2. Treadwell Park
8.4
1125 1st Ave (E 62nd Street), New York, NY
Beer Garden · Upper East Side · 47 tips and reviews
Christine Casano: Try the banana split beer float!!
Amy Mixa: Great atmosphere, good beer, and Amazing bacon lollies!!!!!
Matthew Spector: Stellar new bar in the old Neary's space. A surprisingly spotless gastropub meets beer hall, with a great selection of pretzels, upscale mac and cheese and can't-miss smoked chicken wings.
5. Jacob's Pickles
9.2
509 Amsterdam Ave (btwn W 84th & W 85th St), New York, NY
Southern Food Restaurant · Upper West Side · 672 tips and reviews
Chelsea Balkan: I tried the fried pickles after seeing so many tips to get them but I wouldn't get them again. I guess I'm just not a fan. The chicken sandwiches, root beer floats, and caesar salad are all yummy!
Dan Geiger: Sprecher root beer on tap! It's like I'm back in Madison. Get the root beer float; you won't regret it.
Ed: Fried pickles, beer, atmosphere, meatloaf
9. Garden Cafe
7.6
4961 Broadway, New York, NY
Café · Inwood · 44 tips and reviews
Harrison Kratz: Try the Ice Cream Beer Float - Yes, this is a beer float. Most delicious thing ever.
Sofrito inmySoul: Loving the Beef and Barley Soup, pork chop, and pecan pie with ice cream at The Garden Cafe in Inwood #Inwood #goodfoodnyc #nyc
$$SexyJunglist$🏊🏊🐷🐷🍤🍤🌱🌱: Great food
13. Shake Shack
9.1
Madison Square Park (Madison Ave & E 23rd St), New York, NY
Burger Joint · NoMad · 1236 tips and reviews
NearSay NYC: Your burgerlicious destination in NYC for mind altering burgers and root beer floats!
Joon Licopit: burgers, fries, shakes, everything all gooood!
Time Out New York: Not to be missed: French fries dipped in salted caramel, a.k.a. the stuff stoner dreams are made of.