Eddie Merlot's is one of The 11 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Indianapolis.

1. Eddie Merlot's

8.4
3645 E 96th St (at E Advisory Way), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Keystone at The Crossing · 20 tips and reviews

Kraig P.Kraig Parkinson: Filet mignon was the best I had in Indianapolis. The peanut butter cup dessert is delicious!

SarahSarah: Went for my birthday with my best friend with a Groupon type thing from Costco. I tried the New Orleans Mixed Grill, which was a treat. My friend got truffle fries as her side and they were delicious.

Eddie M.Eddie Merlot's: Our specialties are prime aged beef and seafood. Let us know how we can serve you!

Cold Stone Creamery is one of The 11 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Indianapolis.

2. Cold Stone Creamery

8.7
5025 E 82nd St, Ste 400, Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Parlor · 5 tips and reviews

Lindsay G.Lindsay Goodwin: The Founder's Favorite is my favorite, too!

Tiffanie B.Tiffanie Bridges: Coffee Lover's Only is a dream!!

Katie C.Katie Chancey: Founders favorite with cake batter Ice cream. The best

Red Line Frozen Treats is one of The 11 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Indianapolis.

3. Red Line Frozen Treats

7.1
5920 E Stop 11 Rd (Arlington & Stop 11), Indianapolis, IN
Frozen Yogurt Shop · 3 tips and reviews

Becky H.Becky H.: The Peanut Butter Cup is delicious!

Keith J.Keith Jones: Orange sorbet was great for is lactose intolerant types.

Katie H.Katie Hughes: Oh wow great stuff! Much better than better Leaf!

Dairy Queen is one of The 11 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Indianapolis.

4. Dairy Queen

8.1
7116 N Keystone Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Parlor · 9 tips and reviews

James Trèvis B.James Trèvis Boyd Jr.: Great food and Service! Yummm caramel NUT ROLLLLLL.

Lance R.Lance Rinker: Fast & friendly service. That & the new $5 mini blizzard meal deal made for one of the best fast food experiences of my life!

Lylene M.Lylene Mason: The new cotton candy blizzard is probably one of the tastiest things to ever touch my lips. Awesome!

Baskin-Robbins is one of The 11 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Indianapolis.

5. Baskin-Robbins

7.9
1337 W 86th St, Greenbriar Shopping Center, Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Parlor · St. Vincent - Greenbriar · 4 tips and reviews

Douglas M.Douglas Meissel: Love the Pralines and cream! Yum yum!

Mckenzie H.Mckenzie Hamilton: There cookie dough ice cream with a cone 👅👅👅

Carol J.Carol James: Pralines and Cream - the very best!

Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant is one of The 11 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Indianapolis.

6. Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant

9.1
3815 E 96th St (bt Priority Way W Dr & Delegates Row), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Keystone at The Crossing · 77 tips and reviews

Ed M.Ed Meckes: Get the Trio of Medallions and Barrel Reserve. This place is better than Disney World.!

Andy @.Andy @hust0058: Drink what you like. Good suggested pairings in the menu. Try the calamari. You can order wine from a barrel! And it's great!

Patti B.Patti Bostwick: Love the Peach Sangria

Huddle's Frozen Yogurt is one of The 11 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Indianapolis.

7. Huddle's Frozen Yogurt

8.3
1356 E 86th St (at Monon Tr), Indianapolis, IN
Frozen Yogurt Shop · Nora - Far Northside · 43 tips and reviews

Mary B.Mary B.: Mango Tango is sooo good! Doesn't even need toppings!

JuliusJulius: Cake batter and Red Velvet cake are amazing

Amber S.Amber Shaverdi: Great yogurt flavor and fresh berries, yum!

The Cheesecake Factory is one of The 11 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Indianapolis.

8. The Cheesecake Factory

8.4
8701 Keystone Xing Ste 4A (at E 86th St), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Keystone at The Crossing · 94 tips and reviews

Stan O.Stan Olson: Chicken and biscuits are amazing! Way too much food though! (Must save room for dessert!)

Jake G.Jake Greenfield: Best cheese cake in the world!

Givannivan S.Givannivan Saunders: This is the actual factory. The machines here milk the cows for the cheese and kill the dessert fiends for cake.

Dairy Queen is one of The 11 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Indianapolis.

9. Dairy Queen

7.3
3826 English Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Parlor · Christian Park · 3 tips and reviews

David M.David Mayo: Footling Hotdog with cheese, relish, onion and mustard is really good.

Carrie H.Carrie H.: Pecan cluster blizzard with butterscotch cone dip mixed in instead of chocolate!

Kris R.Kris Reed: Oreo blizzard with extra oreos so yummy!!!!

Bob Evans Restaurant is one of The 11 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Indianapolis.

10. Bob Evans Restaurant

7.1
4441 Southport Crossings Dr, Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · 11 tips and reviews

Kimberly B.Kimberly Brown: Love the wildfire chicken salad!

Modesto Z C.Modesto Z Caldera: Bob Evans Evansville IN *love their Breakfast Pancakes. *

DebraDebra: Bob Evans is a very good restaurant that use should want to go can't wait to eat here again

Baskin-Robbins is one of The 11 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Indianapolis.

11. Baskin-Robbins

7.2
2201 E 62nd St Ste B, Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Parlor · Broad Ripple · 4 tips and reviews

Baskin-Robbins B.Baskin-Robbins Broad-Ripple: We are on Winter hours now, Sunday thru Thursday 11 AM till 9 PM and Fri and Saturday 11 AM till 10 PM

Trudy H.Trudy Honey: Great service here, and the ice cream isn't bad either :))

SaraSara: They have great Oreo cookies n creme milkshakes!