The Old Fashioned Tavern & Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Tomatoes in Madison.

1. The Old Fashioned Tavern & Restaurant

8.8
23 N Pinckney St, Madison, WI
Gastropub · Downtown Madison · 261 tips and reviews

Jane L.Jane Lemon Tereba: If they have a BLT special - order it. The heirloom tomatoes are amazing.

Heather B.Heather Beach: Tomato soup is amazing. Try a cheese platter.

Ruby A.Ruby Anaya: Grilled cheese and tomato soup combo is great!

Panera Bread is one of The 15 Best Places for Tomatoes in Madison.

2. Panera Bread

8.2
6637 Mineral Point Rd, Madison, WI
Bakery · 19 tips and reviews

Sami S.Sami Sonks: If your sick and away from home the creamy tomato soup and grilled cheese totally hits the spot! I don't evening like tomato soup but it's amazing!

Alexander S.Alexander Smith: One of my favorite places. The Bistro French Onion Soup is my go to.

dude b.dude bal: Free Wifi in the Bathroom. Now this is an office.

Dumpling Haus is one of The 15 Best Places for Tomatoes in Madison.

3. Dumpling Haus

8.6
Hilldale Mall 702 N. Midvale blvd #125, Madison, WI
Asian Restaurant · 34 tips and reviews

Danna H.Danna Hamlett: The tomato & cilantro soba were fantastic! The woman who served us was very friendly & helpful!

Bitchin' A.Bitchin' Amy: The Nutella Bao are amazing! The perfect amount of sweet. :)

Fei-FeiFei-Fei: Try the Haus Jiao Zi. A little slice of juicy heaven!

Potbelly Sandwich Shop is one of The 15 Best Places for Tomatoes in Madison.

4. Potbelly Sandwich Shop

8.0
564 State St, Madison, WI
Sandwich Spot · State Street · 20 tips and reviews

dude b.dude bal: Try the new Spicy black bean and roasted tomato soup! It's soup season!

Marissa H.Marissa Hansen: The pizza sandwich is quite yummy

Kim G.Kim G: Had my Potbelly Sandwich today, did you?

Trader Joe's is one of The 15 Best Places for Tomatoes in Madison.

5. Trader Joe's

8.8
1810 Monroe St (at Harrison St), Madison, WI
Grocery Store · Dudgeon - Monroe · 26 tips and reviews

Amy L.Amy Lang: Lots of interesting, new products to check out and try. The BEST place to get sun-dried tomatoes for an excellent price!

Joe M.Joe Menard: Organic at it's best!

Rose Z.Rose Z: Dark chocolate peanutbutter cups yummmmmmm

Marigold Kitchen is one of The 15 Best Places for Tomatoes in Madison.

6. Marigold Kitchen

8.4
118 S Pinckney St (btwn King & Doty St.), Madison, WI
Café · Downtown Madison · 79 tips and reviews

Kevin B.Kevin Buckley: Try the Breakfast Sandwich - Delicious! Would be great when tomato is super fresh later this summer.

Sarah F.Sarah Fuhrmann: Basil tomato cheese scrambler is divine!

Keith T.Keith Tomaszewski: Breakfast sandwich was awesome. Pancakes, blueberry & pumpkin/buckwheat/praline we’re delicious. Skip the classic Bloody Mary, it was a premix.

The Roman Candle Pizzeria is one of The 15 Best Places for Tomatoes in Madison.

7. The Roman Candle Pizzeria

7.8
1054 Williamson St (Ingersoll), Madison, WI
Pizzeria · Marquette · 21 tips and reviews

Arielle B.Arielle Bearheart: Roasted red pepper and tomato soup is delicious!!

Paul L.Paul Larson: Always great pizza, unique topping ideas. Try the candle sticks with marinara, yum!

Megan CMegan C: This could be the best pizza in Madison. It's up for debate, but it's a near-east side gem.

Johnson Public House is one of The 15 Best Places for Tomatoes in Madison.

8. Johnson Public House

8.6
908 E Johnson St (Paterson St), Madison, WI
Café · Tenney-Lapham · 38 tips and reviews

Claire G.Claire Graupmann: Fantastic coffee and atmosphere. I had the roasted tomato, feta toast which was absolutely delicious.

