Attaboy is one of The 15 Best Places for Dark Rum in New York City.

1. Attaboy

9.2
134 Eldridge St (btwn Delancey & Broome St), New York, NY
Speakeasy · Lower East Side · 239 tips and reviews

Noah W.Noah Weiss: The best bespoke cocktails in NYC now? Sam Ross, the owner, created the Penicillin. Even if you don't like scotch, order it. Then get the "Ralphacillin", a riff with maple dark rum.

dsinskydsinsky: Apparently the owner (who bartends regularly) is the inventor of the penicillin and, unsurprisingly, his version is the best in the city. The imperial buck is also spectacular.

The New YorkerThe New Yorker: “Attaboy has no menu; you suggest a mood or a flavor and the bartenders improvise, which they do proudly or gruffly.” Read more.

Duane Park is one of The 15 Best Places for Dark Rum in New York City.

2. Duane Park

8.2
Duane St (at Hudson St), New York, NY
Park · Tribeca · 4 tips and reviews

liz s.liz s: 2nd oldest public park in the city

theluvelyraetheluvelyrae: Good Live Music and burlesque is hard to find. Brian Newman After Dark takes place on Fridays. Sip a cocktail at the bar and feel classy.

Kevin O.Kevin O'Neill: Keep an eye out for events happening here as they're often great. From small band performances to kids signing and dancing crews.

Jazz at Lincoln Center is one of The 15 Best Places for Dark Rum in New York City.

3. Jazz at Lincoln Center

9.1
10 Columbus Cir (at W 60th St), New York, NY
Jazz and Blues Venue · Hell's Kitchen · 27 tips and reviews

Cristiana E.Cristiana Elce: Good jazz music, good panorama

DHR.comDHR.com: If you love jazz, you will have the best time here. This venue at the Frederick P. Rose Hall is the place to watch remarkable performances and concerts. Three different listening spots are in store.

ArtemArtem: If you wanna go inside the club on Friday, make a reservation first, it's full

Shaking Crab is one of The 15 Best Places for Dark Rum in New York City.

4. Shaking Crab

8.2
2869 Broadway (111th), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · West Harlem · 10 tips and reviews

Chris M.Chris Maxwell: The Mac and Cheese is excellent. I get the newness and soft opening, but I want my meal on a plate with a knife and fork. The food and the service were great.

Marios P.Marios Panayiotou: Dominique Dominique Dominique!!! The best waitress i have ever met! She is the most sweet and loving person i have come across in New York (have been coming to the city every year!).

Nancy E.Nancy Elsamanoudi: Boil bags are awesome! This is a great place!

Dolly Varden is one of The 15 Best Places for Dark Rum in New York City.

5. Dolly Varden

8.2
302 W 51st St (btwn 8th and 9th Aves), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · Hell's Kitchen · 8 tips and reviews

Lina A.Lina Artista: We really enjoyed ourselves here. Found this place by accident while walking and were very happy with their cocktail menu.

Scott F.Scott Foster: It was a debut for my latest #Remix tonite!! #DJSet #DuaLipa

Quenna M.Quenna Mabry: Go with your Besties

Rose Theater is one of The 15 Best Places for Dark Rum in New York City.

6. Rose Theater

8.8
10 Columbus Cir Fl 5 (at 60th St), New York, NY
Jazz and Blues Venue · Hell's Kitchen · 28 tips and reviews

Peter M.Peter Marabella: We take our 8 and 3-year old here for Sat. Matinee concerts. Totally family friendly and really cheap fun if you subscribe to a concert package. Rose theater boxes make it easy to control little ones!

Jazz at Lincoln CenterJazz at Lincoln Center: Don't forget. The first 10 people to check in to Rose Theater tonight get a free copy of "For All We Know" by vocalist José James.

AMIAMI: Enjoy "The Music of Astor Piazzolla" featuring Paquito D'Rivera on November 11 & 12 at 8pm! Give us a shout (@AMIagency) when you check-in! #AMIbookings

Emmy Squared is one of The 15 Best Places for Dark Rum in New York City.

7. Emmy Squared

9.0
83 1st Ave (at E 5th St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · East Village · 32 tips and reviews

Jennifer Y.Jennifer Yu: The waffle fries are crispy perfection. And of course, the burger.

Elizabeth B.Elizabeth Burstein: Had a bite of bradys vodka from uber eats - delicious ! Bit salty though

L D.L D: Get the Broccoli salad!

