Prime 951 Steak House is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Key West.

1. Prime 951 Steak House

8.0
951 Caroline St, Key West, FL
Steakhouse · 16 tips and reviews

CentralTexas R.CentralTexas RoadRelics: Truly one of the best Prime Ribeyes I've ever had, will not hesitate to come back again, guaranteed!!

Luiz G.Luiz Geraldo: Order the Rodney Strong with ribeye and truffle macaroni at the side. Simply perfect combination !

Cassandra T.Cassandra Toppino: The best steak on the island. The mac and cheese is not your mother's version. Smoked gouda and truffle oil, outstanding.

Martin's is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Key West.

2. Martin's

7.7
917 Duval St (btwn Olivia & Truman), Key West, FL
New American Restaurant · 34 tips and reviews

Gary K.Gary Keywood: Ok or not bad blue cheese on the ribeye is to much

courtney c.courtney choate: Went for happy hour and was very impressed! Had a few different kinds of the martinis and I especially loved the Key West Sunset. We also shared apps; the pork tenderloin tapas was phenomenal.

Adam V.Adam Van Bavel: Sit outside in the garden. Ask for Dennis!

Pepe's Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Key West.

3. Pepe's Cafe

8.6
806 Caroline St (btwn Williams & Margaret St), Key West, FL
American Restaurant · 97 tips and reviews

Kayla B.Kayla BeeMuddy: Best ribeye EVER. So happy I almost cried.

Patrick K.Patrick Keane: Best breakfast in Key West! Make sure you get the bread special! The chili is great for lunch or dinner. And the make an awesome steak at a good value! Don't forget their Wacky Pack!

Joe D.Joe Devine: Awesome cocktails! Made with fresh squeezed juice.

Cafe Marquesa is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Key West.

4. Cafe Marquesa

8.5
600 Fleming St, Key West, FL
American Restaurant · 16 tips and reviews

Rosie M.Rosie M: Top notch in Key West. Menu changes daily. Great atmosphere. 1 block off of Duval but it feels like 10miles. Like a place in the West Village of Manhattan.

FranFran: Save room for the Key Lime Napoleon for dessert!

Gordon C.Gordon Crawford: Best meal in key west. Lobster and shrimp beautiful.

The Reach Key West, Curio Collection by Hilton is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Key West.

5. The Reach Key West, Curio Collection by Hilton

8.4
1435 Simonton St (at South St), Key West, FL
Hotel · 28 tips and reviews

Allan R.Allan Rodgers: One of the few resorts in this part of Key West with its own beach. Great exercise facility and spacious guest suites.

Lina G.Lina Gonzo: Order a drink, relax on the beach, and listen to the waves flowing in and out of the shore.

JoseJose: Nice hotel with a man made beach. Beware of the free roaming chickens. This is staying at Key West in style.

Azur is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Key West.

6. Azur

8.6
425 Grinnell St (Fleming), Key West, FL
Mediterranean Restaurant · 43 tips and reviews

Marcia D.Marcia Dunsmore: Octopus salad delicious and a good one to try if you have never had octopus before but want to try. French fries excellent as is crab BLT. Beer list a little lame. Setting great. Sit outside by waterf

paul m.paul menta: Anything mike cooks is good and fresh.....I am a chef....his stuff is on

Peter S.Peter Stark: The Crab Cake BLT is delicious!

Duffy's Steak & Lobster House is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Key West.

7. Duffy's Steak & Lobster House

8.2
1007 Simonton St (at Truman Ave.), Key West, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 31 tips and reviews

Morten T.Morten Trolle: Great prime rib cooked to perfection. Leaving with empty plates :)

Monique M.Monique Melton: The fried alligator tail is amazingly yummy!!!!

Steve M.Steve Murray-Smith: great prime rib and yellow tail

A&B Lobster House is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Key West.