Jamie O.Jamie O: Pb&J is delish. Real berries, crunchy o PB and wonderful bread. Vegan friendly! Hard to find a table on the weekend though

Colin S.Colin Steinke: This just might be the best cup of coffee I've had in Madison.

Metcalfe's Market is one of The 15 Best Places for Tomatoes in Madison.

9. Metcalfe's Market

8.4
726 N Midvale Blvd (at Hilldale Mall), Madison, WI
Grocery Store · 42 tips and reviews

Claire L.Claire L.: Get the Don's hot house tomatoes! Locally grown & VERY tasty!

Lisa B.Lisa Briggs: Great salad bar and lots of other things to choose from to grab and go.

Jason H.Jason Horstman: Best Meat in Town!

Ian's Pizza by the Slice is one of The 15 Best Places for Tomatoes in Madison.

10. Ian's Pizza by the Slice

8.4
319 N Frances St (University Ave), Madison, WI
Pizzeria · Johnson Street Bend · 54 tips and reviews

Paul H.Paul Hefti: Try the Mozzarella and Tomato Pizza

Sadashiv H.Sadashiv H: Awesome Pizzas..lots of vegetarian varieties..And its pretty cheap compared to other pizza outlets.

Sonya C.Sonya C: I'm saying order two or less..you are drunk...just being a friend

Yola's Café & Coffee Shop of Madison is one of The 15 Best Places for Tomatoes in Madison.

11. Yola's Café & Coffee Shop of Madison

7.7
494 Commerce Dr (Watts Rd), Madison, WI
Café · 55 tips and reviews

Kristi H.Kristi Hellmer: Best frittata ever, with goat cheese, Brussel sprouts, and sun dried tomatoes... Mmm! Delicious!

Lori H.Lori Heffernon: Yolas does amazing catering, they did a fantastic pumpkin bars and fruit kabobs for Oasis Day Spa

Wendy S.Wendy Soucie: If you like almond milk as a non dairy alternative, they make the drinks best with it.

Panera Bread is one of The 15 Best Places for Tomatoes in Madison.

12. Panera Bread

7.7
2627 East Springs Dr, Madison, WI
Bakery · 30 tips and reviews

Mallary S.Mallary S: Tomato soup is back and better than ever! Don't forget your bread bowl :)

Mary C.Mary Crawford: love the artichoke mini quiche for breakfast

Tiffany G.Tiffany Grayson: Don't stop here! Horribly unapologetically slow! There have to be better places in Madison to eat.

The Madison Club is one of The 15 Best Places for Tomatoes in Madison.

13. The Madison Club

9.0
5 E Wilson St, Madison, WI
American Restaurant · Downtown Madison · 4 tips and reviews

Alexandra K.Alexandra Klein: The Passion Fruit Chili Chicken Salad is the BEST salad ever! Highly recommended!

LiladaLilada: Try the sweet potato fries at Churchill. Delicious!

BeccaBecca: Great place to hold a party or board meeting.

Banzo is one of The 15 Best Places for Tomatoes in Madison.

14. Banzo

7.9
2105 Sherman Ave, Madison, WI
Mediterranean Restaurant · 20 tips and reviews

Yoli Z.Yoli Z: Fabulous, crunchy falafel. Banzo with white pita is where it's at.

Matthew R.Matthew Rathbone: Skip the soups (meh), the excellent falafel is where its at.

Carolyn B.Carolyn Baker: Traditional, healthy, delicious! Best hummus in Madison, the whole menu is great.

Chick-fil-A is one of The 15 Best Places for Tomatoes in Madison.

15. Chick-fil-A

8.2
4212 E Washington Ave, Madison, WI
Fast Food Restaurant · 4 tips and reviews

JohneJohne: They always exceed our expectations, a delightful place to have a quick meal.

Eric O.Eric Olson: Make sure that you are always checking your order before you leave the drive thru. They are often missing parts of your order.

Jessica B.Jessica Brown: Free breakfast everyTuesday AM