3. CupcakeStop
8.3
(See Twitter for current location), New York, NY
Cupcake Shop · SoHo · 20 tips and reviews
Orchid Liu: All about the Peanut Butter Cup Cupcake. The secret is in the frosting ;)
Rachel R: Yummy, homemade tasting cupcakes.
The Corcoran Group: Anything from their seasonal menu is spectacular, but this regular is vanilla butter cake, dyed a festive array of colors, topped with a swirl vanilla frosting and finished with rainbow colored sugar.
5. The Dutch
8.5
131 Sullivan St (at Prince St), New York, NY
New American Restaurant · SoHo · 457 tips and reviews
Babs Harrison: Don't miss the homemade pies. Chocolate peanut butter with peanut 'ice' today
Lauren T: The peanut butter ice box pie is delightful!
Halstead Property: A true foodie is no stranger to the Dutch, and we’re happy to report we were pleased yet again. This time we opted for the mouthwatering Peanut butter ice box pie with salted caramel ice cream.
7. Smile To Go
8.3
22 Howard St (btwn Crosby & Lafayette St), New York, NY
Café · SoHo · 140 tips and reviews
Stefanie Brückler: Must try: manouri cheese sandwich, ham sandwich, peanut butter cups, banana bread!
CCnyc: Breakfast burrito, peanut butter and jelly cookie
Marianna Zazzer: Moroccan meatballs ROCK. Kale salad and sweet corn are amazing.
8. Ground Support
8.5
399 W Broadway (btwn Spring & Broome St), New York, NY
Coffee Shop · SoHo · 507 tips and reviews
Remington Guest: Great muffins..an actual good bran one. Healthy!!! And the tiny peanut butter and jelly sandwiches are amazing. Sandwich happy hour is great. Wine is good too, go during happy hour for that.
Percolate: Great place to sneak an iced coffee and a mini peanut butter and jelly sandwich (on baguette no less) while you're walking around Soho. Also a good place to chill and do some work on the long benches.
Nick Gogel: Peanut Butter and Jelly!!!!!!
The Wall Street Journal: Mr. Ansel's interpretation of a Paris-Brest uses soft caramel, chocolate ganache and peanut butter cream. "It looks like a French classic," he said, "but it tastes like a Snickers bar." Read more.
New York Post: Try the Paris-New York, a traditional French pastry re-imagined as a tribute to the Snickers bar with dark chocolate ganache, peanut butter cream and salted caramel. Read more.
Eater: Cronut master Dominique Ansel unleashes a new pastry today: A "lobster tail" made from pretzel dough encrusted in Maldon sea salt, peanut butter & butter-crunch brittle, with honey brown butter. Read more.
12. Soho Diner
7.7
320 W Broadway (Grand St), New York, NY
Diner · SoHo · 15 tips and reviews
Kelsey✨: Cute & trendy diner, with an amazing grilled cheese, B.A.L.T., and modernized banana split
Paige C: Great chicken fingers but terrible fries.
Soho Diner: Snoozing past noon on Sat and Sun? Soho Diner's fan-favorite brunch menu features a wide selection of over the counter remedies to help you recover from your late-nite carousing. Served 'til 4PM!
13. Westville
9.0
333 Hudson St (at Charlton St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Hudson Square · 205 tips and reviews
Rachel Port: Always share a plate of market veggies, they're all so delicious!
Jen Berg: Biggest and brightest Westville location, same great menu. The Cobb is my go-to. Lemon dill dressing is out of this world. Side of fries to boot!
Alberto Mann: Oh and bring your Bose noise canceling headphones. Babies everywhere. Sounds like a bunch of dying pterodactyls in here.