The Wicked Monk is one of The 15 Best Places for Pot Pies in Brooklyn.

1. The Wicked Monk

8.4
9510 3rd Ave (Btwn 95th & 96th St), Brooklyn, NY
Bar · Bay Ridge · 33 tips and reviews

Jennifer H.Jennifer Harmon: The chicken pot pie is amazing !

Mary J.Mary Jasen: Great Thursday live music! Pot pie so good!

Mary J.Mary Jasen: Another great lunch special at the Wicked Monk, Cesar Salad and chicken franchise special! Finish off with new dessert offering trio chocolate mousse layered dessert

Mejlander and Mulgannon Delicatessen is one of The 15 Best Places for Pot Pies in Brooklyn.

2. Mejlander and Mulgannon Delicatessen

8.5
7615 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Sandwich Spot · Bay Ridge · 11 tips and reviews

owen m.owen masiello: The pot pie is delicious, well everything is but the pot pie and the philly cheesesteak are my fave

Ana C.Ana C: Home of the Brooklyn cupcakes. Yummm. M&M makes everything great!!! Love this spot!!

Timothy B.Timothy Borock: Order the Cardiac Arrest w/ Peter Lugers steak sauce. Best sandwich anywhere!!!

Pie Corps is one of The 15 Best Places for Pot Pies in Brooklyn.

3. Pie Corps

7.8
77 Driggs Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Pie Shop · Greenpoint · 26 tips and reviews

Sinead D.Sinead D.: Fantastic for any meal! Best chicken pot pie I've ever had. And those pie pops...

Abi G.Abi Green: Chicken pot pie! 💜

Ray L.Ray Lin: A terrific addition to the neighborhood. Staff is warm and friendly, and boy can they bake. Personal favorite: the chicken pot // smoked ham & cheddar handpie.

Skinflints Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Pot Pies in Brooklyn.

4. Skinflints Restaurant

8.0
7902 5th Ave (at 79th St), Brooklyn, NY
Pub · Bay Ridge · 50 tips and reviews

Christian E.Christian E.: Chicken pot pie ftw!

Katie I.Katie I: Long wait Saturday night but worth it. Pot pie and shepherd pie rule and I'll be damned but the turkey burger is awesome

Craig K.Craig Kanalley: Amazing homemade chicken pot pie!

Purbird is one of The 15 Best Places for Pot Pies in Brooklyn.

5. Purbird

8.5
82 6th Ave (at St Marks Ave.), Brooklyn, NY
American Restaurant · North Slope · 71 tips and reviews

Cha 🎈🏃🏻Cha 🎈🏃🏻: yummy handheld chicken pot pie. they use d'artagnan chicken

HolidayHoliday: Briny, succulent grilled chicken with crunchy skin. Treat yourself to a few sauces like mango chutney and the lemon parsley.

Alex R.Alex Rainert: As someone who prides himself on being a rotisserie chicken connoisseur, the birds here are top notch. The whole wheat mac and cheese + chopped salad make for a great combo.

Putnam's Pub & Cooker is one of The 15 Best Places for Pot Pies in Brooklyn.

6. Putnam's Pub & Cooker

8.4
419 Myrtle Ave (Clinton Ave.), Brooklyn, NY
Pub · Clinton Hill · 105 tips and reviews

AndreaAndrea: Chicken mushroom pot pie.....delicious

Kiki B.Kiki Beckles: What a fantastic place!!! Great food, great atmosphere, great cocktails!!! Oh and let's not forget great music!

SaraSara: They play The The and The Police and Van Morrison (and other wonderful bands). The service is hit/miss and the food prices aren't excellent but the food, drinks, and atmosphere are excellent!

Boston Market is one of The 15 Best Places for Pot Pies in Brooklyn.

7. Boston Market

7.7
1972 Ralph Ave, Brooklyn, NY
American Restaurant · Flatlands · 7 tips and reviews

Ted L.Ted Levin: Great Chicken and ribs at an affordable price. However the crust on the chicken pot pie is not flakey

Bugs Are Gone E.Bugs Are Gone Exterminating: Sweet Potatoes are off the chain. Today is a 2 for $20 deal.

Zoey A.Zoey Ali: The macaroni and cheese are so yummy !!

Blueprint is one of The 15 Best Places for Pot Pies in Brooklyn.

8. Blueprint

9.1
196 5th Ave (btwn Union St & Berkeley Pl), Brooklyn, NY
Cocktail Bar · North Slope · 140 tips and reviews

Kimberly A.Kimberly Agin: Been here once for brunch once for dinner. Cocktails and food were great. Rabbit pot pie was fabulous. Biscuits and yogurt for brunch was amazing.

