Mediterranean Express is one of The 15 Best Places for Greek Salad in Islip.

1. Mediterranean Express

8.6
625 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY
Greek Restaurant · 15 tips and reviews

James S.James Scully: Greek salad with grilled chicken or Gyro is very good

Anonie A.Anonie Anonnon: The Gyros here are amazing. The Greek salad is too. Also a big fan of their stuffed grape leaves

Melissa E.Melissa Easler-Casillas: Everything is great here but if you like sweets try the chocolate chip baklava its awesome

Peter Pan Diner is one of The 15 Best Places for Greek Salad in Islip.

2. Peter Pan Diner

8.1
854 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY
Diner · 31 tips and reviews

Courtenay B.Courtenay B💋: The greek salad and wrap are the best! Love the jumbo burgers. Curly fries are awesome. Cole slaw is yummy. Love the gyros. They give you plenty of food. Ugh food is just so tasty!

Jessica P.Jessica Palladino: Burgers are delicious, get the deluxe because the cole slaw is the best!

Tim B.Tim B: Ask for Marsha....

Parkway Rotisserie & Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Greek Salad in Islip.

3. Parkway Rotisserie & Pizza

7.7
658 Motor Pkwy (Washington Ave), Hauppauge, NY
Pizzeria · 10 tips and reviews

James H.James Hackett: Best lunch spot around, try the greek salad with chicken.

Mike S.Mike Seilback: The Greek food here is great- salads, gyros, souvlaki

Cheech💫Cheech💫: Service sucks. Called in an order over an hour ago. The driver got lost and didn't even call to ask where we were. When we called back, we were told another 30 minutes for delivery. No bueno.

Aegean Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Greek Salad in Islip.

4. Aegean Cafe

7.8
35 Main St, Sayville, NY
Greek Restaurant · 6 tips and reviews

Tom M.Tom Murray: Great gyros. Greek Salad is good too but doesn't have peppers in it.

Joanne C.Joanne Carlos: Fried zucchini with scordalia dip is awesome! I can have that with side gyro as a meal :)

Vincent F.Vincent Fuori: Very good authentic Greek. Gyro is the best outside NYC!

Nickys On The Bay is one of The 15 Best Places for Greek Salad in Islip.

5. Nickys On The Bay

7.4
Bayshore Marina, Bay Shore, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 10 tips and reviews

Electra B.Electra Bennett: very good greek salad with shrimp

Susan S.Susan S.: The mussels in the white wine sauce were so good! They give you a lot of bread for dipping in the sauce! The Moscow mule was really nice too.

Sara E.Sara Elizabeth: The calamari is awesome!

Mulberry Street is one of The 15 Best Places for Greek Salad in Islip.

6. Mulberry Street

8.9
192 Howells Rd, Bay Shore, NY
Italian Restaurant · 8 tips and reviews

Raffaela S.Raffaela Scaffa: Food is amazing. Great dishes. Great prices.

Andra M.Andra Matera: All the pizza and if you eat the restaurant style food good plus great portions. Can make 2 meals from 1.

Bill Mary Seymour M.Bill Mary Seymour Martini: Alfredo sauce :-)

White Cap Fish is one of The 15 Best Places for Greek Salad in Islip.

7. White Cap Fish

8.6
130 Main St, Islip, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 7 tips and reviews

Jake C.Jake Cohen: Great old school dockside fish joint and market. Raw or cooked they have it.

Alexandra M.Alexandra Martignette: Long Island chowder is to die for

Ulonda J.Ulonda Jemmott: The fried soft shell crab sandwich is absolutely amazing!

Tula Kitchen is one of The 15 Best Places for Greek Salad in Islip.

8. Tula Kitchen

8.9
41 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · 22 tips and reviews

Maggie A.Maggie Arroyo: The food is excellent, the service is top notch and the atmosphere is swank. What more could you want?

Michelle d.Michelle dammit: Great bar!

