Prince Street Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in New York City.

1. Prince Street Pizza

9.1
27 Prince St (btwn Mott & Elizabeth St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · NoLita · 372 tips and reviews

Hannah L.Hannah LaHood: Probably my favorite place to grab a slice. the pepperoni square is a must!

Ben K.Ben K.: One of the best slices in NYC: the square pepperoni. Also try the vodka slice.

No Leftovers J.No Leftovers Jackie Gebel: Pepperoni is a MUST!! It's the best pizza, square style!

Joe's Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in New York City.

2. Joe's Pizza

9.1
150 E 14th St (at 3rd Ave), New York, NY
Pizzeria · East Village · 175 tips and reviews

Darleny L.Darleny Lopez: I loved this one. The pepperoni pizza is to die for 😍 best pizza in town

Mel H.Mel Helama: Capres pizza and pepperoni pizza rock!

Rachel P.Rachel Port: One pepperoni one cheese 😍🍕

Lombardi's Coal Oven Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in New York City.

3. Lombardi's Coal Oven Pizza

8.1
32 Spring St (at Mott St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · NoLita · 534 tips and reviews

Katie F.Katie Flynn: Get a large pepperoni pie. The pepperoni's are the awesome small ones that curl up on the edges!

Patricia C.Patricia Clough: Worth the 30 minute wait if you're with out of town guests. The bruschetta was heaped w chopped, garlicky tomatoes. Get a large pie, and consider 1/2 pepperoni & sausage, 1/2 fresh ricotta. Super yum!

Alexa A.Alexa Alfaro: The best pizza to order is the double pepperoni.

Joe's Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in New York City.

4. Joe's Pizza

8.9
7 Carmine St (at 6th Ave), New York, NY
Pizzeria · West Village · 452 tips and reviews

Shawntini S.Shawntini Santiago: Fresh mozzarella w/ pepperoni... Little garlic, Italian spices& parm cheese. Is the way 2 go

Carol R.Carol Rood: Awesome slice of pizza!! Pepperoni was crispy around the edges, and cheese was hot and gooey! Yum!

Andy F.Andy Franco: Great NY thin slice pizza! The crust was great and you can't go wrong with any type of pizza. The pepperoni pizza is amazing!!!

Adrienne's Pizza Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in New York City.

5. Adrienne's Pizza Bar

8.1
54 Stone St (Mill Ln), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Financial District · 230 tips and reviews

Arielle G.Arielle Garcia: Pepperoni black olive is the best!

Mike C.Mike Chau: Try the Old Fashioned Pizza With Pepperoni, Sausage And Garlic

Mike C.Mike Chau: Try the Old Fashioned Pizza With Pepperoni, Sausage And Garlic - One of the best pies in NY

Mama's Too is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in New York City.

6. Mama's Too

8.9
2750 Broadway (106th Street), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Upper West Side · 38 tips and reviews

Eric G.Eric Gonzalez: You'll want to go back for more; there's no doubt about it. Get the pepperoni slice and expand your palate from there. For added value, watch the process unfolding behind the counter, not your iphone

Mike F.Mike Friedlich: Pepperoni Square slices are amazing. One of my favorite slices ever. The slices are nice and crispy, and the pepperoni is very tasty.

Alex R.Alex Robertson: Excellent square pepperoni slice—might make me appreciate Prince St. more (Made In New York na). $10 card minimum so you’ll have to get at least two slices and a drink without cash

Rubirosa Ristorante is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in New York City.

7. Rubirosa Ristorante

9.1
235 Mulberry St (btwn Prince & Spring St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · NoLita · 843 tips and reviews

Mike C.Mike Chau: Try the Vodka Pizza - With sausage and pepperoni. Cooked to order at the San Gennaro Feast

Kelly W.Kelly Williams: Awesome gluten free pizza and the pepperoni was amazing.

Lori L.Lori Luo: Super thin-crust pizza with a variety of toppings are served at Rubirosa. Try the Vodka variety, but the Supreme (with tomato, mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, and roasted garlic) is the best.

Made In New York Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in New York City.

