Martini Modern Italian is one of The 15 Best Places for Carbonara in Columbus.

1. Martini Modern Italian

8.5
445 N High St, Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 50 tips and reviews

Jack K.Jack K: Mary Beth was the best. Chicken Carbonara and Short Ribs are a must.

Eduardo F.Eduardo Ferrari: A real truly Italian restaurant. Fresh ingredients, fresh pasta, fresh hand rolled mozzarella.... need to say more? My favorite restaurant in Columbus.

Nicholas T.Nicholas Tebbe: Don't really like it when employees take mayorships of long term patrons who support their business. Seems counterproductive to me

Piada Italian Street Food is one of The 15 Best Places for Carbonara in Columbus.

2. Piada Italian Street Food

8.0
2585 E Main St (at S Remington Rd), Bexley, OH
Italian Restaurant · 39 tips and reviews

Elizabeth H.Elizabeth Hill (Blinn): Get the pasta carbonara with crispy chicken and cannoli chips!!

Sarah C.Sarah CJ: The staff is very friendly and helpful! The food portions so big, I can never eat it all! Chicken is great, also if you want a really filling salad, here's your place!!

Delilah N.Delilah Nunez: The wine is cheaper than a soda! At 1.25 it's a steal!

Pastaria is one of The 15 Best Places for Carbonara in Columbus.

3. Pastaria

7.6
59 Spruce St (at North Market), Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 7 tips and reviews

Michelle H.Michelle Harris: Shrimp and Scallop Carbonara was delicious!

Jeffrey N.Jeffrey Ng: Try any of the striped pastas. Their reco on sauce pairing is great too!

jireselljiresell: Bought a great tomato and mozzarella salad here. Also some garlic green beans. The young lady who served us seemed to be having a bad day however. Not very helpful on suggestions for heating beans.

Marcella's is one of The 15 Best Places for Carbonara in Columbus.

4. Marcella's

8.9
615 N High St (at Poplar), Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 67 tips and reviews

Gaurav A.Gaurav A: Really good authentic food. Pasta Carbonara was authentic with a yolk. Like it should be.

Ashley B.Ashley Bowerman: Best dinner: start with a cheese flight of fontina, pecorino, and Gorgonzola dolce, followed by the bresaola (under "Cured Meats"), and finish with the sunchoke and escarole salad and calamari.

Lindsey K.Lindsey Klun: Olive oil is made from olives that are pressed into oil!

Olive Garden is one of The 15 Best Places for Carbonara in Columbus.

5. Olive Garden

7.5
7160 Sawmill Rd (at I-270), Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 19 tips and reviews

Ken B.Ken Bourque: Chicken and shrimp carbonara is really good

Taylor W.Taylor Watkins: I love dipping the breadsticks in the Chicken and Gnocchi soup. Oh my goodness I can't get enough of that stuff!! I'm so glad they serve endless soup.

Brandie W.Brandie Williams: Me likey breadsticks

Piada Italian Street Food is one of The 15 Best Places for Carbonara in Columbus.

6. Piada Italian Street Food

7.9
1315 W Lane Ave (btwn Northstar & Kenny), Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 58 tips and reviews

Hunter F.Hunter Fox: Pasta carbonara is very good!

BuzzFeedBuzzFeed: This growing chain is the place to go for quick and fresh salads, pastas, and piadas: thin-crust, Italian dough baked on the grill and rolled up with cheese, veggies, and meat. Read more.

Jayme H.Jayme Hoffman: PIADA STICKS!!!!!

Basi Italia is one of The 15 Best Places for Carbonara in Columbus.

7. Basi Italia

8.6
811 Highland St (Buttles), Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 31 tips and reviews

Scioto ValleyScioto Valley: The cozy atmosphere, tasty cuisine and ever-changing wine list make this the perfect spot in Columbus for date night.

Horacio N.Horacio Nieto: Amazing atmosphere and patio!

Columbus Food AdventuresColumbus Food Adventures: If it's your first time make sure you get the zucchini pronto. It's the best zucchini ever tasted (with olive oil, pecorino and almonds)

Hickory House is one of The 15 Best Places for Carbonara in Columbus.

