1. Milk Bar
7.8
251 E 13th St (at 2nd Ave), New York, NY
Dessert Shop · East Village · 711 tips and reviews
S: Cereal milk soft serve with fudge and corn flakes is awesome!
Sana Currimbhoy: One of my favorite soft serve ice creams. The cereal milk is an exotic flavor and the crunch is a nice addition with the smoothness of the ice cream. It really does taste like cereal and milk!
Dina Fierro: The best. Nothing better. My favorites include the Cereal Milk Soft Serve with Crunch, Birthday Cake Truffles and the Corn Cookie.
5. Cha Cha Matcha
7.9
373 Broome St (at Mott St), New York, NY
Tea Room · NoLita · 132 tips and reviews
Caroline Deng: Matcha and Vanilla soft serve is delicious! almond milk matcha latte. They serve everything matcha, from matcha "doissants (donut and croissants) to matcha cupcakes. Cool interior.
Claire: Excellent matcha and try the soft serve. Note: soft serve portions are huge, worth sharing.
Jackson Isaacson: Cute AF, with delicious matcha soft serve and coffee. 9/10 for sure.
6. Taiyaki NYC
8.0
119 Baxter St (btwn Canal & Hester St), New York, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · Little Italy · 91 tips and reviews
Anissa: What's better than soft serve? Soft serve in a fish mouth! In this case, a warm cake with custard serves at the cone and makes for a delightful treat!
Honghui Yu: Delicious soft serve - recommend the matcha black sesame swirl
Tom: Ice cream goals. Delicious soft serve, snack on a wafer and mochi and you still have a taiyaki cake for your happy ending 😋
7. Milk Bar UWS
7.4
561 Columbus Ave (at W 87th St), New York, NY
Dessert Shop · Upper West Side · 113 tips and reviews
Amber Kho-Udom: Awesome staff <333 ordered the cereal milk soft serve and tipped it over :( staff immediately said "it was already tilting anyways" and gave me a new one for free!!! Ahhh :)
Ben R: The surprise corn flake crunch at the bottom of your soft serve is a thing of joy.
CCnyc: Cornflake marshmallow cookie, birthday cake, cereal milk soft serve
Daria: The cookies n cream soft serve is amazing. It's a gourmet mcflurry.
Real Cheap Eats: Try the Cookies and Cream Sundae ($6.95), which mixes crisp chunks of three types of cookies with vanilla bean soft serve. "Just make sure to share with one or two people; the portion is huge." Read more.
Mike Chau: Try the Michelle Obama Sundae - Shapely arms of salted caramel over clever vanilla bean soft serve in savvy espresso with a classy frost of pecan
9. Momofuku Noodle Bar
8.5
171 1st Ave (btwn E 10th & E 11th St), New York, NY
Ramen Restaurant · East Village · 849 tips and reviews
Jaeson Kim: pork buns, chicken wings, and the soft serve ice cream (olive oil & pickled cherry flavored) are amazing. noodles are great too, unique and not traditional. be sure to try the ginga kogen beer.
Grace S.: Pork kimchee tamale, pork buns, potatoes n poached egg(seasonal), momofuku ramen, soft serve, kimchee stew(off the menu)!
Mike Chau: Try the Peanut Butter Soft Serve - Wow, one of their best flavors ever. There's a generous helping of jelly as a surprise toward the bottom too.
12. Milu
8.7
333 Park Ave S (25th St), New York, NY
Chinese Restaurant · Rose Hill · 16 tips and reviews
Karen Chin: I have been trying a new dish every time I stop by and have liked each one. I love finishing off with the egg tart soft serve and getting salted egg potato chips to go from their pantry section.
Ryan Zhang 🤪: Egg tart soft serve
Joyce: Don’t get the egg tart soft serve… really doesn’t taste like egg tart, even though the puff pastry are a nice touch!
13. Seed + Mill
8.5
Chelsea Market, New York, NY
Dessert Shop · Chelsea · 24 tips and reviews
Chad Horner: an astounding variety of flavored halvah on display at this Chelsea Market newcomer - cinnamon, pistachio, cranberry, etc. try the tahini soft serve topped with a mix of different halvah!
Rachel B: Halva topped tahini soft serve
Dolci Key: Goats milk ice cream WITH toppings and white chocolate raspberry halva are incredible. Love this little place!
15. Milk & Cream Cereal Bar
8.1
159 Mott St (Grand Street and Broom Street), New York, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · Little Italy · 42 tips and reviews
Victoria U.: Best bang for you buck? Mixed soft serve and cereal. For those who like things not too sweet get vanilla, Cap'n Crunch, and strawberry syrup.
Ashley Chan: Delicious soft serve mixed with cereal and topped with candy. Cute place with dessert that definitely brings you back to your childhood! I enjoyed the regular combo w/ fruity pebbles & teddy grahams
ℳ𝒶𝓎♍: 5 stars because cereal and ice cream is the best thing I can ask for. I'm such a huge fan of cereal growing up and the ice creams here are legit. Build your own and enjoy🍦🍪