1. The Smith
8.8
956 2nd Ave (at E 51st St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Turtle Bay · 364 tips and reviews
Bollare: Laid back atmosphere with cool décor. The mac & cheese is awesome, as are the brussels sprouts (no, really, they're amazing!) —Nicole
Carly Heitlinger: My FAVORITE spot for dinner, dessert, and drinks. For food, you absolutely must get the Brussels sprouts and mac & cheese. I dream about it. (Don't forget to pop downstairs for the photo booth!)
Charlotte Schwenke: We've tried the burger and mac n cheese > soooo good!
2. The Capital Grille
8.0
155 E 42nd St, New York, NY
American Restaurant · Turtle Bay · 83 tips and reviews
Katie Pitre: Great bar, lovely service, spacious seating... oh, and amazing steaks! Lobster mac & cheese is awesome!
The Corcoran Group: The Capital Grille is the place to go for a professional business lunch. You have to try the Parmesan Truffle Fries and the Lobster Mac ‘N’ Cheese. The dirty martini is excellent too.
Norman Ellis: The perfect Grill lunch: Crab meat cocktail appetizer, the Petite Filet medium rare, the kick ass Lobster Mac "n" Cheese and Wild Mushrooms on the side and end with the Creme Brulee. YUM!
3. Sofia Wine Bar
8.6
242 E 50th St (Bet 2nd & 3rd Ave), New York, NY
Wine Bar · Turtle Bay · 93 tips and reviews
Amanda Albergo: Revising my tip: Caramere wine, prosciutto mac and cheese, and the fancy buffalo cheese with sea salt-- FTW!
Christopher Tai: Order the Prosciutto mac n' cheese with the buffalo cheese and sea salt! Order it with some red wine and you're good to go!
Shakeera Datwani: The prosciutto Mac and cheese is a must here! Great combination!
4. P.J. Clarke's
8.7
915 3rd Ave (at E 55th St), New York, NY
Pub · Midtown East · 316 tips and reviews
Bill Masterson: get the mac and cheese with bacon and peas
Welcome to College: If your college visits bring you to the big city, find a few minutes to grab a bite and watch world go by at PJ Clarke's. The burgers, the mac & cheese, the raw bar...you cannot go wrong here!
Meghann Morin: The lobster Mac n cheese is the best I've ever had. It's full of chunks of lobster, not what you usually find.
5. Club A Steakhouse
8.6
240 E 58th St (btwn 2nd & 3rd Ave.), New York, NY
Steakhouse · Midtown East · 83 tips and reviews
Kristy Vasquez: Try the following. Filet mignon, Mac n cheese, Canadian bacon and a bottle of Santa margherita. Will be worth the money you spend here.
Wilmania Polanco: Try the Filet Mignon With Mac N Cheese - Yummyness, come during restaurant week if you want to try the menu without paying too much
Christine Chow: Seriously amazing service. Owner is super sweet! Super into the creamed spinach mac and cheese and cream puffs
Andrea Giese: Get the mac 'n cheese! Yummmmy!
M: Mini burgers and romaine salad for appetizers. Skirt steak, stk sauce, sweet corn pudding, Mac and cheese. These are the best oblates on the menu!
Christina Chin: Mac n cheese!! Got stk dip, fries are perfect
9. Del Frisco's Grille
7.8
50 Rockefeller Plz (Rockefeller Center), New York, NY
Steakhouse · Rockefeller Center · 101 tips and reviews
honeywhatscooking.com: Amazing truffle Mac & cheese and Creme Brûlée cheesecake. The crab cakes are good as are the chicken lollipops w buffalo sauce. Bad Caesar salad! You'll find a lot of men in suits! Overpriced!!!
Dalton Spear: Good location, loud atmosphere, good drink selection, good stroganoff, try the truffle mac
Justin Fraser: Great wine, bourbon, and food!
12. Butter Midtown
7.3
70 West 45th Street (6th Avenue), New York, NY
New American Restaurant · Midtown East · 174 tips and reviews
Jorge Castro: Nice place, all the food was perfect (we tried the shrimp, NY steak, Mac and cheese, beignets). Our host was so nice! Expensive and noisy, but the food is worth it.
Andrew C: Celebrity chef or not, I say its overrated... the lamb bacon and gnocchi mac 'n cheese app were the best items, that's it!!! For the price, go somewhere else that has better main course choices
Lauren Smyla: Parkerhouse rolls are amazing! Also get the Gnocchi Mac and Cheese, you won't regret it!
14. Parnell's Pub
7.5
350 E 53rd St (at 1st Ave.), New York, NY
Gastropub · Turtle Bay · 16 tips and reviews
Teeker Kaj: Adorable to see older, local crowd keep coming in to congregate. Great mac and cheese and tomato bisque/grilled cheese, albeit a kind of smaller sandwich. Great attentive service.
Thiago Cardoso: Very good Guinness and food -- what else you need?
Pawel Godlewski: Nice relaxed attitude and there's a guy just slappin da bass, big tiiiiime
Nikki Reed: Jalapeño Poppers , Mac n Cheese Balls, hand cut French fries, Caprese flatbread and spiked hot chocolate !
Fotoloco: great service, drinks and appetizers, i even got my 1st burger in NY and it was delicious
Melody Ewing: Derek is my favorite bartender in all of NYC. Charming Irish kid, attentive, with great stories!!!