Flatwater Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Mahi Mahi in Indianapolis.

1. Flatwater Restaurant

9.2
832 E Westfield Blvd (at IWC Canal Greenway), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Broad Ripple · 81 tips and reviews

Randall E.Randall Ells: Get the Mahi Mahi tacos!

Jenny G.Jenny Goins: Pulled pork nachos and mahi mahi tacos are the way to go!

Ty M.Ty Morton: Try the Mahi Mahi Tacos

P.F. Chang's is one of The 15 Best Places for Mahi Mahi in Indianapolis.

2. P.F. Chang's

8.2
8601 Keystone Crossing (at E 86th St), Indianapolis, IN
Chinese Restaurant · Keystone at The Crossing · 50 tips and reviews

Keeth D.Keeth DeMers: Pretty pumped about the First Time Check-in Special! Get the Mahi Mahi!

Sarah O.Sarah Oliver: The spring rolls are great and the dessert shooters are the perfect sweet bite to end your meal. Try the red velvet cake shooter!!

Andy @.Andy @hust0058: Two words: lettuce wraps

Bonefish Grill is one of The 15 Best Places for Mahi Mahi in Indianapolis.

3. Bonefish Grill

7.7
4501 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN
Seafood Restaurant · 38 tips and reviews

Matthew G.Matthew Grosebeck: The Bang Bang shrimp is amazing and so is the Mahi Mahi!!

Craig H.Craig Holloway: Lobster Rangoon! That's all you need to know.

Omar H.Omar Habayeb: The Swordfish with Pumpkin Ravioli is Outstanding!

Love Handle is one of The 15 Best Places for Mahi Mahi in Indianapolis.

4. Love Handle

7.2
877 Massachusetts Ave (College), Indianapolis, IN
Comfort Food Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 9 tips and reviews

Jon B.Jon B.: Sampled the sweetbreads and mahi mahi sandwiches, and they were excellent.

Joel S.Joel Smith: Earnest and delicious. Love Handle brings heart to its creative and delicious fare. I loved the Pork Belly Biscuits and Gravy.

Jesse W.Jesse Wright: New location! Next to ‘Quality’ same side as YATS! Pop in, it’s great!

Kona Jack's is one of The 15 Best Places for Mahi Mahi in Indianapolis.

5. Kona Jack's

8.6
9419 N Meridian St (in Meridian North Shopping Center), Indianapolis, IN
Sushi Restaurant · Nora - Far Northside · 18 tips and reviews

ʇʇoɔs ɹ.ʇʇoɔs ɹolʎɐʇ: Very filling, very delicious - great service and atmosphere. I'll be back :)

Noah S.Noah Swint: Great food, fast service and great atmosphere. All food was made from scratch and the Romano Herb Bread with Macadamia Nut butter was superb.

Bob S.Bob St Claire: Very good selection of seafood, preparations conservative but delicious. A bit pricey, particularly for lunch.

Taylor's Pub at Greenbriar is one of The 15 Best Places for Mahi Mahi in Indianapolis.

6. Taylor's Pub at Greenbriar

8.6
1325 W 86th St (at Ditch Rd.), Indianapolis, IN
Pub · St. Vincent - Greenbriar · 16 tips and reviews

Leslie C.Leslie C: Great place to bring a group and have parties. Come early on Friday nights to get a good spot on the patio.

Leslie C.Leslie C: Ask for Miss Leslie for the best service of your life!

☠Bill C.☠Bill Cesavice☠: Tip well, the staff deserves it.

Sakura is one of The 15 Best Places for Mahi Mahi in Indianapolis.

7. Sakura

8.8
7201 N Keystone Ave (71st St.), Indianapolis, IN
Sushi Restaurant · 39 tips and reviews

Stephanie D.Stephanie Daily: The Rock n Roll, Spicy Tura Roll, Shrimp Tempura - YUMM!

Adrienne S.Adrienne Strange: Softshell crab is bomb!

Tim W.Tim Wilsbach: The Rock N Roll is the most delicious roll you will find anywhere. You must order one.

Taylor's Pub at Nora is one of The 15 Best Places for Mahi Mahi in Indianapolis.

8. Taylor's Pub at Nora

7.7
1546 E 86th St (at Westfield Blvd.), Indianapolis, IN
Pub · Nora - Far Northside · 8 tips and reviews

tobias s.tobias smith: Go see Grace on Sunday nights!

Robin G.Robin Gilmour: Good Luck Jodie on your new adventures in school. I will miss your smile and your A+ customer service. Robin G.

