Milk Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Toasties in Brooklyn.

1. Milk Bar

8.3
620 Vanderbilt Ave (at Prospect Pl), Brooklyn, NY
Breakfast Spot · Prospect Heights · 168 tips and reviews

Brandon C.Brandon Cummins: The Toasties are super tasty, especially w/avocado. And if you're into it, I've heard they make a proper Flat White. :) Read more.

Tim C.Tim Cox: Spinach Mushroom Toastie, coffee, poached fruit and greek yogurt.

Yoojin L.Yoojin L.: They changed the menu! No more alcohol, or guac & poached egg toasties, but still a great spot nonetheless.

Dirty Precious is one of The 15 Best Places for Toasties in Brooklyn.

2. Dirty Precious

8.6
317 3rd Ave (1st Street), Brooklyn, NY
Cocktail Bar · Gowanus · 30 tips and reviews

Kevin R.Kevin Reevers: Great drinks, great toasties (iykyk) just wish the there was a better vibe.

Ren T.Ren Tucker: Cocktails! Mocktails! Meatballs! Staff & Space!

IrmaZandl Z.IrmaZandl ZandlSlant: New spot in Gowanus. Delicious cocktails (I like the booziest ones) and the sardines and the meat and cheese plates are great!!

Colonia Verde is one of The 15 Best Places for Toasties in Brooklyn.

3. Colonia Verde

9.1
219 Dekalb Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Latin American Restaurant · Fort Greene · 87 tips and reviews

GothamistGothamist: Those who prefer their beef ground can opt for the pao de quiejo burger, served in a toasty bun and topped with a zesty onion and cilantro pesto like the one you'd be dipping your steak into. Read more.

Sebastian B.Sebastian Behar Piquero: A Brooklyn-Brazilian mix with a juicy beef served in a toasty pao de queijo bun and topped with cilantro pesto onion sauce. Sweet potato fries and a spicy sauce on the side.

aneessa s.aneessa steilen: Duck confit tacos are a must. Big portions, plan on sharing because everything is so tasty.

Brooklyn Ball Factory is one of The 15 Best Places for Toasties in Brooklyn.

4. Brooklyn Ball Factory

9.3
95 Montrose Ave (btwn Leonard St & Manhattan Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Japanese Restaurant · East Williamsburg · 90 tips and reviews

Tiffany H.Tiffany Hui: The Hoji Latte was perfect- beautifully made and tasted incredible (rich, sweet, toasty flavor).

Bienvenido C.Bienvenido Cruz: Great coffee and bento box lunches

Lane R.Lane Rettig: The salmon in the grilled salmon bento was maybe the best salmon I've ever had. Unfortunately the rest of the bento was so so!

Shelsky's of Brooklyn is one of The 15 Best Places for Toasties in Brooklyn.

5. Shelsky's of Brooklyn

9.0
141 Court St (at Atlantic St), Brooklyn, NY
Bagel Shop · Boerum Hill · 128 tips and reviews

Real Cheap EatsReal Cheap Eats: "The baked salmon salad works really well with a warm, toasty bagel; in one bite, the combination is cool, warm, crunchy and soft. The salad tastes fresh and will satisfy any salmon lover." Read more.

P. D.P. D.: Excellent bagel. Fresh and soft.

Time Out New YorkTime Out New York: Try the Peter Shelsky. A spin on the bagel-and-lox format with 3 kinds of fish—Eastern Gaspé salmon, soft sable & sweet pickled herring in cream sauce. It’s one of our #100best dishes & drinks of 2011 Read more.

Vinegar Hill House is one of The 15 Best Places for Toasties in Brooklyn.

6. Vinegar Hill House

9.0
72 Hudson Ave (at Water St), Brooklyn, NY
American Restaurant · Vinegar Hill · 263 tips and reviews

Brooklyn B.Brooklyn Based: At brunch, get the Ruben Sanchez, cheesey, toasty, meaty deliciousness.

Sophie G.Sophie Goodwin: Pork chops! Chicken! Ratatouille! Garden!

EaterEater: Plenty of great finds on the budget-friendly wine list. [Eater 38 Member]

Mama Rao's is one of The 15 Best Places for Toasties in Brooklyn.

7. Mama Rao's

8.5
6408 11th Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Borough Park · 21 tips and reviews

Anastasia B.Anastasia Bonilla: Everything is good! I love the pear salad!

