1. The Smith
8.7
956 2nd Ave (at E 51st St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Turtle Bay · 362 tips and reviews
Mike Kalen: Great spot in turtle bay. Call for reservations and ask for window seat. Try the deviled eggs!
DoubleDeuce: Great food. Great energy. Clean, trendy, hip, non-gender bathrooms with red lights and industrial hardware...everything you could want in a Turtle Bay outing!
Caroline Deng: Came here for a networking event, and the service is great! The hors d'oeuvres, especially the steak, are delicious.
2. Pennylane Coffee
7.9
305 E 45th St (at 2nd Ave), New York, NY
Coffee Shop · Turtle Bay · 44 tips and reviews
Project Latte: a NYC cafe culture guide: A much needed Turtle Bay shop, this design heavy shop serves Stumptown to consulates, the UN, and nearby residents that previously had to make do with Jittery Joes.
Jeffrey Sellers: Beautiful, simple design fitting the Midtown East and diplomat crowd well. Seats about 15 between the communal, table, bench & coffee bar. Stumptown coffee served right. Pastries looked good too.
Maria M: Stumptown coffee? Yes please!!! This place might save UN peeps from horrible cafeteria coffee!!
4. Hudson Malone
7.8
218 E 53rd St (by 3rd Avenue), New York, NY
Restaurant · Turtle Bay · 52 tips and reviews
Tony Xerri: Came here for casual drinks. Lots of suits but infinitely better than the trash over at Turtle Bar or any of the other bro bars. Good beer selection and a great old fashioned. Well done.
Andrew Doll: A chill, easy going bar that is equally good for an easy pint with the game, or a great cocktail with a date. Kitchens open late, as well as the bar!
Amy Leigh: Great new midtown east after work spot. Grab the lone table at the front, if available!
5. Fogo de Chão
8.5
40 W 53rd St (at 5th Ave), New York, NY
Churrascaria · Midtown East · 127 tips and reviews
Deon D: For “Restaurant Week“ some meats are taken out of the rotation – the ribeye, filet, and lamb shank. All the meats we tried were excellent. The service is top notch. Try the feijoada at the salad bar.
Claudio Souza: Add the price of the taxi to your expenses expectations because you gonna need one after eating like a king here.
Alex Borodach: It's simply an Eden for meat-eaters. Nice concept, friendly staff, very good salad bar, and of course unique way to try different steaks at once at a fixed price.
6. Sinigual
7.2
640 Third Ave (E 41st St), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · Midtown East · 91 tips and reviews
Brian Casey: The Perfect Patron margarita makes the fact that turtle tried to rep avion tequila for two seasons seem laughable
Andrew Fafoutakis: The Golden Margarita is a real treat and a great happy hour deal. Unfortunately no happy hour food menu. Beautiful space. A hidden gem.
Meli: Upscale Mexican food that's worth the price. Lobster quesadilla & chicken quesadilla are savory; guacamole is tasty and chunky; pineapple & mango mojitos are must tries. Will def return for more.