Willy Street Co-op is one of The 11 Best Places for Mustard Sauce in Madison.

1. Willy Street Co-op

8.9
1221 Williamson St (Baldwin St.), Madison, WI
Grocery Store · Marquette · 19 tips and reviews

Taiowa W.Taiowa Waner: Great place for grocery shopping. They usually have a lot of cheese ends available. Grab a slice of zucchini bread for an excellent snack or check out the hot bar.

Rebecca L.Rebecca Lin: My favorite thing to do here is read about #firstworldproblems via the customer comments and complaints board by the restrooms. Very entertaining.

Christian S.Christian Sandvig: The YouTube sensation 'Chad Vader' was filmed here.

Johnny Delmonico's Steakhouse is one of The 11 Best Places for Mustard Sauce in Madison.

2. Johnny Delmonico's Steakhouse

8.1
130 S Pinckney St, Madison, WI
American Restaurant · Downtown Madison · 13 tips and reviews

Blake R.Blake Robertson: One of Madison's steak triumvirate. This is a place to show off and impress. Great steak. Best calamari anywhere.

Dave T.Dave T: Great steak.

Stephen K.Stephen Koontz: Their desire to be upscale is met with tepid results. Madison can do better than this!

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. - Madison East is one of The 11 Best Places for Mustard Sauce in Madison.

3. Glass Nickel Pizza Co. - Madison East

8.7
2916 Atwood Ave (at S Fair Oaks Ave), Madison, WI
Pizzeria · 23 tips and reviews

jill l.jill losser: One of my fav places for pizza cheese curds & bloody marys

Amanda C.Amanda Carlson: The nickel nuggets are awesome.

Allison G.Allison Garver: Nickel nuggets!

The Cheesecake Factory is one of The 11 Best Places for Mustard Sauce in Madison.

4. The Cheesecake Factory

7.7
1 W Towne Mall, Madison, WI
American Restaurant · 7 tips and reviews

Madison  ヅMadison ヅ: Lemoncello cream torte is sooo good!

Christopher S.Christopher Sanders: EVERYTHING IS AWESOMELY

mark t.mark turner: Creole shrimp and andouille sausage.

Jordan's Big Ten Pub is one of The 11 Best Places for Mustard Sauce in Madison.

5. Jordan's Big Ten Pub

8.1
1330 Regent St, Madison, WI
Bar · 40 tips and reviews

Josef B.Josef Burger: The Friday fish fry is one of the best around -- and there's always a new "Catch of the Day" every week to spice up the menu.

T.j. G.T.j. Gillitzer: If you have not been here yet, you have not eaten the best food in Madison!

Kim M.Kim Murray: Try Trevor's amazing desserts!!!!

Dotty Dumpling's Dowry is one of The 11 Best Places for Mustard Sauce in Madison.

6. Dotty Dumpling's Dowry

8.9
317 N Frances St, Madison, WI
Burger Joint · 72 tips and reviews

Ben L.Ben Luginbill: Some of the favorite burgers in Madison and has been apart of UW community for decades. Had to try the appetizer sampler with Cheese Curds and Mac&Cheese wedges. Pair with Spotted Cow beer!

AJ S.AJ Storrs: The Heartthrob burger is a close second to the Melting Pot, especially if you like the spicy. The chili is also excellent.

BethBeth: Fabulous veggie burger but really messy. The onion rings my friends ordered were delish! Exactly how onion rings should be made. Will be back!

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Fitchburg is one of The 11 Best Places for Mustard Sauce in Madison.

7. Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Fitchburg

7.3
3191 Muir Field Rd, Madison, WI
Pizzeria · 10 tips and reviews

AlyskaAlyska: Tasty gluten-free pizza crust; just make sure you ask for it "extra done" if you have a lot of wet toppings!

Sean L.Sean Lawler: To piggyback on Amanda's tip, this location does not have beer. If enough people ask for it it will. We all know pizza + beer = super awesome!! Get a liquor license Glass Nickel please.

Catie O.Catie O'Donnell Glogovsky: Get pizza by the slice for an inexpensive lunch out.

Glass Nickel Pizza is one of The 11 Best Places for Mustard Sauce in Madison.

8. Glass Nickel Pizza

7.3
5003 University Ave (Whitney way), Madison, WI
Pizzeria · 17 tips and reviews

Julie S.Julie Shackleton: Great staff, DELISH salads and the pizza is gooood. I had the margarita on cracker base. Tip: get sauce. I didn't and was a bit dry. The cinnanuggets for dessert are YUM

Ed R.Ed R: Fantastic BBQ chicken pizza

AllisonAllison: Not much of a sit-down joint, but the pizza is delicious and easy to pick up for dinner elsewhere. We always swap pepperoni for tomatoes on the deluxe... Mmm!

Great Dane Pub & Brewing Company is one of The 11 Best Places for Mustard Sauce in Madison.

9. Great Dane Pub & Brewing Company

8.5
123 E Doty St (at King St), Madison, WI
Brewery · Downtown Madison · 141 tips and reviews

Cooper S.Cooper Smith: Start with the Cheese & Artichoke Dip (if you're craving more, order the Dane Burger, which comes topped in the dip). Goes great with a Crop Circle Wheat in the summer.

Men's Health MagMen's Health Mag: Fresh brewed beer. Billiards without daiquiri stains. Food served on platters. No wonder the states mandate closing hours, or you’d never leave this place. Start with Peck’s Pilsner, go from there.

Ryan H.Ryan Huber: Ask for Dario. He makes the dirtiest drinks.

Essen Haus is one of The 11 Best Places for Mustard Sauce in Madison.

10. Essen Haus

7.4
514 E Wilson St (Btw S Franklin & S Blair), Madison, WI
German Restaurant · Downtown Madison · 41 tips and reviews

Brent G.Brent Gatewood: Great beer on tap, pretzels and German music!

EsquireEsquire: Congratulations, you've found one of Esquire's Best Bars in America. Try any one of the 17 German tap biers, in a two-liter boot stein. Read more.

Peter M.Peter M: Loud atmosphere. A fun place to party.

Tipsy Cow is one of The 11 Best Places for Mustard Sauce in Madison.

11. Tipsy Cow

7.6
102 King St (at Main St), Madison, WI
Bar · Downtown Madison · 80 tips and reviews

Rk S.Rk S: Burgers are a must. Truffle fries are decadent. Great beer selection.

Serious EatsSerious Eats: Fantastic smashed burgers in a little, casual bar that can compete with the more well-known spots on Capital Square.

Erin P.Erin Perry: Excellent burgers and great beer menu. So many choices, get a few apps in half orders to try everything!