Burger & Lobster is one of The 9 Best Places for Garlic Butter in the Theater District, New York.

1. Burger & Lobster

7.7
132 W 43rd St (6th Ave And 7th), New York, NY
Burger Joint · Theater District · 37 tips and reviews

EileenEileen: Shared the original burger, original lobster roll, lemon & garlic butter, truffle mayo, and calamari. Good but I felt it wasn't worth the price. Skip the calamari, rings were small

Kenan S.Kenan Sadayo: Original lobster roll is the way to go hands down

Jennifer G.Jennifer Graham: The lobster was awesome!

Beer Deck @ The Three Monkeys is one of The 9 Best Places for Garlic Butter in the Theater District, New York.

2. Beer Deck @ The Three Monkeys

7.4
236 W 54th St (btwn 8th & Broadway), New York, NY
Beer Garden · Theater District · 3 tips and reviews

ℳ𝒶𝓎♍ℳ𝒶𝓎♍: Coolest sports bar in midtown. It's a decent space with a dive atmosphere. Tons of beer available and the bar food was legit. Your typical favorites but with a little NYC love. Service was exquisite

Theresa R.Theresa Roldan: Good crowd, wings, and beer options...outdoor deck is not cold!

Kieron C.Kieron Crampsey: COMIN SOON!! Summer Sundays!! Cool Down inside or soak up the sun outside!! Special ALL day EVERY Sunday!! ALL SUMMER LONG!!

Russian Samovar is one of The 9 Best Places for Garlic Butter in the Theater District, New York.

3. Russian Samovar

8.4
256 W 52nd St (btw 8th & Broadway), New York, NY
Russian Restaurant · Theater District · 77 tips and reviews

Michael H.Michael Hussey: Relaxing atmosphere; very comfortable.

Zina Я.Zina Яkovleva: Best place for a get together or after work party. Live music sets the right mood, staff is amazing especially the bartender Pavel who is the core of a guaranteed fun night!

Cat C.Cat Cat: If you like tea- you must order the tea and stir in the cherry preserves it's AMAZING- especially paired with some of the cranberry infused vodka (my fav).

Gallaghers Steakhouse is one of The 9 Best Places for Garlic Butter in the Theater District, New York.

4. Gallaghers Steakhouse

8.8
228 W 52nd St (btwn Broadway & 8th Ave), New York, NY
Steakhouse · Theater District · 108 tips and reviews

Janut S.Janut Suchato: Porterhouse is one of the best in NYC. Their home made sauce is one of a kind. Fabulous presentation of the dry-aged beef room in front of the entrance.

ThrillistThrillist: All of the steaks are pulled from a gorgeous meat locker where they age their beef in full view, including a killer New York sirloin that's got a great, Earthy-yet-juicy flavor. Read more.

Steve H.Steve Heiner: Good burger, good steak sandwich good Bloody Mary, good service, good times, good day bitches

Cafe Un Deux Trois is one of The 9 Best Places for Garlic Butter in the Theater District, New York.

5. Cafe Un Deux Trois

7.6
123 W 44th St (btwn 6th & 7th Ave.), New York, NY
French Restaurant · Theater District · 87 tips and reviews

Will T.Will Tower: Featuring the best Quiche Lorraine in Manhattan I've had, Un Deux Trois is a Midtown lunch must.

Felix S.Felix Salmon: Wifi password is the phone number, 2123544148

Jose Luis R.Jose Luis Rochefort: Careful! They didn't make good on the offer of 2 glasses of wine for the price of one. Manager says "doesn't know about the promotion".

Guantanamera is one of The 9 Best Places for Garlic Butter in the Theater District, New York.

6. Guantanamera

8.0
939 8th Ave (btwn W 55th & W 56th St), New York, NY
Cuban Restaurant · Theater District · 173 tips and reviews

Crystal H.Crystal Hernandez: Been here multiple times, get something different every single time and loved every single thing! And the sangria is among the best in the city, if not The best...a must!

Jason L.Jason Lumpkin: Food is good, and there is a live band after 9pm every night.

Taylor W.Taylor Waltmon: Best cuban sandwich. Miami status

Brasserie Cognac is one of The 9 Best Places for Garlic Butter in the Theater District, New York.

7. Brasserie Cognac

7.3
1740 Broadway (btwn W 55th & W 56th St.), New York, NY
French Restaurant · Theater District · 77 tips and reviews

Fat E.Fat Englishman: Possibly the best croissants and pain au chocolate in NYC - closest to the real French thing you'll find. Makes this a must for breakfast

Random House P.Random House Publishing Group: Get the Chicken Salad. We call it the "magic salad" because it's so good.

Gilt CityGilt City: Over 100 cognacs are available by the glass—and many are used in dishes like salmon ceviche with endives and dill-and-lobster flambé with sautéed potatoes and green peppercorns.

Bubba Gump Shrimp Co. is one of The 9 Best Places for Garlic Butter in the Theater District, New York.

8. Bubba Gump Shrimp Co.

8.1
1501 Broadway (btwn W 43rd & W 44th St), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Theater District · 433 tips and reviews

Luciano S.Luciano Silva: Nice place to eat and enjoy good time with friends. We love the Mac & Cheese and the drinks like Strawberry Mango Chiller! Excellent service!

Bader A.Bader Alghamdy: You have to be aware of the movie story, as they have funny pop quiz about the movie you have to answer :-)

Matheus A.Matheus Arnellas: Run forrest: you're good. Stop forrest: you want service.

Red Lobster is one of The 9 Best Places for Garlic Butter in the Theater District, New York.

9. Red Lobster

7.5
5 Times Sq Fl 1 (at W 41st St.), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Theater District · 232 tips and reviews

Nostaljik KediNostaljik Kedi: A real American seafood restaurant...Warm and cozy ;)

C T.C Tully: Class class class. High end restaurant, a locals-only hangout, and a must see in New York.

David M.David Meyer: For you cheap-os complaining about the automatic gratuity and it being so "high". Newsflash. This isn't South Dakota. Cost of living sucks here and tourists tip shit or not at all. 18% is very fair!