Harvard Club of New York City is one of The 7 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Midtown East, New York.

1. Harvard Club of New York City

8.3
35 W 44th St (btwn 5th & 6th Ave), New York, NY
Historic and Protected Site · Midtown East · 52 tips and reviews

Sara .Sara 🌈⚔🍾: The key lime pie is amazing!

Christian T.Christian Thwaites: Work in the basement. Wifi and printers available. Nice people too!

DensDens: I was here for opening day of the buffalo shrimp in the upstairs bar -- highly recommended, tho you only get 3. FYI - Beware if dudes in suits talking tennis.

Fogo de Chão is one of The 7 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Midtown East, New York.

2. Fogo de Chão

8.5
40 W 53rd St (at 5th Ave), New York, NY
Churrascaria · Midtown East · 127 tips and reviews

KarenKaren: Unlimited meats. Great salad bar. The key lime pie dessert is very refreshing for the palate after eating rich meats.

Philipp N.Philipp Nass: Loved it! We came here for the full churrasco experience for lunch.

Claudio S.Claudio Souza: Add the price of the taxi to your expenses expectations because you gonna need one after eating like a king here.

Morton's The Steakhouse is one of The 7 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Midtown East, New York.

3. Morton's The Steakhouse

8.1
551 5th Ave (at E 45th St), New York, NY
Steakhouse · Midtown East · 62 tips and reviews

Matt W.Matt Wieser: Key Lime Pie.... mmmmhh

Pelin G.Pelin Güllü: Such great menu and pleasant restaurant!Besides,my friends mentioned my birthday and they prepared a specific menu for it.Thank you!

Peter S.Peter Shankman: It's possible to do a Morton's dinner for under 600 calories! Small petit fillet, asparagus, raw oysters.

Baked By Melissa is one of The 7 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Midtown East, New York.

4. Baked By Melissa

8.0
109 E 42nd St (btwn Park & Lexington), New York, NY
Cupcake Shop · Midtown East · 38 tips and reviews

Mafe S.Mafe Sotillo Lairet: So cute and delicious! The rainbow ones are my favorite

Lia Deliana S.Lia Deliana S.: Try all the flavors!!! One for each flavor ;p

Michelle M.Michelle Mu: Peanut butter cup to die for!

Strip House is one of The 7 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Midtown East, New York.

5. Strip House

8.7
15 W 44th St (btwn 5th & 6th Ave), New York, NY
Steakhouse · Midtown East · 57 tips and reviews

Craig M.Craig Middleton: The food is outstanding! Anything you try here will be amazing. You can't miss!

Geoffroy B.Geoffroy Bablon: The porterhouse for two is one big, tasty steak. Just charred on the outside, super tender on the inside. Get it with a bottle of Belle Pente Pinot noir.

Brendan L.Brendan Lewis: Trust me on this: you do not like whoever you are with enough to share the roasted bacon appetizer. Tell them to get their own damn order

Rose Club at The Plaza is one of The 7 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Midtown East, New York.

6. Rose Club at The Plaza

7.0
768 5th Ave Fl 3 (Central Park South), New York, NY
Hotel Bar · Midtown East · 10 tips and reviews

dara lynnedara lynne: Classy and elegant! Get a seat overlooking the lobby and order the salami plate (with cheese to die for).

Ryan D.Ryan Drushel: Order the cherrywood cocktail!! And ask for an extra brandied cherry - amazing!

Ryan D.Ryan Drushel: Try the Crispy Lobster Roll!! Amazing!

Grand Central Oyster Bar is one of The 7 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Midtown East, New York.

7. Grand Central Oyster Bar

7.5
89 E 42nd St (Grand Central Terminal), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Midtown East · 403 tips and reviews

Ms H.Ms Helene: Stick to oysters $3-4 each and apple pie dessert $7. Skip lobster 1lb salad $34, key lime pie $7 and sweet potato ice cream $7.

Kristel v.Kristel van den Elzen: Dutch herring: available only for two weeks when the new season is there, somewhere in June. Lovely (and huge!) herring salad!

Tristan L.Tristan Louis: Stand in one corner in front of the Oyster Bar at Grand Central and have a friend stand on the other side and whisper. the other person can hear you...