Tony's Di Napoli is one of The 7 Best Places for Chicken Marsala in the Theater District, New York.

1. Tony's Di Napoli

8.7
147 W 43rd St (btwn 6th & 7th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 235 tips and reviews

Dan M.Dan Manioci: The chicken Marsala is a must here. Always a lot, piled with mushrooms and sauce. So good!

Jenny K.Jenny K: We love the Caesar salad, chicken Marsala, and sausage and meatballs. Save room for their strawberry shortcake and sangria.

Rodrigo B.Rodrigo Barbaresco: Veal parmesian with spaghetti marinara was delicious, especially enjoying a glass of Tony's Chianti.

Olive Garden is one of The 7 Best Places for Chicken Marsala in the Theater District, New York.

2. Olive Garden

7.2
2 Times Sq (W 47th St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 292 tips and reviews

Madhav S.Madhav Srikanti: Chicken Marsala is to die for.. the Stuffed version is even better :)

Wladimir R.Wladimir Restituyo: Try the Chicken Marsala - Simply too much!

LaTina L.LaTina Lane: Stuffed Chicken Marsala isn't so stuffed anymore. First time I ate this dish the chicken was stuffed perfectly. Since then more than once the stuffing seemed to have disappeared....

Carmine’s Italian Restaurant is one of The 7 Best Places for Chicken Marsala in the Theater District, New York.

3. Carmine’s Italian Restaurant

8.9
200 W 44th St (btwn Broadway & 8th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 564 tips and reviews

Jay G.Jay Gress: DIP THE GARLIC CHEESE BREAD IN THE CHICKEN MARSALA OH MY GOD.

Nick M.Nick Marques: Everything is good. The garlic and oil with angel hair is the best. Pair it with chicken marsala.

DJ G.MAC!DJ G.MAC!: Come with your appetite! Best bet is for everyone in your group to agree on a dish and share! The portions are HUGE! The chicken marsala, and the angel hair pasta with garlic is delicious!

Starlite Deli is one of The 7 Best Places for Chicken Marsala in the Theater District, New York.

4. Starlite Deli

212 W 44th St (btwn 7th & 8th Ave), New York, NY
Deli · Theater District · 14 tips and reviews

Walter F. R.Walter F. Rodriguez: This place has good food for very cheap prices compared to the rest of Times Square. Great sandwiches and they've got pork roll! (aka Taylor Ham!)

Walter F. R.Walter F. Rodriguez: Broadway's best-kept secret. Good food, super-cheap in one of the most expensive parts of town. Their bagels and cookies are fantastic.

MeghanMeghan: I love Starlite, the folks who work here are great and service is usually speedy! Always stop here when I have to be in midtown early. Bagel w/cream cheese and coffee for 3.50? Can't beat it!

Mastro's Steakhouse is one of The 7 Best Places for Chicken Marsala in the Theater District, New York.

5. Mastro's Steakhouse

9.0
1285 Avenue of the Americas (at W 52nd St), New York, NY
Steakhouse · Theater District · 59 tips and reviews

Sem A.Sem Alghamdi: Bone in steak, lobster bisque, crab cake, and lobster mashed potatoes. Best steak I have ever tried.

Lee H.Lee Hoffman: The best filet mignon I’ve ever had. Get the bone in one it’s even better.

Nabil B.Nabil Bazzari: Have not been. Aboud Najjar recommends...appetizers sushi steak with wasabi mashed potato. Their Beverly Hills location is yummy.

Luigi's is one of The 7 Best Places for Chicken Marsala in the Theater District, New York.

6. Luigi's

936 8th Ave (btw 55th & 56th St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Theater District · 34 tips and reviews

Andy N.Andy None: Slices are very good; the dough is almost sweet. Garlic knots are excellent.

Kevin M.Kevin McDonald: Good thing Lennys was closed.....finally a place with bang for the buck! Meatball Parm was redonkulous!

Dana D.Dana Dee: Best chicken salad ever. Get it with Mozzarella.

Buca di Beppo is one of The 7 Best Places for Chicken Marsala in the Theater District, New York.

7. Buca di Beppo

6.7
1540 Broadway (btwn 7th Ave & 46th St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 42 tips and reviews

Nicole z.Nicole znu: Huge portions! Best spaghetti a la bolognese ever!

Dayron A.Dayron Arias™: I'm a great Italian food lover, however when it comes to taste a good pasta you should try this place. Although it's not traditional you'll still would love the Italian flavors :)

Luciana S.Luciana Silva: Large pizza is really large !!