3. The Amish Market
8.0
240 E 45th St (btwn 2nd & 3rd Ave.), New York, NY
Grocery Store · Turtle Bay · 75 tips and reviews
Daniel: Best brick oven thin crust pizzas in midtown east , also 10 dollar whole rotisserie chickens !!!
Karina Mireles Gza: Its a great market! Looks small on the outside but you will be surprise how big it is once you are in, perfect place I did many organic and healthy food, amazing salads !
The Corcoran Group: One of our favorite markets in the city, but also a great take-out lunch place with yummy sandwiches – try the Fresh Turkey with Brie. Coffee is top notch too!
4. My Pie
7.8
696 Lexington Ave (at E 57th St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Midtown East · 61 tips and reviews
Sean Sable: Delicious, fresh and airy thin crust Pizza. Nice crunch out of the oven.
B H: Awesome customer service - yummy pizza. Tried mushroom & buffalo chicken!
Jean Lee: Don't know why it says it's expensive. It's only $4 for a slice of the best margherita pizza! All organic with no added sugar... You can taste the difference. Authentic Romana style!
5. Best Pizza
7.3
1038 1st Ave (at E 57th St.), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Sutton Place · 15 tips and reviews
Bibi Miller: Slices are awesome & eclectic. They do cracker thin crust, and it's Amazing.
Ryan Platner: I would highly recommend both their pizza and pasta dishes. I usually go to one of their competitors, but had a slice of theirs that was ordered to a local bar in the area and wanted more! Enjoy!
David Greenberger: The place lives up to its name. 1 of the top 3 slices I've had in NYC. No need to get fancy, the plain and mini pepperoni slices are out of this world.
6. Pathos Cafe
7.5
932 1st Ave (at 51st), New York, NY
Greek Restaurant · Turtle Bay · 5 tips and reviews
Paola Venturini: Octopus, tuna tartar, and prosciutto and gorgonzola pizza. Sangria pitchers too.
Monday Lisa: Nice outdoor seating but food very over priced for what it is. BF got a Cuban that looked like a 5th grader made a turkey sandwich and it was $15 🙄
Elvi Rod: This place is really nice a the food it's excellent!!
7. Benoit Bistro
8.4
60 W 55th St (at 6th Ave), New York, NY
French Restaurant · Midtown East · 77 tips and reviews
Martin Hurst: Lobster salad appetizer is delicious!
Eater: The bar room is a cool place for after-work cocktails and hors d’oeuvres, and on the weekends, Benoit serves one of the best brunches in Midtown (it includes a dessert buffet). [Eater 38 Member]
nymag: The three-course, $25 lunchtime prix fixe menu is one of the better deals in midtown. And per Adam Platt, the signature tarte flambée is worth a special trip. Read more.