Flatwater Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish in Indianapolis.

1. Flatwater Restaurant

9.1
832 E Westfield Blvd (at IWC Canal Greenway), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Broad Ripple · 81 tips and reviews

Brian S.Brian S: Very nice little restaurant. The salmon sandwich was great and definitely try the Wedge salad

Jenny G.Jenny Goins: Pulled pork nachos and mahi mahi tacos are the way to go!

#1 Local#1 Local: Pork nachos, mahi mahi tacos and wurst app were all awesome!

Caplinger's Fresh Catch Seafood Market is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish in Indianapolis.

2. Caplinger's Fresh Catch Seafood Market

8.4
7460 N Shadeland Ave (75th), Indianapolis, IN
Seafood Restaurant · 16 tips and reviews

Mike John M.Mike John Mccoy: LOVE THE CATFISH

Steven R.Steven Ressler: A great place for fish lovers.

Tina C.Tina Cline: The fresh fish, shrimp cocktail, fried okra!!

Bakersfield Mass Ave is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish in Indianapolis.

3. Bakersfield Mass Ave

9.0
334 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Mexican Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 107 tips and reviews

Suzi E.Suzi Ensch: The taco are awesome!!!! Defiantly try the fish taco!!!! So good!!! While your there get a pitcher of margaritas!!! Great place to hang with friends!!!

Sarah G.Sarah Greenberg: Fish tacos are awesome!

James P.James Paden: Best tacos in town. Short rib and fish are my favorites.

Oceanaire Seafood Room is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish in Indianapolis.

4. Oceanaire Seafood Room

8.5
30 S Meridian St (btwn E Maryland St and E Washington St), Indianapolis, IN
Seafood Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 44 tips and reviews

Anastasia C.Anastasia Clarkson: Hawaiian Ahi Tuna -melts in your mouth

RL H.RL Hollowell-Bolding: The sour cream mashed potatoes are amazing! I hope, for your sake, the Lake Trout is on the fresh catch list - delightful (especially the chef's special prep)!

Ernie S.Ernie Smith: Best seafood restaraunt in the world. Amazing oysters, lobster, and fish. Amazing everything! Read more.

Aristocrat Pub & Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish in Indianapolis.

5. Aristocrat Pub & Restaurant

8.5
5212 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Pub · Meridian Kessler · 52 tips and reviews

Kate H.Kate Hayward: The new salad with grilled tuna is delicious, but be sure to request it rare with dressing in the side.

Kayla J.Kayla Johnson: Love the style, food, and service here. Fish and chips are amazing. My boyfriend always gets the pork tenderloin and its a beast! Never had a bad experience here. Large, good draught list.

DreDre: Friendly service, huge beer list and they even have a few ciders. I had the tuna sandwich and it was amazing

Chatham Tap is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish in Indianapolis.

6. Chatham Tap

8.6
719 Massachusetts Ave (at N Park Ave), Indianapolis, IN
Pub · Chatham Arch · 98 tips and reviews

Adam V.Adam VanOsdol: Indy's best Fish n' Chips

Mike B.Mike Boone: Best fish n' chips outside of the motherland. Top it off with a cold pint, and you've got yourself the best pub in Indy.

JR C.JR Chambers: The Wings w/house sauce ROCK! Fish n Chips are some of the best in Indy too!

Harry & Izzy's is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish in Indianapolis.

7. Harry & Izzy's

9.1
153 S Illinois St (at W Georgia St in Circle Centre Mall), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Downtown Indianapolis · 109 tips and reviews

Chris B.Chris Borland: The Filet was awesome. I liked the potato pancakes. The shrimp cocktail and seared tuna is incredible. Be careful the shrimp cocktail sauce will burn the hairs out of your nose. Read more.

Sean M.Sean Molin: Possibly the best fish 'n chips in town. Hard to bring myself to get them when there's such an epic prime rib sandwich on the same menu, though.

India J.India Johnson: The blackened catfish was great...spicy but awesome!!!

Nine Irish Brothers is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish in Indianapolis.