🌺 Lauren S.🌺 Lauren S 🇺🇸: Best lemon cookies around : )

💋StephanieMarie💋💋StephanieMarie💋: After you eat go next door & pick up their DELISH lemon cookies! They have a wide selection of cookies & food! Heaven

baba cool cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Toasties in Brooklyn.

8. baba cool cafe

7.4
64 Lafayette Ave (btw S Elliott & S Portland), Brooklyn, NY
Café · Fort Greene · 54 tips and reviews

GokulGokul: cozy cafe with delicious toasties!

Nate F.Nate Folkert: brisket sandwich with italian sausage and bell peppers on brioche with a small side green salad

Liz W.Liz Won: The bike pump outside still works!

SkyIce Sweet & Savory is one of The 15 Best Places for Toasties in Brooklyn.

9. SkyIce Sweet & Savory

7.6
63 5th Ave (at St. Mark's Ave.), Brooklyn, NY
Dessert Shop · North Slope · 104 tips and reviews

Bryan B.Bryan B: The non fried fry ice cream is not what you'll expect, it's way better. Toasty and delicious.

Angie T.Angie Tee: Amazing ice cream. Good spicy noodles and Thai iced tea too

Serious EatsSerious Eats: The food is just average at this Thai restaurant, but we're fans of the ice cream, in particular the Thai tea flavor.

Boston Market is one of The 15 Best Places for Toasties in Brooklyn.

10. Boston Market

8.0
1972 Ralph Ave, Brooklyn, NY
American Restaurant · Flatlands · 7 tips and reviews

Ted L.Ted Levin: Great Chicken and ribs at an affordable price. However the crust on the chicken pot pie is not flakey

Zoey A.Zoey Ali: The macaroni and cheese are so yummy !!

Bugs Are Gone E.Bugs Are Gone Exterminating: Sweet Potatoes are off the chain. Today is a 2 for $20 deal.

Brooklyn Wine Exchange is one of The 15 Best Places for Toasties in Brooklyn.

11. Brooklyn Wine Exchange

8.8
138 Court St (btwn Pacific & Atlantic), Brooklyn, NY
Wine Store · Cobble Hill · 40 tips and reviews

Mike P.Mike Pope: Absolutely love the membership. Attend so many amazing classes. Love.

estheribrown ✌🏻estheribrown ✌🏻: The staff here are super friendly and helpful - they're happy to make recommendations and I've never had a miss w/one. Love the $12 and under table and the free wine tastings & classes. Great shop.

Scott F.Scott Flaherty: I'm no connoisseur (tend to pick wine by the design on the label), but it seems like they keep the cheaper stuff on a table in the middle, and in general have a great selection.

Amber Steakhouse is one of The 15 Best Places for Toasties in Brooklyn.

12. Amber Steakhouse

7.9
119 Nassau Ave (at Eckford St), Brooklyn, NY
Steakhouse · Greenpoint · 23 tips and reviews

Alice M.Alice Mancino: We got the steak tartare, filet mignons, asparagus, and creamed spinach. Everything was good.

Michael P.Michael Palladino: Try the avocado mashed potatoes w/ sea scallops GREATEST FOOD EVER!!!

Josh F.Josh Friedlander: Warm and inviting service. Get the ribeye.

Subway is one of The 15 Best Places for Toasties in Brooklyn.

13. Subway

7.3
3102 Avenue U, Store #3 (Gerritsen Avenue), Brooklyn, NY
Sandwich Spot · Sheepshead Bay · 1 tip

Jim R.Jim Regan: Always get great service, restaurant is always clean.

Starbucks is one of The 15 Best Places for Toasties in Brooklyn.

14. Starbucks

7.5
5296 Kings Plaza (at Macy's), Brooklyn, NY
Coffee Shop · Mill Basin · 9 tips and reviews

TommyTommy: Super friendly guy at the register from time to time...but all the workers I've met here are friendly. It's also one of few Starbucks around so it's all we got. I'll take it!

Kesiel W.Kesiel W: Slow service!

Joyce C.Joyce Coco: Enjoy their decaf coffee & occasionally will treat myself to a caramel macchiato.

McDonald's is one of The 15 Best Places for Toasties in Brooklyn.

15. McDonald's

7.4
3143 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Fast Food Restaurant · Highland Park · 4 tips and reviews

MarcMarc: Sunday afternoon, very nice day, not crowded at all

LexiLexi: Two drive thru lanes.

MarcMarc: 8-10 minute wait for 2 cheeseburgers. Something's wrong here. Oh well.