1. Dépanneur
8.8
242 Wythe Ave (at N 3rd), Brooklyn, NY
Deli · Williamsburg · 104 tips and reviews
Cooper Smith: Awesome little Williamsburg bodega of local products. The #4 turkey sandwich, with peppadews, Manchego, arugula, and a spicy Harissa mayo is one of the best sandwiches in the hood.
Vivek Vadoliya: Best Turkey sandwich I've ever had
Noah Weiss: Fantastic sandwiches in a bougey gourmet grocery store. The #4 turkey sandwich, with peppadews, Manchego, arugula, and a spicy Harissa mayo is delicious. 🦃🍞🧀👌
2. Henry Public
8.8
329 Henry St (btwn Atlantic Ave & Pacific St), Brooklyn, NY
Gastropub · Cobble Hill · 192 tips and reviews
The New York Times: Recommended: Turkey sandwich, cross-cut marrow bones, salad, oysters, Wilkinsons for dessert. The well-charred “hamburger sandwich” is a balm to an appetite fatigued by too many baroque burgers. Read more.
Dee H: Nice bartender, chill atmosphere, great turkey sandwich and Wilkinsons, $5 beer during happy hour... I'm a happy camper!
Melody Gambino: Solid cocktails and OMG kind of good turkey sandwich and deviled eggs
Sarah: Grocery selection is small but very nicely curated. The spicy turkey sandwich is delicious and large, well worth the $9 and the wait.
Anna Brown: Nice little grocery store with specialty items. It's on the expensive side but it's not a place you do a weeks worth of shopping. The bread is amazing as are the veggies. I love the kalamata olives!!
Serious Eats: Fresh mozzarella from the Bronx, cheese from upstate, produce and chocolate from Brooklyn, home goods from the South, and more—there's quite a bit tucked into this specialty shop.
Danny Hillman: Came back two days in a row. Turkey sandwich was unreal. Broccoli Rabe and Siracha Honey. Come on.
Aneta Besecker: Their sandwiches are a killer & their coffee is to die for!
The New Yorker: “If a deli is only as good as its egg-and-cheese, Court Street Grocers rules them all: creamy scrambled eggs, melted white Cheddar, arugula, and a split hickory-smoked sausage, on a buttered roll.” Read more.
9. Butler Bakeshop
8.7
40 Water St (at Dock St), New York, NY
Café · DUMBO · 23 tips and reviews
Emma Barnes: Turkey sandwich and curried chicken wrap were delicious
Jastine Kho: Fantastic location with a nice view of the Brooklyn Bridge. Pleasant baristas. Decently priced, quality food.
Andrew James: The fresh pastries, the coffee, the food, the vibe, the baristas, the location
10. Eastern District
8.7
1053 Manhattan Ave (btw Eagle & Freeman St), Brooklyn, NY
Food and Beverage Retail · Greenpoint · 41 tips and reviews
Cooper Smith: Love the turkey sandwich with smoked gouda and bacon jam (next time ill add greens). Pair it up with a growler of whatever they have on tap, especially if its Founders All Day IPA
thecoffeebeaners: Adorable shop with quality products. Mast Brothers chocolate, Grumpy's coffee, and nunu treats too!
Tom Evans: Best selection of cheeses. Great place for sandwiches. All their products are high quality. Owners and staff are fantastic and very knowledgeable. A gem of a place!
11. Bread & Spread
8.2
147 Front St, Brooklyn, NY
Sandwich Spot · DUMBO · 19 tips and reviews
Gothamist: The turkey sandwich is served on 7-Grain bread prepped with cranberry mustard and Muenster before it's toasted. Once the cheese is bubbly, they add shallots, watercress and herb-accented turkey. Read more.
Aaron Moodie: The Porchetta sandwich is amazing . Be sure to visit early though as they tend to sell out around 2pm.
Amy Coates: Everything is deeeeelish! I haven’t tried the newest sammie yet - short rib. Next time :)
14. Almondine Bakery
8.2
85 Water St (btwn Dock & Main St), Brooklyn, NY
Bakery · DUMBO · 151 tips and reviews
Shah: Hands down the best baguettes in the city (get a whole or the turkey sandwich), and I should know, I've had them all.
Jimmy Chandler: Turkey sandwich.
Stuart Adler: Yummy bread baked on-site. Arrive early though, for the whole grain breads