8. Nine Irish Brothers

8.5
575 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Irish Pub · Downtown Indianapolis · 21 tips and reviews

Sean M.Sean Molin: Shepard's Pie, Guinness beef stew, fish 'n chips, spicy mussels. Can't go wrong.

Dana P.Dana Parker: Fish and chips, a real ploughman's lunch, and the best bread pudding all make this a great new addition. Try the Trojan Horse, Guinness and Coca Cola!

SarahSarah: Tasty fish and chips. The shepherd's pie is delicious, too!

Red Lion Grog House is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish in Indianapolis.

9. Red Lion Grog House

8.5
1043 Virginia Ave (in the G. C. Murphy Building), Indianapolis, IN
Pub · Fountain Square · 63 tips and reviews

Jeremy W.Jeremy Williams: The Fish & Chips are great. Be sure to order a side of the spicy curry sauce, it's awesome.

Tina H.Tina Hooven: Fish & Chips are awesome!

Chris S.Chris Smith: Salmon patty hit the spot, tots are always a good choice, made me a great Bloody Mary, and I have to try both Grogs next time!

Seasons 52 is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish in Indianapolis.

10. Seasons 52

8.9
8650 Keystone Xing, Indianapolis, IN
New American Restaurant · Keystone at The Crossing · 48 tips and reviews

Nathan M.Nathan Medley: The tuna in the sushi and Maui Tuna Salad is great!

John C.John Currens: Best wine selection. Go with the fish tacos.

Brigitte M.Brigitte Mills: Grilled trout entree was not only nutritious but very tasty also. Pomegranite martini fantastic!

Fire by the Monon is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish in Indianapolis.

11. Fire by the Monon

8.1
6523 Ferguson St (at E Coil St), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Broad Ripple · 52 tips and reviews

Emily R.Emily Richardson: New Management. Love the pork nachos and fish tacos. Everyone is friendly here. Love this place!!

StefanieStefanie: Fish tacos are amazing!

Conor B.Conor Byron: Great fish tacos. Lunch time is pretty low-key for a quick in and out.

Tomo Japanese Steak House & Sushi Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish in Indianapolis.

12. Tomo Japanese Steak House & Sushi Bar

8.3
7411 N Keystone Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Japanese Restaurant · 36 tips and reviews

Olivia D.Olivia DePaulis: Great place to have a birthday party! I recommend the spicy tuna roll it's one of the best I've had.

Mick W.Mick Welling: Spicy Cajun Salmon Roll ... It's not on the menu, it's a Chef's Special. ASK FOR IT, you won't be sorry!

Versha S.Versha Sharma: get the spicy girl roll - one of the best rolls I've ever had!! spicy salmon inside, spicy tuna on top, sooo gooood.

Indy Tacos is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish in Indianapolis.

13. Indy Tacos

8.4
2196 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN
Taco Restaurant · 9 tips and reviews

Cameron D.Cameron Dershem: They're nearly authentic and vegetarian friendly. Plus they just got some wonderful fish tacos. Might be a bit of a wait, they might close early, or they might run out of some things...But it's solid.

Brent S.Brent Sutton: Fish Tacos!

Zach S.Zach Steiner: Fish tacos are a must try.

Wheatleys is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish in Indianapolis.

14. Wheatleys

7.9
8902 Southeastern Ave (Northeastern Ave.), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Wanamaker · 6 tips and reviews

James L.James Land: Best fish in indy

Dean M.Dean M: Great fish fry.

Nora C.Nora Caguioa: The fish is awesome. The atmosphere comfortable. The carrot cake was the best I have had since my grandmas. Will definitely come again

Cheddar's Scratch Kitchen is one of The 15 Best Places for Fish in Indianapolis.

15. Cheddar's Scratch Kitchen

8.0
5151 Noggle Way, Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · 23 tips and reviews

Keith J.Keith Jones: Good food, nice atmosphere. Cool fish tanks.

AnitaAnita: Cajun grilled catfish very good. Prices reasonable. Service slow

William O.William Oliver: Fried Catfish is Delicious