8. A&B Lobster House

8.1
700 Front St, Key West, FL
American Restaurant · 45 tips and reviews

Binky G.Binky Greene: Don't miss out on the Escargot Saute ... served in a puff pastry with garlic wild mushrooms and a creamy cognac demi glace I give it 5 stars

Greg N.Greg Needham: Fantastic! Best restaurant on the island.

Amy W.Amy Wright: Lobster bisque is fantastic!!

Commodore Steak & Lobster House is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Key West.

9. Commodore Steak & Lobster House

7.5
220 Margaret Street, Key West, FL
Steakhouse · 18 tips and reviews

Shervy S.Shervy Sherv: Great food, great atmosphere and great service. Sit upstairs for more upscale dining and downstairs for more casual.

Jason K.Jason Keath: Order the Yellowtail Snapper. Thank me when you're done. Sans lemon butter sauce to save the calories. Either way, delicious.

Carl R.Carl Ramallo: Unbelievable location & food on the Pier.

Dante's is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Key West.

10. Dante's

8.1
955 Caroline St, Key West, FL
Cuban Restaurant · 50 tips and reviews

Shawn G.Shawn Gray: Nice pool boats on one side and two Tiki bars. Try Cuban mix sandwich its really good and comes with fresh cut fries.

Cathy B.Cathy Belcher: Great for lunch and drinks by the pool!

Matt L.Matt Leese: Plenty of specialty rum drinks, poolside bar with waterfall, hidden from the street and bayside. All good so far!

Fausto's Food Palace is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Key West.

11. Fausto's Food Palace

7.5
522 Fleming St, Key West, FL
Grocery Store · 15 tips and reviews

Stacey H.Stacey Herron: A really great wine selection. In a grocery store! Sure, you can get a box of Franzia, but you'll find a nice selection of wines from Russian River, the Willamette Valley and more.

Carl R.Carl Ramallo: Like a mini Whole Food, in the Keys.

Alex R.Alex Rainert: They (along with seemingly every other "grocery" stores around here) close at 8pm sharp so make sure you don't leave any potential grocery emergencies (like booze or ice cream) till after dark.

Hog's Breath Saloon is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Key West.

12. Hog's Breath Saloon

8.3
400 Front St, Key West, FL
Bar · 110 tips and reviews

Kristen P.Kristen P: Famous bar in Key West. The live bands are amazing there. So fun!

Mike T.Mike T: Call your friends back home and tell them to log into "hogsbreath.com" while you are there. They can view you through the bar's live streaming cam.

The Inn At Key WestThe Inn At Key West: A trip to Key West is not complete without visiting Hog's Breath.

Smallest Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Key West.

13. Smallest Bar

7.7
124 Duval St (between Front & Greene Sts), Key West, FL
Bar · 33 tips and reviews

Captain Nick'sCaptain Nick's: Love this tiny bar. Go get a cocktail and take a picture there! Not sure that its open in the day time, might be only at night!

John H.John Hagga: This the smallest bar in the world!

Adrian C.Adrian Castillo: A must visit to this place! Great service and drinks!

Two Friends Patio Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Key West.

14. Two Friends Patio Restaurant

8.3
512 Front St, Key West, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 93 tips and reviews

JimmyGotUpsJimmyGotUps: Karaoke in the evenings. This place also has reasonable prices on crab legs.

Tara G.Tara Gangi: Try the conch fritters here. yum yum

Tricia B.Tricia Bellamy: Good crab sandwich and homemade potato chips! The key lime pie was delicious!!

Schooner Wharf Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Key West.

15. Schooner Wharf Bar

8.3
202 William St, Key West, FL
Beer Garden · 135 tips and reviews

Donna P.Donna Perdue: Not classy, but "the last part of original Key West" is right there. Live music every night (visit them online). Their breakfast is solid! Raw oysters good while enjoying cigars and music.

Cathy B.Cathy Belcher: Try the Tuna Nachos. Amazing!

Jeff O.Jeff Ollis: Come and listen to Michael McCloud. He is an institution here.