Jacqulyne D.Jacqulyne Dimartino: Wonderful atmosphere...and great food the chicken is moist and fresh also the veggies were rich in flavor defiantly recommend everyone to come hear plus the staff is amazing always smiling and nice

Pie At Salvatore's is one of The 15 Best Places for Greek Salad in Islip.

9. Pie At Salvatore's

8.3
120 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY
Italian Restaurant · 9 tips and reviews

April S.April Scarduzio: I've had a lot of pizza and this is by far the best! All their other food is great as well.

Steve F.Steve Fog: Best pizza in Bay Shore.

GinaGina: The filleto is worth the 30 minute drive to get here from our house. Not to mention the pizza is the best I've ever had.

Bright Bay Deli & Caterers is one of The 15 Best Places for Greek Salad in Islip.

10. Bright Bay Deli & Caterers

8.1
180 Howells Rd, Bay Shore, NY
Deli · 5 tips and reviews

Leon G.Leon Gurinsky: They have hardy sandwiches and their food is fresh and good!

Keith P.Keith Palazzolo: Have a egg sandwich on a bagel.

Steve F.Steve Fog: Breakfast is great

La Tavola is one of The 15 Best Places for Greek Salad in Islip.

11. La Tavola

8.3
183 W Main St (Greeley Ave.), Sayville, NY
Italian Restaurant · 27 tips and reviews

Rich W.Rich Waters: The service, the food, the ambiance--it's all incredible! Everyone is awesome and everything on the menu is stellar! Never do they ever fail to impress!

Matt M.Matt Martin: The Mussels are to die for!!!

Michele F.Michele Falcone: Monday through Friday at the bar: happy hour + $5 appetizers.

The Garage is one of The 15 Best Places for Greek Salad in Islip.

12. The Garage

8.1
170 Bridge Rd, Islandia, NY
Sandwich Spot · 6 tips and reviews

Neils O.Neils Olesen: Great vibe, feels like they're still paying for the decor but Boars Head pizza toppings are an amazing touch. Great staff, recommended.

Renee B.Renee Barnes: They have a fabulous Denver omelet with a side of home fries. Everything I've purchased has been delicious. I recommend them for breakfast or lunch. You can eat in or take out.

Liza B.Liza Bullen: Good food great prices.

Fratelli Pizzaria is one of The 15 Best Places for Greek Salad in Islip.

13. Fratelli Pizzaria

7.9
553 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY
Pizzeria · 8 tips and reviews

Craig Peter LowCraig Peter Low: The traditional Italian pizza (margherita) in the best around!

Mike K.Mike Kaiser: Frank makes the best buffalo chicken slice

Daniel M.Daniel Maksym: The food is terrible. The pizza is tasteless and, no matter what time of day you go in, all of the pizzas look DAYS old. Yuck.

Frank & Maria's Italian Pork Store is one of The 15 Best Places for Greek Salad in Islip.

14. Frank & Maria's Italian Pork Store

8.0
10 W Main St (at 4th Ave), Bay Shore, NY
Italian Restaurant · 7 tips and reviews

Dustin R.Dustin Ress: Olive oil is the best around. Dry aged steaks are to die for!!!

Erin S.Erin Shaw: The eggplant lasagna is delicious!

P. D.P. D.: As good an Italian grocery and deli as you'll find in New York City. Tucked into Bay Shore without nearly the noteriety it deserves. Mozzarella at the register is warm to the touch; that's how fresh!

Cafe Joelle is one of The 15 Best Places for Greek Salad in Islip.

15. Cafe Joelle

7.6
25 Main St, Sayville, NY
Café · 11 tips and reviews

Chris P.Chris Pinola: The calamari appetizer with sesame seeds and General Tso's sauce is incredibly unique and very good.

Long Island Restaurant WeekLong Island Restaurant Week: The First Spring Long Island Restaurant Week 2011 is April 3 -10. Come here to enjoy a 3-course prix fixe for $24.95. See other participants or make a reservation at www.longislandrestaurantweek.com.

DAVIDO A.DAVIDO ANYHONY: Ordered the CHEESE TORTELLINI, it was exceptionally very good, coming from an Italian boy. Highly Recommend.