Don Antonio by Starita is one of The 9 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Hell's Kitchen, New York.

1. Don Antonio by Starita

8.8
309 W 50th St (at 8th Avenue), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Hell's Kitchen · 376 tips and reviews

Wil S.Wil S: Order the pagnotello (sausage, rapini, smoked buffalo mozzarella and olive oil)

Staff PicksStaff Picks: Ever had fried pizza? Try this Naples specialty called montanara. The dough is flash-fried before it's cooked in the oven. Then covered with tomato sauce, basil, & smoky buffalo mozzarella. Read more.

Anna P.Anna Preston: Lunch special- 8 dollars for margarita pizza and a small salad. Amazing.

Gallo Nero is one of The 9 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Hell's Kitchen, New York.

2. Gallo Nero

402 W 44th St (9th Ave), New York, NY
Wine Bar · Hell's Kitchen · 51 tips and reviews

Nina L.Nina LoSchiavo: The buffalo mozzarella is excellent.

Kara S.Kara Scagnelli: Great find! Excellent food and atmosphere, worth it!

New DramatistsNew Dramatists: For an authentic and savory meal before the theater look no further than Gallo Nero.

Joe Allen is one of The 9 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Hell's Kitchen, New York.

3. Joe Allen

8.0
326 W 46th St (btwn 8th & 9th Ave), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 47 tips and reviews

David R.David Reed: Great atmosphere and food, well worth a trip to chill with a beer and a snack

Andrew A.Andrew Andrew: After a great show or a flop, get the meatloaf!

Serious EatsSerious Eats: A solid option for a quick, no-fuss pre-theater dinner.

ViceVersa is one of The 9 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Hell's Kitchen, New York.

4. ViceVersa

7.9
325 W 51st St (8th & 9th Aves.), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 36 tips and reviews

Dorothee W.Dorothee Walliser: best bread basket, best service, awesome food

Marques S.Marques Stewart: get a 3 course meal for only $35, all the time.

Tash C.Tash Concepcion: Mushroom pasta is ok but a little too much oil. Order the smaller portion.

Tavola is one of The 9 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Hell's Kitchen, New York.

5. Tavola

8.3
488 9th Ave (at W 38th St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 72 tips and reviews

PaddyPaddy: Very nice place in Hells Kitchen. Neopolitan pizza and pasta dishes. Pappardelle with veal ragu was delicious and the Calabresa pizza was great too. Cannoli and decent espresso for dessert.

Michael A.Michael Axelbaum: The lasagna and wild boar meatballs were great. Wood fried artichokes were delish. Service could use some polishing. But we were here on night 1.

Banana Nut Bread O.Banana Nut Bread Oo Oo Oo Oo Kie: Look up at the ceiling, the fans work on an old school belt system by rotating rope! Awesome. Oh and the pizza is very very good!

Sullivan Street Bakery is one of The 9 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Hell's Kitchen, New York.

6. Sullivan Street Bakery

8.9
533 W 47th St (btwn 10th & 11th Ave), New York, NY
Bakery · Hell's Kitchen · 122 tips and reviews

Will C.Will C.: Delicious and delectable selections...always! I love this place...too much!

Gansevoort Hotel GroupGansevoort Hotel Group: YUMMY BOMBOLONI!!!!

Serious EatsSerious Eats: Best Bomboloni: The one filled with vanilla pastry cream is our favorite, but the chunky caramelized apple and raspberry are excellent as well. Read more.

Bocca Di Bacco is one of The 9 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Hell's Kitchen, New York.

7. Bocca Di Bacco

8.0
635 9th Ave (btwn W 44th & W 45th St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 38 tips and reviews

Brad R.Brad Ritter: Got a grilled octopus starter and a lamb orichiette, both between 2 people and the were plenty and delicious. Couple with dessert and and (relatively) cheap montepulciano made for tasty dinner

Jeremy D.Jeremy Davis: Get the Bruschetta Ai Funghi to start. It. Does. Not. Disappoint.

Mandar M.Mandar M: Just wait for the free bread if you are ordering an entree, it comes with garlic tonatoes - you can make your own bruschetta!

Mama Mia 44sw Italian Cuisine is one of The 9 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Hell's Kitchen, New York.

8. Mama Mia 44sw Italian Cuisine

7.6
621 9th Ave, New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 12 tips and reviews

Greta H.Greta Hu: Love the calamari pasta here

Karmyn T.Karmyn Tyler: Great little spot. Yummy food. Usually crowded in the weekends.

Cyril S.Cyril S.: Great food but slow service

Don't Tell Mama is one of The 9 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Hell's Kitchen, New York.

9. Don't Tell Mama

7.8
343 W 46th St (btwn 8th & 9th Ave), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · Hell's Kitchen · 61 tips and reviews

Inman NewsInman News: One of the favorite places of the Inman Team to go to - love the piano bar and their martini's are the best!

Juan C.Juan Carrillo: There's a 2 drink minimum with every visitor. That's why they have no cover.

Juan V.Juan Vallejo: THE best place to sing in NYC!!!!