My Pie is one of The 15 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Midtown East, New York.

1. My Pie

7.8
696 Lexington Ave (at E 57th St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Midtown East · 61 tips and reviews

K L.K Lag: Just about everything. Couldn't stop ordering. Must try buffalo mozzarella and grandma nonnina

Monica K.Monica Kong: Must try..... Mushroom truffle oil and buffalo mozzarella. Yummmmz!!

Rosi L.Rosi Liriano Facenda: Buffalo mozzarella

Casa Lever is one of The 15 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Midtown East, New York.

2. Casa Lever

8.2
390 Park Ave (btwn E 53rd St & E 54th St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Midtown East · 69 tips and reviews

Ana C.Ana Concejero: Finally a place that carries true buffalo mozzarella!

James H.James H.: Grilled eggplant with buffalo mozzarella was very good.

John M.John Morton: Impress your date by taking them here for a drink. The design of the space is amazing.

Il Corso is one of The 15 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Midtown East, New York.

3. Il Corso

8.1
54 W 55th St (btwn 5th & 6th), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Midtown East · 41 tips and reviews

Sean C.Sean Cover: Had the buffalo mozzarella and tomatoes and calamari for appetizers. For dinner we had the saffron risotto, the sea bass, the seafood pasta, and the spaghetti. Everything was delicious.

ChloeChloe: This is an innovative parmigiana, they use Buffalo mozzarella cheese instead. And it’s light and tasty.

Christopher F.Christopher Floss: An amazing experience that brought me back to #Rome. All of the #pastas are homemade. Great wine selections. A MUST if you are searching for #Italian cuisine in #NewYork.

Il Gattopardo is one of The 15 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Midtown East, New York.

4. Il Gattopardo

8.1
33 W 54th St (btwn 5th & 6th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Midtown East · 33 tips and reviews

New York PostNew York Post: Mozzarella in carozza is one of the city’s great, stealth grilled cheese sandwiches, a blissful blur of buffalo mozzarella and anchovies not deep-fried, but pan-sauteed on crunchy country bread. Read more.

Norma S.Norma Santoyo: Try any pasta dish! A must when in NYC

G I.G I: Place is overrated. Staff is nice, but food is ok. Everything has so much salt in it! Would not be returning for sure.

Cipriani Le Specialita is one of The 15 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Midtown East, New York.

5. Cipriani Le Specialita

7.6
110 E 42nd St (btwn Park Ave S & Lexington), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Midtown East · 38 tips and reviews

Gansevoort Hotel GroupGansevoort Hotel Group: The Mozzarella Di Bufala & Tomato Salad is to die for!

Joymarie P.Joymarie Parker: The Mixed Berry Panna Cotta is the perfect way to end a magnificent lunch!

BravoBravo: Known internationally for the ladies who lunch. -Luann De Lesseps, Real Housewives of New York City

Club A Steakhouse is one of The 15 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Midtown East, New York.

6. Club A Steakhouse

8.2
240 E 58th St (btwn 2nd & 3rd Ave.), New York, NY
Steakhouse · Midtown East · 83 tips and reviews

Tim C.Tim Curran: Really excellent buffalo mozzarella in the mozzarella and tomato salad.

Halstead PropertyHalstead Property: One of our favorite restaurants for the extra special occasions, Club A Steakhouse is a great place to celebrate while indulging in Prime NY Strip cut extra-thick and cooked to perfection.

The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group: Intimate steakhouse, with a very red interior. Take advantage of their $100 four-course dinner-for-two deal – try the hanger steak with a bottle of malbec.

Ideal Cheese Shop is one of The 15 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Midtown East, New York.

7. Ideal Cheese Shop

8.7
942 1st Ave (52nd St), New York, NY
Cheese Store · Turtle Bay · 12 tips and reviews

The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group: A unique place and for serious cheese lovers. Walk in and take in the wonderful cheesy aroma and sample cheeses from all over the world.

Christine W.Christine Wong: wow this place is amazing! the staff is very welcoming and provide great recommendations.

M R.M Reilly-Brooks: Great cheese selection (truffle Gouda too). Staff is wonderful, answering questions and providing guidance.

La Gioconda is one of The 15 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Midtown East, New York.

8. La Gioconda

8.1
226 E 53rd St (btwn 3rd Ave & 2nd Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Turtle Bay · 12 tips and reviews

Rachel G.Rachel Gruber: I didn't expect such a great Italian restaurant in midtown, but everyone that I was with loved it. Great food, very authentic, I will be going back.