8. Made In New York Pizza

7.9
421 Amsterdam Ave (at W 80th St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Upper West Side · 16 tips and reviews

Will H.Will Harahan: The spicy pepperoni is the slice to get here. Worth the trip if you’re not close by.

David A.David Ambrose: if you’ve experienced the prince st. spicy roni, give this one a try. similar and nearly identical pepperoni but needs a bit more sauce. overall solid.

E BE B: The Squares are all good the pepperoni is fantastic but the plain square may be better

Capizzi is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in New York City.

9. Capizzi

8.4
547 9th Ave (at W 40th St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Hell's Kitchen · 109 tips and reviews

Leah T.Leah Taylor: All you need to know is that they make their own pepperoni, red pepper flakes, and dried oregano in-house. PS: octopus carpaccio

Don N.Don Nguyen: Best pizza in town. Fresh ingredients and the pepperoni slices are thick and yummy!!!

Beth H.Beth Hauptman: Fantastic!! Best pizza I've had in years. Fresh ingredients, wood fired and absolutely delicious. The pepperoni is hand cut and yummy. Homemade sangria as well. Save room for the cannoli homemade too!

John's of Bleecker Street is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in New York City.

10. John's of Bleecker Street

8.9
278 Bleecker St (at Jones St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · West Village · 225 tips and reviews

Sinan A.Sinan Arkonac: Best pepperoni pizza in the city

DorouliniDoroulini: Freshly baked pizza! We ordered the large pepperoni and it was amazing! Old classic decoration.

Jarel H.Jarel Hill: So good! Classic my slice. Ricotta with basil was my favorite. Meatball was second then pepperoni

Bleecker Street Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in New York City.

11. Bleecker Street Pizza

8.3
69 7th Ave S (at Bleecker St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · West Village · 181 tips and reviews

Noah X.Noah Xifr: Yah nona maria but also the chicken pepperoni sausage all on 1 wow slice

Emmanuel H.Emmanuel H L: Great selection of IPAs; try the pepperoni and sausage, it will change your life!

Adam J.Adam Johnson: Great pepperoni pizza

Patsy's Pizzeria is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in New York City.

12. Patsy's Pizzeria

8.2
61 W 74th St (at Columbus Ave.), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Upper West Side · 65 tips and reviews

James S.James Sims: Damn good pepperoni pizza!

Ryan Scott T.Ryan Scott Tandy: Pepperoni, mushroom & olive 16" Stick to the basics. Hard to beat.

Jacob V.Jacob Van De Weert: White pizza with pepperoni. Do it.

New York Pizza Suprema is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in New York City.

13. New York Pizza Suprema

8.9
413 8th Ave (btwn W 30th & W 31st St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Chelsea · 343 tips and reviews

JinsJins: The pepperoni pizza is the best. Each slice is $4 but a while pizza is $25

Cezar L.Cezar Lenci: Pepperoni and Suprema Special are excellent.

Josh A.Josh A: Is there a pizza in New York which isn't delicious? The slice of pepperoni was solid.

Harry's Italian Pizza Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in New York City.

14. Harry's Italian Pizza Bar

7.8
2 Gold St (at Maiden Ln.), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Financial District · 139 tips and reviews

Dan T.Dan Taylor: Try the Old Fashioned Square with prosciutto, pepperoni, and meatballs and wash it down with a Peroni.

Kami S.Kami S: Brunch - Get the hangover pie! Pepperoni + fries + hot sauce on the side 😍

Mike C.Mike Chau: Try the Old Fashioned Pizza Pie With Pepperoni, Meatballs And Garlic

Vezzo Thin Crust Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in New York City.

15. Vezzo Thin Crust Pizza

8.7
178 Lexington Ave (at E 31st St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Rose Hill · 277 tips and reviews

Rio L.Rio Longacre: Thin-crust whole wheat pizza with pepperoni and mushroom is amazing. Took a friend who said it was "the best pizza he ever had." Wash it down with a Sixpoint The Crisp and you're good to go!

GOLDYGOLDY: Best Pepperoni In the game

D C.D C🐧: Amazing pepperoni pizza 🙌