo, cotija cheese and seasonings. Best damn grilled corn I've *ever* eaten. Ever.
Kino: Mexican corn here is tasty, thanks to the chipotle mayo. They serve cactus here, which is different & good. Quesadillas are small, but I liked the squash blossom. Shrimp ceviche is not worth ordering.
__TR3V: very chill spot. great food. Tilapia tacos were on point. The spicy mayo really is really good. Also can't go wrong with their sangria
8. Mother's
7.8
347 Graham Ave (btwn Metropolitan Ave & Conselyea St), Brooklyn, NY
Burger Joint · Williamsburg · 101 tips and reviews
Johanna: Sweet potato fries with chipotle mayo and an IPA.
Kristina Rudic: Get the regular burger and sweet potato fries, which come with the chipotliest of mayos. All beers are superb here as well!
Kimmie Ohh: Bacon cheeseburger, sweet potato fries, chipotle mayo & a beer
9. Southside Coffee
8.7
652 6th Ave (at 19th St.), Brooklyn, NY
Coffee Shop · Greenwood Heights · 70 tips and reviews
Andrew Weiser: Scrambled eggs, Heritage Meats ham, Cheddar, pickled onion, and a compulsively edible redeye-gravy-like mayo on a brioche roll.
Anthony De Rosa: Southside breakfast sandwich is as good as advertised. Pickled red onions and breakfast mayo add an awesome tang.
eric mortensen: Outstanding cappuccino. Some places might even call this a cortado. Whatever it is, it's perfect. Killer croissants, too. From Balthazar, I think.
11. Ashbox Cafe
8.6
1154 Manhattan Ave (btwn Ash & Box St), Brooklyn, NY
Café · Greenpoint · 42 tips and reviews
Rebekah N: Order the salmon avocado seaweed wrap with spicy mayo, shiso, and radish sprouts. And an iced matcha green tea, of course!
VotreX Tan: Unassuming and a rare gem at North Greenpoint.
thecoffeebeaners: Order the famous Onigiri riceballs with salmon or plum!
12. Smashburger
7.5
80 Dekalb Ave (btwn Hudson Ave & Rockwell Pl), Brooklyn, NY
Burger Joint · Fort Greene · 72 tips and reviews
Rob: Hello Brooklyn!!!! i think that smashburger signature NJ burger is the best : Bacon , blue cheese , grilled onion , haystack onion , lettuce , tomato, mayo , pretzel or multigrain bun (try it !)
Eric Shepherd: <3 grilled chicken on an egg bun, with lettuce, tomato, grilled onion, Swiss cheese, and spicy mayo.
💩Anthony Keller: Dont even bother with the burgers, they are usually burnt and gross. I get the fried chicken sandwich with pepperjack cheese and chipotle mayo. If you want a good burger go to 67 Burger or Shake Shack
13. Habana Outpost
8.4
757 Fulton St (at S Portland Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Cuban Restaurant · Fort Greene · 248 tips and reviews
Michelle Lee: Go to Habana Outpost and get some corn. Cheese, mayo, chili powder. Yum.
7th.List: Taste: The famous corn - slathered in mayo, cotija cheese, and chile powder and kicked up with a squeeze of lime..also try sweet plantains; hot dog; steak sandwich Read more.
Daniel Howells: The Cuban sandwich was perfect. The corn was good too but not everything needs to be covered in mayo :-)
15. Gen
9.0
659 Washington Ave (at St Marks Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Sushi Restaurant · Prospect Heights · 63 tips and reviews
Erika B.: Sashimi deluxe is always fresh, spicy tuna roll has the mayo on top.
Oliver Huang: The Traditional Breakfast brought me back to Japan. Try it if you've spent time living in Japan or want to embrace traditional food, it's not easy to find! Yaki-salmon, unagi-maki, kinpira, and NATTO!
BrooklynMuseum: Staff Pick! Stephanie (Education): Gen has high-quality, fresh sushi at good prices. The patio out back is a lovely spot for dining in the spring and summer. Enjoy the green or red bean ice cream.