Shan P.Shan Parker: The breaded tenderloin and fries are awesome here!

Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Mahi Mahi in Indianapolis.

9. Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant

9.2
3815 E 96th St (bt Priority Way W Dr & Delegates Row), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Keystone at The Crossing · 77 tips and reviews

Dameatrice M.Dameatrice M.: Pair your meal with the suggested wine, you will love it!

Andy @.Andy @hust0058: Drink what you like. Good suggested pairings in the menu. Try the calamari. You can order wine from a barrel! And it's great!

Patti B.Patti Bostwick: Love the Peach Sangria

Loughmiller's Pub & Eatery is one of The 15 Best Places for Mahi Mahi in Indianapolis.

10. Loughmiller's Pub & Eatery

7.4
301 W Washington St (Senate), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 28 tips and reviews

Mary Lloyd B.Mary Lloyd Barbera: The ultimate stuffed grilled cheese and fries were great!!

Qatadah N.Qatadah Nasaaj: Go for the Skillet burger!!! Angus beef & cheesy chilli on sourdough. Mmmm... (WARNING)Not using a fork on it,is not an option.

Chanda G.Chanda Glover: Their burgers taste so fresh you'd swear they slaughtered the cow that morning.

Oceanaire Seafood Room is one of The 15 Best Places for Mahi Mahi in Indianapolis.

11. Oceanaire Seafood Room

8.2
30 S Meridian St (btwn E Maryland St and E Washington St), Indianapolis, IN
Seafood Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 44 tips and reviews

Ernie S.Ernie Smith: Unbelievably wonderful food! Great for business parties or guests, or for an anniversary. Oceanaire is probably the best seafood restaraunt I have ever eaten at. Enjoy!! Read more.

Jessica B.Jessica Brown: Order the Chocolate Mousse!

John K.John Kinder: Have bartender Jessica make a 'Fresca' substituting Death's Door White Whisky for tequila. You'll be glad you did.

Rick's Cafe Boatyard is one of The 15 Best Places for Mahi Mahi in Indianapolis.

12. Rick's Cafe Boatyard

8.8
4050 Dandy Trl (at W 38th St), Indianapolis, IN
Seafood Restaurant · Eagle Creek · 72 tips and reviews

Mike K.Mike Kivett: #1 place in Indy for a fun night out. Great food and drinks on the deck overlooking Eagle Creek.

Paula H.Paula Henry: Best Calamari I have ever had. Always a nice escape for a weekday lunch with views of Eagle Creek.

Rachel H.Rachel Harrell: Request Rach H. If you tip BIG. Request Grey if you don't tip at all!! :p

Smee's Place is one of The 15 Best Places for Mahi Mahi in Indianapolis.

13. Smee's Place

7.5
1454 W 86th St (Ditch), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · North Willow Farms · 17 tips and reviews

Chad F.Chad Feaster: Ribs, sweet potato fries, and onion rings are amazing. Great service, delicious food, and large menu choice

Brenda M.Brenda Marino: Best Pork Tenderloin & Grouper Sandwich ever !! Janet is the most wonderful waitress - they make us feel like family !! Supper jewel - don't pass it by !

Michele G.Michele GretchCarter: Everything here is good! The service is always top notch! Should be your favorite hang out.

Saffron Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Mahi Mahi in Indianapolis.

14. Saffron Cafe

7.7
621 Fort Wayne Ave (at E. North St.), Indianapolis, IN
Moroccan Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 26 tips and reviews

Reneta T.Reneta Thurairatnam: Definitely start with the Atay. Bastilla is a great app if you're looking for savory and sweet. Definitely try a tajine. I recommend lamb. Finish with baklava. Do NOT get the tiramisu. You're welcome.

Jeff M.Jeff McQuary: The bastilla is a dessert-like appetizer that is different and delicious.

Jake M.Jake Miller: Order the ginger chicken Tajine and make sure you dip your break in the sauce! Delicious! 5 stars.

Skyline Club is one of The 15 Best Places for Mahi Mahi in Indianapolis.

15. Skyline Club

7.4
1 American Square, 36th Floor, Indianapolis, IN
Lounge · Downtown Indianapolis · 15 tips and reviews

Kendall Elise H.Kendall Elise Horvatich: The side rooms are great for meetings, and the buffet always has a great verity.

Satyen J.Satyen Jhaveri: Great staff! Ask for Jamie, Cezar or Alyssa. Beth is a great bartender. Mark and his team do a great job!!

Serina K.Serina Kelly: What a great place for meetings, trainings and an office outside the office! Food is great! Try the black bean soup-yummy!!