El Siboney Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic in Key West.

1. El Siboney Restaurant

8.9
900 Catherine St (Margaret St.), Key West, FL
Cuban Restaurant · 142 tips and reviews

Amber D.Amber DeBevec: I always get the #31, half a grilled garlic chicken. Everything is big enough to split! Thursday is BBQ beef ribs, gone by 2:00. For dessert try the natilla.

Kate R.Kate Ritchie: Had their garlic shrimp (like a super fresh and tangy scampi) and split portions bc it's more than enough for two. When the local police are eating there. U know it's good:0)

Caroline H.Caroline H: Great food (we had the garlic shrimp and grilled snapper), great sangria, and great service.

New York Pasta Garden is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic in Key West.

2. New York Pasta Garden

8.4
1075 Duval St, Key West, FL
Italian Restaurant · 53 tips and reviews

Zach D.Zach Davis: Huge portions! Fantastic garlic bread tools with Parmesan and chopped garlic. Dwayne is a cool guy is is ready to answer your questions about the food or Key West in general.

Sydney E.Sydney E: Great ambience and service. Great wine price by the glass for delicious house wine. The garlic butter bread they being out first is amazing. Tomato Napoleon absolutely superb.

Marcel P.Marcel P.: addictingly good garlic bread (!!!), friendly staff, nice ambience, but be careful, portions are really huge!

Big John's Pizza, Pasta & Subs is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic in Key West.

3. Big John's Pizza, Pasta & Subs

7.4
1103 Key Plz (Roosevelt & 13th), Key West, FL
Italian Restaurant · 10 tips and reviews

Chelsey F.Chelsey Fallin: The garlic knots are amazing! :)

Victoria E.Victoria Elizabeth: Garlic Knots! They are the best thing I have ever had here!

Randall B.Randall Beggs: Very pleasant seating and surroundings. Extensive menu. Pizza by the slice is really good,

Salute! is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic in Key West.

4. Salute!

8.1
1000 Atlantic Blvd, Key West, FL
American Restaurant · 74 tips and reviews

Mark H.Mark Hendrix: Always check the specials! The seafood pasta in a garlic butter sauce was so good today!

Dolores G.Dolores Gutierrez: Mussels in garlic and butter sauce on top of a bed of linguine,

BobbyBobby: Go for the stone crab claws served with a key lime mustard sauce. Don’t forget the key lime pie!

Café Solé is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic in Key West.

5. Café Solé

8.1
1029 Southard St, Key West, FL
Café · 22 tips and reviews

Paula B.Paula Bendfeldt-Diaz: Quiet and romantic. Try the hog fish, the bacon wrapped garlic stuffed dates and the duck, all are delicious! ! Our server Mike was knowledgeable and entertaining, truly outstanding service!

Scott R.Scott Rudd: Angels on Horseback, roasted beet salad, hog fish & chocolate soufflé were all amazing. Ask for Tom the waiter. Service was exemplary.

Cathy B.Cathy Belcher: Nothing compares to the hogsnapper. Doesn't matter what it is.

D.J.'s Clam Shack is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic in Key West.

6. D.J.'s Clam Shack

8.6
629 Duval St (at Angela St), Key West, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 91 tips and reviews

Ivy M.Ivy Muthart: My husband loves the Maine Lobster Roll and this place meet the standards of having good food. I got the garlic steamed clams and it’s the best!

DilekDilek: Amazing lobster sandwich. Shrimp was a bit too fried but still good. A must go place for lobster…

Sylvia Q.Sylvia Quinn: You must try the Lobster roll. Best value in Old Town

Boat House Bar & Grill is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic in Key West.

7. Boat House Bar & Grill

8.1
220 Margaret Street, Key West, FL
American Restaurant · 37 tips and reviews

Randy C.Randy Cook: Peel and eat fresh shrimp, garlic bread and the clam chowder were Amazing !!

Rob W.Rob Waldron: One word..... BREAD

JamesonJameson: Eat the bread!!