8. Hickory House

8.1
550 Officenter Pl (Corner of Taylor and Morrison), Gahanna, OH
Bar · 24 tips and reviews

Jay I.Jay Irby: Get the rib appetizer (great portion!) and/or The Ultimate....it is indeed the ultimate sandwich.

Lea S.Lea Smith: Onion straws were great. I really liked the rib dinner and salad. My husband had crab cakes and he said they were mostly filling and will not get them again. We will definitely go back.

Derrick-BrittDerrick-Britt: Stop by the bar for great drink prices and great service.

TAT Ristorante di Famiglia is one of The 15 Best Places for Carbonara in Columbus.

9. TAT Ristorante di Famiglia

7.9
1210 S James Rd, Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 10 tips and reviews

SemaSema: True Italian Ristorante. Feel like you travel back in time. :) Homemade pasta and a lemon cake to die for.

Jesse K.Jesse Karma: Go with the Chicken-Parm.. You will leave full. Our waitress Seena was on top of it.. BTW Bacardi's were 6.25 a drink.

Jordan T.Jordan Tyler: My boyfriend's lasagna is superior.

Brio Tuscan Grille is one of The 15 Best Places for Carbonara in Columbus.

10. Brio Tuscan Grille

8.5
3993 Easton Sta (at Easton Town Center), Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 48 tips and reviews

Barbie C.Barbie Coleman: Great, friendly service! You will always feel welcome here! Food is delish too! Two thumbs up for a great overall experience!

Joseph T.Joseph Tsoi: Lobster Bisque

Cindy C.Cindy C: The lobster bisque!

Fazoli's is one of The 15 Best Places for Carbonara in Columbus.

11. Fazoli's

7.6
1520 Hilliard Rome Rd, Hilliard, OH
Italian Restaurant · 11 tips and reviews

Mikaela H.Mikaela Hunt Thorpe: You eat from real plates at a great price... and Fast! Plus it's one of the cleanest "fast food" places on Hilliard-Rome. Two thumbs up from this Mom!

Carolina S.Carolina Skinner: Tuesdays kids meal is 99¢

AndrewAndrew: "Italian" food... Fast!

Cooper's Hawk is one of The 15 Best Places for Carbonara in Columbus.

12. Cooper's Hawk

9.1
4230 The Strand (Worth Ave), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · Easton · 69 tips and reviews

Brandie F.Brandie Feuer: Pretzel bread, pork medallions & risotto are some faves. Plus any sandwich can be made on gluten free bread! Make sure to get your 2 free wine samples at the wine bar!

dana 🍓 .dana 🍓 : Complimentary Mimosa or Bellini with brunch? Ok!

Joshua S.Joshua Swearingen: Food is outstanding and the wine selection isn't to be missed. Wine club is absolutely worth it and it's a great date night out. Wear nice clothes or risk having the Waite staff treat you poorly.

OSU Faculty Club is one of The 15 Best Places for Carbonara in Columbus.

13. OSU Faculty Club

7.5
181 S. Oval Dr., Columbus, OH
Restaurant · 3 tips and reviews

John M.John Mahilo: Upstairs food is much better than in colleagues....costs about $10 more but worth it!

Don B.Don Bush: Great Food. Comfortable as Home

Mickey L.Mickey Luft: Freeman's easy

Market Stand Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Carbonara in Columbus.

14. Market Stand Cafe

7.6
Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 6 tips and reviews

Leah F.Leah Fetters: The food is delicious and all made from scratch. The shaved prime rib sandwich with balsamic mushrooms and caramelized onions is incredibly good. Yummy goodness!

Jamie L.Jamie Lyon: Great gluten free options and reasonable sit down prices. Try the salmon with citrus drizzle for dinner and the buffet for breakfast!

Carrie R.Carrie Ricer: Great food!!

The Cheesecake Factory is one of The 15 Best Places for Carbonara in Columbus.

15. The Cheesecake Factory

8.4
1566 Polaris Pkwy # 124 (at Polaris Mall), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 63 tips and reviews

Kristina K.Kristina Kusuma: Famous for their cheesecakes. Red velvet & tiramisu cheesecake are my favorite.

Meghann C.Meghann Cleary: Best Happy Hour in the Area!

Sara C.Sara Cleary: Erica is a pretty sweet bartender!