Chick-fil-A is one of The 11 Best Places for American Cheese in the Theater District, New York.

1. Chick-fil-A

8.3
918 8th Ave, New York, NY
Fast Food Restaurant · Theater District · 4 tips and reviews

HowardHoward: Large and brand new. Plenty of seats. Best yet in nyc

Alison J.Alison J.: Great food. Don't let lines deter you. The team taking orders via iPads will get you in and out quickly.

Will H.Will Harahan: Terrific staff and great food.

Dunkin' is one of The 11 Best Places for American Cheese in the Theater District, New York.

2. Dunkin'

7.4
750 8th Ave (W 46th St), New York, NY
Donut Shop · Theater District · No tips or reviews
Stage Star Deli is one of The 11 Best Places for American Cheese in the Theater District, New York.

3. Stage Star Deli

7.8
105 W 55th St (btwn 6th & 7th Ave), New York, NY
Deli · Theater District · 13 tips and reviews

Pablo C.Pablo Castillon: All the sandwiches are great at this quintessential deli... But the cheesecakes are true New York.

Anisa A.Anisa Alhilali: Love the unlimited toppings salad bar. Lots of great options including grape leaves and small size is plenty big. And they also throw in cornbread free when they have it

New York Hilton MidtownNew York Hilton Midtown: Offers a varied menu making it a great breakfast or lunch stop on your way out of the hotel!

McGee's Pub is one of The 11 Best Places for American Cheese in the Theater District, New York.

4. McGee's Pub

7.3
240 W 55th St (btwn 8th Ave & Broadway), New York, NY
Pub · Theater District · 236 tips and reviews

TraciTraci: Get the sliders with american cheese - delish!Also, check out their website for the $4 beer of the month and daily drink specials.

Sol V.Sol Vargas: The "Best burger in NY" in the HIMYM special menu is literally the best burger in NY

Sherri F.Sherri Feldman: The writers of How I Met Your Mother modeled the atmosphere of McLaren's after McGee's.

The Bread Factory Cafe is one of The 11 Best Places for American Cheese in the Theater District, New York.

5. The Bread Factory Cafe

7.2
935 8th Ave (btw 55th & 56th), New York, NY
Bakery · Theater District · 14 tips and reviews

Alexandra L.Alexandra Levitas: Amazing assortment of all snacks and sandwiches. Good take out (go sit in Central Park) but also nice seating. Yummy pastries, good sandwiches.

NedNed: Superb plain cheese pizza slice

Jon M.Jon McHatton: Order before you check in!:)

Melt Shop is one of The 11 Best Places for American Cheese in the Theater District, New York.

6. Melt Shop

7.7
135 W. 50th St., New York, NY
Sandwich Spot · Theater District · 70 tips and reviews

Scott P.Scott Parmenter: Fried chicken sandwhich, shop tots and nutella shake is the way to go

Nick C.Nick Cruz: Delicous grilled cheese... tell the people that are working there that they are chessey and watch what happens :)

Kristina B.Kristina Baker: My favorite lunch spot!! Gluten free bread upon request and make sure you get the shop tots with a side of melt sauce!

Cranberry Cafe is one of The 11 Best Places for American Cheese in the Theater District, New York.

7. Cranberry Cafe

7.3
115 W 45th St (Btw 6th & Broadway), New York, NY
Deli · Theater District · 40 tips and reviews

Leemor Y.Leemor Yuravlivker: Make your own salad is a great value. They even have avocado :)

River G.River Go: bagels are so scrumptious!!!!

Stephen N.Stephen N: Reasonable prices, great food, cool upstaires seating area.

Pick A Bagel is one of The 11 Best Places for American Cheese in the Theater District, New York.

8. Pick A Bagel

8.0
891 8th Ave (at W 53rd St.), New York, NY
Bagel Shop · Theater District · 179 tips and reviews

Matt B.Matt Brooks: Their poppy seed bagels are amazing especially with a #3 breakfast special!

Brian M.Brian Michael: Nova Scotia Salmon on a Bagel with cream cheese. I die!

M.A. U.M.A. Unger: This place is the bomb. Bagels baked all day everyday. 20 types of spreads. Huge create your own salad bar. What's not to love.

Bobby Van's is one of The 11 Best Places for American Cheese in the Theater District, New York.

9. Bobby Van's

7.1
120 W 45th St (btwn 6th Ave. & Broadway), New York, NY
Steakhouse · Theater District · 35 tips and reviews

Munirah A.Munirah AlOqla: Best Steakhouse in NYC. Try the Steak A La Stone and the Shrimp Scampi 👌 I would definitely come back 😍👏👏

Fatima Al SlailFatima Al Slail: Get the Horeseradish Salmon! So good!

Jason D.Jason Denny: Best breakfast bacon/egg/chez sam'wich in midtown.

Shake Shack is one of The 11 Best Places for American Cheese in the Theater District, New York.

10. Shake Shack

8.8
691 8th Ave (at W 44th St), New York, NY
Burger Joint · Theater District · 855 tips and reviews

Armagan A.Armagan Aksoy: Best Burgers in the world.. Must be tasted double Shack burger😍😍

nymagnymag: "They have this thing called the 'Shroom Burger for the vegetarians," Miss USA tells us in her NY Diet. "It's just cheese inside a fried mushroom. Oh my God." Read more.

ZiyadZiyad: Best burger ever but u have to guard ur seat

Junior's Restaurant & Bakery is one of The 11 Best Places for American Cheese in the Theater District, New York.

11. Junior's Restaurant & Bakery

8.4
1515 Broadway (at W 45th St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Theater District · 725 tips and reviews

Zuss R.Zuss Ruvalcaba Gómez: The best cheescake I have ever tasted! the plain original cheescake is a must :)

BravoBravo: There is no substitute anywhere in the world for Junior's cheesecake. -Emily Sprissler, Top Chef

Allan T.Allan Tito: Junior's Steaks and Eggs for Breakfast must you have, Young Foodie . .