Blackfin Bistro is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic in Key West.

8. Blackfin Bistro

8.3
918 Duval St (btwn Olivia St. And Truman Ave.), Key West, FL
New American Restaurant · 49 tips and reviews

Daniel H.Daniel Huamani: Excellent food! Got the shripms with garlic sauce.

Martha Z.Martha Zampino: Super good the tuna tartar, salmon and pan roasted grouper

Sarah .Sarah 🌴: I've been here three time so far and am never disappointed with the food or service. Service food and ambience are out of control. Definitely check this place out if you are in key west.

Abbondanza Italian Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic in Key West.

9. Abbondanza Italian Restaurant

8.3
1208 Simonton St, Key West, FL
Italian Restaurant · 26 tips and reviews

P S.P Sawtell: Roasted Garlic

Tony T.Tony Thrasher: The food was absolutely delicious. Definitely worth trying. I now have a new favorite when we come to Key West.

Ki-J J.Ki-J Jones: Amazing food!!!!

A&B Lobster House is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic in Key West.

10. A&B Lobster House

8.0
700 Front St, Key West, FL
American Restaurant · 45 tips and reviews

Binky G.Binky Greene: Don't miss out on the Escargot Saute ... served in a puff pastry with garlic wild mushrooms and a creamy cognac demi glace I give it 5 stars

David S.David Schwartz: This restaurant sits dockside, which might account for the fresh, awesome seafood. Try the Buffalo Shrimp and everything else on the menu.

Greg N.Greg Needham: Fantastic! Best restaurant on the island.

Denny's is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic in Key West.

11. Denny's

8.7
2710 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West, FL
Breakfast Spot · 2 tips and reviews

DilekDilek: A classic diner with good food

Ghaida✨Ghaida✨: Strawberry fried pancake was awesome!

Coles Peace is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic in Key West.

12. Coles Peace

8.7
1111 Eaton St (White St), Key West, FL
Bakery · 6 tips and reviews

Bethany K.Bethany K: Great fresh bread and amazing Mango Bread Pudding. Definitely a great lunch place, although can be a bit expensive.

Magdalena W.Magdalena Wolak: Espresso, sandwiches

Travis L.Travis Larson: Sandwiches, Craft beer selection. Get the Ciabatta-Lotta or the Brisket Sandwich!

El Meson de Pepe Restaurant & Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic in Key West.

13. El Meson de Pepe Restaurant & Bar

8.2
410 Wall St, Key West, FL
Cuban Restaurant · 103 tips and reviews

MISSLISAMISSLISA: The warm flat bread with two dipping sauces hot and garlic is good you will want extra

The DurbsThe Durbs: Don't miss this place! I had the Cuban steak sandwich, phenomenal! You can't go wrong here. FYI They add 18% gratuity automatically.

Julie C.Julie Camp: Do not miss this place while in Key West! Excellent Cuban food and great atmosphere!!

Cafe Marquesa is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic in Key West.

14. Cafe Marquesa

8.7
600 Fleming St, Key West, FL
American Restaurant · 16 tips and reviews

Steve M.Steve Mouzon: Both flatiron steak and yellowtail were excellent. Can't go wrong with either.

FranFran: Save room for the Key Lime Napoleon for dessert!

Gordon C.Gordon Crawford: Best meal in key west. Lobster and shrimp beautiful.

Prime 951 Steak House is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic in Key West.

15. Prime 951 Steak House

8.2
951 Caroline St, Key West, FL
Steakhouse · 16 tips and reviews

Elena B.Elena Barba: Steak of course is the best..love the decor.

Yordan R.Yordan Rodriguez: Must try the "Mac&Cheese"!(not your regular Mac&cheese)Oh...don't forget your Rockefeller Oysters!!!

Jason T.Jason Tavares: Service is great ambiance is wonderful and ASK FOR AMY SHES THE BEST SERVER EVER what a pleasure having her I LOVE GREAT SERVICE YOU GO AMY