The 7 Best Places for Italian Sandwiches in Chelsea, New York

William Huba: Really great, simple Italian sandwiches.

Brian Strauss: Maddone! This place is the bomb. Great bread. Excellent quality ingredients. Stuffed but not too stuffed. Seriously one of the best Italian sandwiches I’ve ever had.

Dan Castellano: Very nice Italian sandwiches, recommend the Cappone for the full experience

Brad D: Italian sandwiches!

Wesley Bliss: Great, old fashioned Italian sandwiches. Multiple bread options

Cole Kennedy: After one visit, I’m ready to declare this one of the best lunch spots within walking distance of Madison Square Park. The sandwiches are enormous, delicious, fresh, and cheap. Here’s the Firenze.

Lou Carulli: Subway, Lenny's, Pot Belly go there first AND then go to Salumeria Biellese, you will immediately taste the difference REAL deli meat thats homemade makes! I got the large Italian sub

Mike Schoppmann: Single best Italian sandwich I've ever had, and it's only $10

Michael Spinelli: A none-too-fancy, low-key lunch spot with amazing Italian salumi choices and excellent lunch specials. Or just get the meatball parm hero and go sit on a stoop somewhere.

Chez Ong: The hot dog is frankly the best. 😏 oh and get the Italian sandwich too! It’s kinda like a Cuban sandwich but Italian.

Magdalena Welcz: Looks like everyone is getting a hot dog here, but TAKE STEAK SANDWICH OR SLOPPY ITALIAN SANDWICH. They are much better value and sooo good.

jon ferrer: The best place to buy quality locally sourced meat. great sandwiches (ham and cheese, roast beef, Italian combo), roast chicken, and AMAZING housemade hot dogs.

Jeremy Perry: Best Italian sandwiches in Chelsea.

Tim Shey: My usual: the #13 sandwich on baguette with roast turkey instead of roast beef.

Steven Lehrburger: Even the paper bags for the sandwiches are 3x better than they are anywhere else.

Zac Snider: Amazing, simple, Italian sandwiches. Incredible.

ZenFoodster: Canotto w/ brioche dough, gruyere, prosciutto, & mascarpone is my 1st pick of savory items. And for my fave sweet one, I'd take any 1 of their Canottos w/ bits of super-juicy & fresh seasonal fruit!

Village Voice: As far as filled donuts are concerned, we're hard-pressed to find a finer specimen than the bomboloni. Treat yourself to the vanilla custard one; a delight you won't forget!

Kristen Egan: $3 organic juices! They'll add ginger to a green dream if you ask! Healthy and refreshing!

Melissa B: best breakfast sandwiches in the area.

Mike: Get an egg and cheese sandwich with a hashbrown in the middle. You won't regret it.