Robert B.Robert Bratney: One of my favorite cocktail bars, with definitely the highest quality cocktails you'll find around the area. Ryan, one of the bartenders, is a very good mixologist.

Time Out New YorkTime Out New York: Sit at the wood-topped bar to watch co-owner Regina Christiansen mix drinks like the classic Blood & Sand, or abscond to one of the smaller tables along the wall for a quiet conversation. Read more.

Park Slope Ale House is one of The 15 Best Places for Pot Pies in Brooklyn.

9. Park Slope Ale House

7.1
356 6th Ave (at 5th St.), Brooklyn, NY
Pub · Central Slope · 49 tips and reviews

matt s.matt sudol: Find me a better chicken pot pie - I dare you

dave d.dave d: The chicken pot pie is very good.

Brad K.Brad Klein: Stopped in for a pregame snack before meeting friends for trivia. Fries were very good and they had Sweet Baby Jesus on tap! Will be back

Hamilton's is one of The 15 Best Places for Pot Pies in Brooklyn.

10. Hamilton's

8.4
2826 Fort Hamilton Pkwy (E 4th St), Brooklyn, NY
American Restaurant · Windsor Terrace · 114 tips and reviews

Nate F.Nate Folkert: chicken pot pie with creamy sauce

Adrianna G.Adrianna Grężak: Omg the chicken pot pie

Nate F.Nate Folkert: decadent bread pudding oozing with creme anglaise

Landi's Pork Store is one of The 15 Best Places for Pot Pies in Brooklyn.

11. Landi's Pork Store

8.5
5909 Avenue N (Ralph Avenue), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Flatlands · 11 tips and reviews

Babs M.Babs MacCourtney: Only the best Italian Meat and Deli and more. Get: meat, pasta, artichokes, pasta salad, antipasti. Ate the delicious food later at home! Better than going out!

Charles D.Charles D'Alessandro: The true flavor of Brooklyn Italian style!

The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group: Make sure you listen for your number when the place is crowded…just shout and they’ll help you. Make sure you try the rice balls and the antipasto salads.

Diner is one of The 15 Best Places for Pot Pies in Brooklyn.

12. Diner

8.9
85 Broadway (at Berry St), Brooklyn, NY
Diner · Williamsburg · 286 tips and reviews

Erick D.Erick Diaz: Pot pie was huge and delicious. The trout with prosciutto a dream come true.

n g.n g: Cute retro diner meets upmarket fares. Delicious swordfish and pork tenderloin! You should always make room for the flourless cake. Magnifique!

Phillip B.Phillip Bowden: lmao if you think Diner isn't amazing.

Hunter's Steak & Ale House is one of The 15 Best Places for Pot Pies in Brooklyn.

13. Hunter's Steak & Ale House

8.2
9404 4th Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Steakhouse · Bay Ridge · 19 tips and reviews

Mary J.Mary Jasen: Another great meal at Hunter's excellent chicken francese ! Service always friendly and nice. Great band tonight!!!

Daniel H.Daniel H: surf and turf!!!

Lisa R.Lisa Ryan: Went here for my 29th bday and the food was AMAZING. .the staff was so friendly and there was a man there playing a keyboard and he was awesome, we knew every song! !' Wonderful dining experience!

Atrium DUMBO is one of The 15 Best Places for Pot Pies in Brooklyn.

14. Atrium DUMBO

7.5
15 Main St (btwn Water St & Plymouth St), Brooklyn, NY
American Restaurant · DUMBO · 96 tips and reviews

James K.James Kiernan: Excellent wine list though I wish they mixed up the menu more. Chicken for two with mini pot pie FTW!!

Nicole C.Nicole Checo: Atrium became one of my faves places in all NYC. Delicious food & cocktails, beautiful ambiance and amazing, friendly staff. Nothing else you could ask for.

The New YorkerThe New Yorker: "Many of the dishes are downright heavy, oddly wintery for an end-of-summer meal by the water. Which is not to say that the results aren’t frequently, even disconcertingly, satisfying." Read more.

Buckley's Restaurant and Catering is one of The 15 Best Places for Pot Pies in Brooklyn.

15. Buckley's Restaurant and Catering

7.6
2926 Avenue S (at Nostrand Ave.), Brooklyn, NY
American Restaurant · Madison · 19 tips and reviews

ChristineChristine: Great filet mignon & shrimp Scampi on weekend menu! Always tip your servers my mom works here! Also great party rooms had a beautiful baby shower in the large party room

Ken M.Ken MacBride: Best Roast Beef Dinner in Brooklyn!

Mary J.Mary Jasen: Steak is great, company excellent! Staff so friendly. Sat with Jackie and had dessert, nice guy! Happy Holidays!