Manolo Tapas is one of The 15 Best Places for Dark Rum in New York City.

8. Manolo Tapas

8.2
4165 Broadway, New York, NY
Tapas Restaurant · Hudson Heights · 27 tips and reviews

Christina D.Christina Dace: Really great Spanish beer and wine list, fresh seafood, cash only.

Ana U.Ana Urso: Great happy hour. Beautiful bar.

Michelle N.Michelle Nyemchek: Jordy the saxophonist is amazing as well! Very entertaining.

The Milling Room is one of The 15 Best Places for Dark Rum in New York City.

9. The Milling Room

8.9
446 Columbus Ave (at W 81st St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Upper West Side · 52 tips and reviews

Alex F.Alex Fish: Stunning and romantic spot. The rabbit pappardelle is on point

Zach H.Zach Hamed: Hidden gem on Upper West Side with American/Mediterranean cuisine. Chicken, risotto, and codfish all delicious. Beautiful high ceilings and old fashioned decor.

Tracy H.Tracy Hixon: The special cocktail of the day had a huge jalapeno flavored ice cube in it, try it! Tasty octopus, salads and pasta in a relaxed atmosphere

Emack & Bolio's Ice Cream is one of The 15 Best Places for Dark Rum in New York City.

10. Emack & Bolio's Ice Cream

9.0
1564 1st Ave (btwn 81st St & 82nd St), New York, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · Yorkville · 84 tips and reviews

Paige C.Paige C: New cereal soft serve and they make it fresh every time! 2 flavors. Don't miss it!

Anthony C.Anthony Ciolino: These people do things to Oreos that Paula Deen can only dream about

Tash C.Tash Concepcion: S'moreo! Best flavor of ice cream at Emack & Bolio's.

The Rum House is one of The 15 Best Places for Dark Rum in New York City.

11. The Rum House

8.7
228 W 47th St (btwn 8th Ave & Broadway), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · Theater District · 188 tips and reviews

Matt W.Matt Watson: Good whiskey and rum selection, live swing music

Scott M.Scott Monty: Great to find a place that knows what a Gin Buck is - and makes a good one!

Serious EatsSerious Eats: Swanky, consciously old-timey bar from the folks behind Ward III, with excellent cocktails and a never-predictable crowd.

Black Barn Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Dark Rum in New York City.

12. Black Barn Restaurant

8.3
19 E 26th St, New York, NY
American Restaurant · NoMad · 57 tips and reviews

Jamie D.Jamie Dumbill: Brunch burger with parm fries was delicious.

LaurenLauren: HAPPY HOUR Monday-Saturday, 4-6 pm & 9-11 pm | $1 Oysters | $1 Wings Half Priced Margherita Pizza, Meatballs, Mushroom Toast & Burger $5 draft beer | $7 Select Wine (Glass) | $10 Classic Cocktails

Jordan D.Jordan David: Duck, ribs, white pizza, oysters, cheese

Little Alley is one of The 15 Best Places for Dark Rum in New York City.

13. Little Alley

7.5
550 3rd Ave (btwn 36th and 37th Sts), New York, NY
Shanghai Restaurant · Murray Hill · 24 tips and reviews

Alex S.Alex Song: The xiao long bao is on point. The cumin lamb is great too.

Rock RainesRock Raines: Great addition to the neighborhood. Could eat here at least once a week.

LaurenLauren: I love their soup dumplings

Sweetbriar is one of The 15 Best Places for Dark Rum in New York City.

14. Sweetbriar

7.4
127 East 27th Street, New York, NY
Restaurant · Rose Hill · 3 tips and reviews

PouyaPouya: Burger and Maple Sour cocktail

Harris S.Harris Sokoloff: Great decor and vibe. Food and match the atmosphere.

Raj B.Raj Beharry: Get the Cornbread!

The Library at The Public is one of The 15 Best Places for Dark Rum in New York City.

15. The Library at The Public

8.1
425 Lafayette St (at Astor Pl), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · NoHo · 52 tips and reviews

Ms H.Ms Helene: Book ahead as every table and the bar was full on a show night. Brussel sprouts side,mussels appetizer and roasted beet with goats cheese salad were all good

The Wall Street JournalThe Wall Street Journal: Options include the pickle plate and marinated olives, as well as peekytoe crab rolls, which are more like sliders, and ruby red shrimp tacos. Read more.

Serious EatsSerious Eats: Solid menu of American classics and excellent cocktails; a great bet for a pre- or post-show meal.