Sonya D.Sonya Doshi: Loved the Cacio e Pepe!

Kip R.Kip Rupp: We typically get the specials, which are always awesome. But have never had anything off the menu that disappointed.

Serafina Osteria is one of The 15 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Midtown East, New York.

9. Serafina Osteria

8.0
38 E 58th St (btwn Madison & Park Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Midtown East · 13 tips and reviews

Paige C.Paige C: They’re doing an excellent job with outdoor dining and covid precautions. Their outdoor set up is very safe, comfortable and well heated. I also must say that they have the best coffee I’ve ever had.

Rachel S.Rachel Smith: Penne stolichnaya!!!

Keoni S.Keoni Souza: Yum Bruscheta!

The Shops at The Plaza is one of The 15 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Midtown East, New York.

10. The Shops at The Plaza

7.7
1 W 58th St (5th Ave), New York, NY
Shopping Mall · Midtown East · 5 tips and reviews

Emeltri G. A.Emeltri G. Alegre: Be sure to visit Gramercy Park Flower Shop ;). And also great place to hang tasty foods and frozen yogurt

Felicia V.Felicia Valentine: One of the cutest flower boy I did ever see ♥ and very charming too ;)

Sheshelaghost L.Sheshelaghost LaGhost: One of a kind pieces! A-List fav! Womens clothes & Accessories.

Murray's Cheese at Grand Central Market is one of The 15 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Midtown East, New York.

11. Murray's Cheese at Grand Central Market

8.1
42nd St at Lexington Ave, New York, NY
Cheese Store · Turtle Bay · 38 tips and reviews

Serious EatsSerious Eats: The uptown outpost of one our favorite cheese shops in the city. Smaller than the original and lacking in the awesome sandwiches, but great for grocery shopping or a quick snack.

Village VoiceVillage Voice: Village Voice is excited to have Murray's Cheese at the 2012 Choice Eats food fest! Full list of restaurants here: http://ow.ly/8QjDQ

Jaro G.Jaro G4: Make sure to get the card which allows you to stamp everytime you purchase on the 11th stamp it's 10% off

Pathos Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Midtown East, New York.

12. Pathos Cafe

7.5
932 1st Ave (at 51st), New York, NY
Greek Restaurant · Turtle Bay · 5 tips and reviews

Paola V.Paola Venturini: Octopus, tuna tartar, and prosciutto and gorgonzola pizza. Sangria pitchers too.

Monday L.Monday Lisa: Nice outdoor seating but food very over priced for what it is. BF got a Cuban that looked like a 5th grader made a turkey sandwich and it was $15 🙄

Elvi R.Elvi Rod: This place is really nice a the food it's excellent!!

Aretsky's Patroon is one of The 15 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Midtown East, New York.

13. Aretsky's Patroon

8.0
160 E 46th St (btwn Lexington & 3rd Ave.), New York, NY
New American Restaurant · Turtle Bay · 36 tips and reviews

Affinia Hotel CollectionAffinia Hotel Collection: This classic American steakhouse offers not only delicious steaks, but also an extensive menu of classic, well-loved American fare. Additionally, they mix strong, excellent cocktails.

RazorfishRazorfish: A favorite rooftop bar come Spring and great place for entertaining clients.

Joanna F.Joanna Flamm: Fried Chicken Fridays are a perfect place to take a date. $25 for fried chicken, two sides, dessert, and live jazz. Make a reservation; they often fill up.

Cellini is one of The 15 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Midtown East, New York.

14. Cellini

7.7
65 E 54th St (btwn Park Ave & Madison Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Midtown East · 22 tips and reviews

Annie A.Annie Alfstad: The thing you get is their special envelope pasta. It.is.everything.

Jim F.Jim Follett: Great restaurant! All pasta dishes are great. Veal and fish are outstanding. Get the table for 8 under the alcove if you have a group. Almost like having a private room

Emily R.Emily Ritchlin: Great service and you're served right away!

Cello Wine Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Midtown East, New York.

15. Cello Wine Bar

7.6
229 E 53rd St (btwn 2nd & 3rd Ave), New York, NY
Wine Bar · Midtown East · 27 tips and reviews

Nicole A.Nicole Albano: Delicious food - short ribs are not to be missed! Amazing service. My new favorite neighborhood joint!

Kristen P.Kristen Peirano: Great flatbreads especially the white one !

Jarett L.Jarett Lewis: 2 drinks $43 enjoy. Didn't get wine.