Arni's Restaurant is one of The 13 Best Places for Apple Pie in Indianapolis.

1. Arni's Restaurant

8.8
4705 E 96th St (at Brandt Rd), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Keystone at The Crossing · 41 tips and reviews

Alexander P.Alexander Pritchard: Personally we only go here for the apple pie. Everything else, other than the pizza, seems confused or of fast food quality... great service, however and a friendly environment!

Anita K.Anita Kerlin: Southern fried chicken salad with honey mustard. Be sure to get your garlic bread! Amazing!

Dustin W.Dustin Weber: Paige is the greatest server!

St. Elmo Steak House is one of The 13 Best Places for Apple Pie in Indianapolis.

2. St. Elmo Steak House

9.0
127 S Illinois St (btw Maryland St. & Georgia St.), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Downtown Indianapolis · 196 tips and reviews

Jennifer E.Jennifer Evans: Amazing dinner but come hungry! Loved the shrimp cocktail, ribeye steak and lobster mac n' cheese. Homemade apple pie was delicious!

PureWowPureWow: St. Elmo is especially famous for its shrimp cocktail, which comes out with great to-do-four jumbo shrimp, on ice, with a generous dollop of cocktail sauce. And the steak’s pretty epic, too. Read more.

Visit IndyVisit Indy: Shrimp Cocktail is amazing and the cocktails are even better. Try the Bloody Mary that is made with St. E's famous cocktail sauce!

Rocket Fizz is one of The 13 Best Places for Apple Pie in Indianapolis.

3. Rocket Fizz

8.9
52 Monument Cir, Indianapolis, IN
Candy Store · Downtown Indianapolis · 17 tips and reviews

Lydia B.Lydia Boyer: Really great place! Love it here!!!!

Jenna R.Jenna Renee: Best soda/candy selection in Indy!

Greg S.Greg Schmidt: More soda and candy than one knows what to do with! Very cool place!

Wheatleys is one of The 13 Best Places for Apple Pie in Indianapolis.

4. Wheatleys

8.2
8902 Southeastern Ave (Northeastern Ave.), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Wanamaker · 6 tips and reviews

Greg E.Greg Earle: I always enjoy the biscuits & gravy on the weekends.

Nora C.Nora Caguioa: The fish is awesome. The atmosphere comfortable. The carrot cake was the best I have had since my grandmas. Will definitely come again

Daniel G.Daniel Graves: Awesome as always! Great food at a good price! Gotta love supporting small businesses

Starbucks is one of The 13 Best Places for Apple Pie in Indianapolis.

5. Starbucks

7.8
4850 E Southport Rd, Indianapolis, IN
Coffee Shop · I65-South Emerson · No tips or reviews
Starbucks is one of The 13 Best Places for Apple Pie in Indianapolis.

6. Starbucks

7.5
1950 Kessler Boulevard West Dr, Indianapolis, IN
Coffee Shop · Crooked Creek · 15 tips and reviews

David D.David Dodson: Chris and Nate are the best! Ask for a Ritter WF hot chocolate !!!

Tom S.Tom Spalding: Tremendous asset to a neighborhood that lacked a community gathering pitstop.

Sara C.Sara C: Best customer service from any starbucks in Indianapolis

OAKLEYS bistro is one of The 13 Best Places for Apple Pie in Indianapolis.

7. OAKLEYS bistro

8.0
1464 W 86th St (at Ditch Rd), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · North Willow Farms · 15 tips and reviews

Chris D.Chris D.: The Chef's nook is a great option. Lobster waffles and 5 pickles were awesome for a starter.

Evelina E.Evelina Edmundson: Oakley's is always delicious! They need to add "dinner combos" which would include a nicely paired glass of wine

B Barnett @.B Barnett @notoriousb_o_b: Shrimp corndogs, Mac 'n goat cheese w/ pesto

Boston Market is one of The 13 Best Places for Apple Pie in Indianapolis.

8. Boston Market

7.5
7910 US 31 S, Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · 2 tips and reviews

Andrew A.Andrew Angle: Blockbuster Express & Boston Market have a special through 7/24/11. Buy food here & get a free movie rental.

Diane N.Diane Niccum: Check your receipt. When you buy a meal during the week, Saturday coupon for buy one meal get one free with purchase of a drink.

Huddle's Frozen Yogurt is one of The 13 Best Places for Apple Pie in Indianapolis.

9. Huddle's Frozen Yogurt

8.3
1356 E 86th St (at Monon Tr), Indianapolis, IN
Frozen Yogurt Shop · Nora - Far Northside · 43 tips and reviews

Mary B.Mary B.: Mango Tango is sooo good! Doesn't even need toppings!

JuliusJulius: Cake batter and Red Velvet cake are amazing

Amber S.Amber Shaverdi: Great yogurt flavor and fresh berries, yum!

Hollyhock Hill Restaurant is one of The 13 Best Places for Apple Pie in Indianapolis.

10. Hollyhock Hill Restaurant

7.8
8110 N College Ave (86th & Meridian St), Indianapolis, IN
Southern Food Restaurant · 17 tips and reviews

Tara P.Tara Puckey: Family style dining. Delicious biscuits! Read more.

Lauren B.Lauren Boxell: Indy's best kept secret by far! Chicken dinner without question!

Visit IndyVisit Indy: Comfort food at its finest. Hand-fried chicken, whipped potatoes and fresh biscuits topped with apple butter- need we say more?

Kip's Pub is one of The 13 Best Places for Apple Pie in Indianapolis.

11. Kip's Pub

7.2
9546 Allisonville Rd (Suite 110), Indianapolis, IN
Bar · Castleton · 15 tips and reviews

Steve H.Steve Hummel: Awesome place for darts, pool and poker. The food is very good as well

Whitney S.Whitney Seidman: Candice is a great sever here!

Dave R.Dave Riley: Join Gina for Karaoke on Tues from 10 til 2

Bob Evans Restaurant is one of The 13 Best Places for Apple Pie in Indianapolis.

12. Bob Evans Restaurant

7.3
4441 Southport Crossings Dr, Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · 11 tips and reviews

Kimberly B.Kimberly Brown: Love the wildfire chicken salad!

Modesto Z C.Modesto Z Caldera: Bob Evans Evansville IN *love their Breakfast Pancakes. *

DebraDebra: Bob Evans is a very good restaurant that use should want to go can't wait to eat here again

Weber Grill Restaurant is one of The 13 Best Places for Apple Pie in Indianapolis.

13. Weber Grill Restaurant

8.0
110 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 91 tips and reviews

Eric T.Eric Thomas: One of my favorite places to grab a burger for lunch... ample seating space but if you're flying solo or with just one friend grab a stool at the bar. Great service always.

David AllenDavid Allen: Always ask for a tall server!!

Yangzhi Z.Yangzhi Zhao: Our waiter was wasted...lol.