Changing Times is one of The 15 Best Places for Celery in Islip.

1. Changing Times

7.6
29 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY
Sports Bar · 20 tips and reviews

James F.James Ferguson: Don't get the lobster roll. They add onions and celery and hardly any lobster.

George R.George Raab: Best bar/sports bar im bay shore. Always a good time. The bartenders are great and sociable. I always have a great times

SamanthaSamantha: Thursday is ladies night !!! $2 mix drinks and $2 buds -- the perks of having a vagina...

Mulberry Street is one of The 15 Best Places for Celery in Islip.

2. Mulberry Street

8.7
192 Howells Rd, Bay Shore, NY
Italian Restaurant · 8 tips and reviews

Tom C.Tom C.: Awesome food, not expensive, always an open table, polite people. Check em out.

Andra M.Andra Matera: All the pizza and if you eat the restaurant style food good plus great portions. Can make 2 meals from 1.

Bill Mary Seymour M.Bill Mary Seymour Martini: Alfredo sauce :-)

The Cheesecake Factory is one of The 15 Best Places for Celery in Islip.

3. The Cheesecake Factory

8.5
1701 Sunrise Hwy Westfield South Shore, Bay Shore, NY
American Restaurant · 8 tips and reviews

Arnold M.Arnold Marmol: Everything we had was really good ,the nachos is excellent and big

Daniel W.Daniel W: White bean chili and that white raspberry cheesecake. Yes!

john r.john rossiello: Food was right on point as usual but it's the first time I dined in house and I hope tonight's service isn't indicative of the overall staff. They somehow forgot about us and brought wrong entree.

The Garage is one of The 15 Best Places for Celery in Islip.

4. The Garage

8.1
170 Bridge Rd, Islandia, NY
Sandwich Spot · 6 tips and reviews

Renee B.Renee Barnes: They have a fabulous Denver omelet with a side of home fries. Everything I've purchased has been delicious. I recommend them for breakfast or lunch. You can eat in or take out.

Liza B.Liza Bullen: Good food great prices.

Jeff F.Jeff F: Ok good. Beyond over priced. Go sparingly. When just in that mood go overpriced food

Frank & Maria's Italian Pork Store is one of The 15 Best Places for Celery in Islip.

5. Frank & Maria's Italian Pork Store

8.1
10 W Main St (at 4th Ave), Bay Shore, NY
Italian Restaurant · 7 tips and reviews

P. D.P. D.: As good an Italian grocery and deli as you'll find in New York City. Tucked into Bay Shore without nearly the noteriety it deserves. Mozzarella at the register is warm to the touch; that's how fresh!

Erin S.Erin Shaw: The eggplant lasagna is delicious!

Frank and Marias F.Frank and Marias Frank and Marias: Frank and Marias

The Sayville Inn is one of The 15 Best Places for Celery in Islip.

6. The Sayville Inn

7.7
199 Middle Rd, Sayville, NY
American Restaurant · 6 tips and reviews

Michael Z.Michael Z: Two things you can count on being delicious....the burgers, and anything on the specials board.

KeriKeri: Great baja tacos!

🎃Sam M.🎃Sam Murphy🎃: My dads an awesome chef here :)

Jackson Hall American Bar & Grille is one of The 15 Best Places for Celery in Islip.

7. Jackson Hall American Bar & Grille

8.0
335 E Main St, East Islip, NY
American Restaurant · 7 tips and reviews

Angelique P.Angelique P: Rainbow cookie martini hits the spot, sweet but great!

TaraTara: Love this place......best food ever when you go get the penne with chicken, spinach, and mozzerella in a pink cream sauce it's like eating heaven : D

Alexandra M.Alexandra Mendes: Delicious food and reasonably priced, also really fun drink menu!

Panera Bread is one of The 15 Best Places for Celery in Islip.

8. Panera Bread

8.0
1701 Sunrise Hwy Unit A16, Bay Shore, NY
Bakery · 14 tips and reviews

Marcus P.Marcus Pierre: Chai is great! However, you may need a bathroom close by part of the day. Worth it!

Wilfred T.Wilfred TR: The BearClaw is sinfully good

Erik K.Erik Kortright: Bread bowl chicken noodle soup is awesome

Mamma Lombardi's is one of The 15 Best Places for Celery in Islip.

9. Mamma Lombardi's

8.2
877 Main St, Holbrook, NY
Italian Restaurant · 22 tips and reviews

RoseAnne F.RoseAnne Foxx: This a great local Italian restaurant with A pizza restaurant attached. Which is 2nd to Gino's as far as pizza. BUT...a good wine list with some great California wines..attentive staff. Ask for Dan.

Lou C.Lou Capezza: Just smelling the food makes me full.

Megan S.Megan Splain: Amazing hot food bar... Whole wheat pasta is yummy! Best eggplant parm around!

Kingston's Clam Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Celery in Islip.

10. Kingston's Clam Bar

8.0
130 Atlantic Ave (Montauk Hwy.), West Sayville, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 17 tips and reviews

Stu C.Stu Chamberlain: Best-kept secret in town. Worth discovering!

Denise F.Denise Federico: Great food

Ryan D.Ryan D: Clam strips!

La Tavola is one of The 15 Best Places for Celery in Islip.

11. La Tavola

7.9
183 W Main St (Greeley Ave.), Sayville, NY
Italian Restaurant · 27 tips and reviews

Veronica B.Veronica Button: Anything here is amazing. Dont be shy. Eat everything.

Matt M.Matt Martin: The Mussels are to die for!!!

Michele F.Michele Falcone: Monday through Friday at the bar: happy hour + $5 appetizers.

Albert's Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Celery in Islip.

12. Albert's Pizza

7.6
676 Motor Pkwy Ste E, Hauppauge, NY
Pizzeria · 3 tips and reviews

Eye M.Eye Muffler: Best garlic knots and you get one free with your slice if dining in.

MattMatt: Worst pizza of all time.

Eye M.Eye Muffler: This place has changed for the better 100% with this staff in comparson to two years ago. Great food. They are killing it.

Cornucopia Natural Foods is one of The 15 Best Places for Celery in Islip.

13. Cornucopia Natural Foods

7.7
39 N Main St, Sayville, NY
Grocery Store · 11 tips and reviews

Maria S.Maria Simonetti: Delicious 3 salad choice for $8.99. Amazing!

Tom M.Tom Murray: Sandwich is overpriced, but everything else there seems great.

Ian W.Ian Wilder: Salmon is yummy. Pre-made green salads are great.

Captain Bill's is one of The 15 Best Places for Celery in Islip.

14. Captain Bill's

7.7
122 Ocean Ave, Bay Shore, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 15 tips and reviews

Cynthia J.Cynthia J: Go for the brunch special. The shrimp is amazing! For dessert don't miss out on the rice pudding. Simply the best! Fabulous brunch... How can you go wrong with UNLIMITED Mimosas?!!!

Tim O.Tim ORourke: Excellent clams and oysters

Michelle F.Michelle F: Ok so the dinner was delicious, the appetizers were small but expensive. Entrees are great and plentiful. But they had a new desert guy and the deserts were really cold!!!!

New Idle Hour Deli is one of The 15 Best Places for Celery in Islip.

15. New Idle Hour Deli

7.5
1500 Montauk Hwy, Oakdale, NY
Deli · 6 tips and reviews

Mark H.Mark Heyert: Homemade Baked goods! The homemade coffee cake and brownies are wonderful! There are also great homemade desserts including Rice pudding. The hot entrées are freshly prepared. Highly recommended!

SeanSean: There egg sandwiches are the best in the area

John P.John P: Get the half and halfs!!