Luigi's Pizza is one of The 9 Best Places for Supreme Pizza in Brooklyn.

1. Luigi's Pizza

8.9
686 5th Ave (btw 20th & 21st St), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Greenwood Heights · 47 tips and reviews

Ms. Madeline M.Ms. Madeline MS: Very good supreme pizza slice

AdamAdam: Best regular slice in south slope!

David Z.David Zhang: So underrated. Just as good as grimaldis without the wait. They are the best "order by the slice" pizzeria in nyc.

Margot's Pizza at EMILY is one of The 9 Best Places for Supreme Pizza in Brooklyn.

2. Margot's Pizza at EMILY

919 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · 4 tips and reviews

Josephine S.Josephine Son: Finally made it! Love Supreme pizza is where it's at! These guys need a permanent spot soon!

JocelynJocelyn: If you love mushroom get the Funghitown. Love the super crispy crust of all the pizzas.

Rachel W.Rachel W.: Get The Love Supreme!

Emmy Squared is one of The 9 Best Places for Supreme Pizza in Brooklyn.

3. Emmy Squared

8.7
364 Grand St (at Marcy Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Williamsburg · 168 tips and reviews

Juho R.Juho Ranta: Tried the Roni Supreme pizza and the Big Matt burger, OMG 😱 So good and so unhealthy in the same time! 😍 A huge recommendation to all the burger lovers!

Neel B.Neel Bhargava: Ridiculously good pizza. If you've never had Detroit style you are in for a great surprise

EaterEater: The pizzas are baked in pans and resemble Sicilian-style pies. Options include the Deluxe (sauce, mozzarella, sausage, peppers, mushrooms) and the Lou-Wow (sauce, mozzarella, spicy pineapple, ham). Read more.

Russ Pizza is one of The 9 Best Places for Supreme Pizza in Brooklyn.

4. Russ Pizza

7.4
745 Manhattan Ave (btw Norman & Meserole), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Greenpoint · 23 tips and reviews

rich m.rich masio: One of the best slices in Brooklyn.

Carissa R.Carissa R: BEST PIZZA. Greater than any in williamsburg/greenpoint!

Aneta (.Aneta (Netty): Gotta Love the Pepperoni Hero and the Chicken Parmesan on a hero .. yumm

Brooklyn Fare is one of The 9 Best Places for Supreme Pizza in Brooklyn.

5. Brooklyn Fare

8.6
200 Schermerhorn St (at Hoyt St), Brooklyn, NY
Grocery Store · Boerum Hill · 81 tips and reviews

Mary W.Mary Woods: I fell in love with the place it has everything and a lot of choices from meats veggies etc. Service is great. Will definitely be back to shop

The New York TimesThe New York Times: Turn off your device and let the evening wash over you like a dream. Don’t return to the grid until afterward. Pinky swear on that. Read more.

KPKP: Everyone should shop here. Excellent food, good product selection, and great prices.

Marks Pizza is one of The 9 Best Places for Supreme Pizza in Brooklyn.

6. Marks Pizza

7.6
326 Van Brunt St (Pioneer), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Red Hook · 6 tips and reviews

Alex R.Alex Ravenel: Very good classic New York pizza. Good delivery option in the neighborhood.

Jay A.Jay Alston: Lasagna pizza!! Gotta get it!!!

Mike S.Mike Sherman: Best chicken bacon ranch slice I've had in my entire life.

Roberta's Pizza is one of The 9 Best Places for Supreme Pizza in Brooklyn.

7. Roberta's Pizza

9.2
261 Moore St (at Bogart St), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · East Williamsburg · 864 tips and reviews

Glaelis S.Glaelis Sierra Gomez: We went for brunch... Try the sticky buns! They're amazing! Also, we had the Cowabunga pizza... It's like a supreme pizza!! Super good!!!

Nandi A.Nandi Anderson: Delicious pizza. Cool vibe! Try the brunch food!

EaterEater: Here's what happens when hipster chefs get it right. Market-driven goodness and go-to pizzas. Check out the Heritage Radio Network, which broadcasts from the dining room on Sundays. [Eater 38 Member] Read more.

Little Caesars Pizza is one of The 9 Best Places for Supreme Pizza in Brooklyn.

8. Little Caesars Pizza

7.1
2874 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Highland Park · 1 tip

Kimmie O.Kimmie Ohh: Pizza pizza!

AJ's Pizzeria is one of The 9 Best Places for Supreme Pizza in Brooklyn.

9. AJ's Pizzeria

7.2
4412 Fort Hamilton Pkwy, Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Borough Park · 3 tips and reviews

Kevin C.Kevin Campbell: Heroes, linguini and clam sauce, all the different slices are good. Try the stromboli slice

Jessy S.Jessy Singh: Must have: Stuffed shells

Kevin C.Kevin Campbell: Chicken parm hero on garlic bread