54 Below is one of The 11 Best Places for Homemade Desserts in the Theater District, New York.

1. 54 Below

9.2
254 W 54th St (btwn Broadway & 8th Ave), New York, NY
Performing Arts Venue · Theater District · 45 tips and reviews

Concert Ticket AgencyConcert Ticket Agency: A must for all Broadway fans! From Ben Vereen to Patti LuPone. Food/drink minimum, but the small plates are delicious. Not a bad seat in the house, staff is very accommodating and performance-friendly

Andrea M.Andrea Mathias: The perfect place for a first date, catch up with friends, or just to slip away from reality for a while. Also, I will do bad things to get my hands on some of their truffle Mac & Cheese.

Kay B.Kay Burnett: Nice venue for music, good sound system, intimate room.

Lucille's Grill is one of The 11 Best Places for Homemade Desserts in the Theater District, New York.

2. Lucille's Grill

237 W 42nd St (between 7th & 8th Aves), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Theater District · 2 tips and reviews

Jessica H.Jessica Herbst-Thorn: Ehhhh, kinda blah. Jerk chicken too wet, shrimp and grits bland and @ $20 for a burger deluxe it shoulda been great but, ehhhh.

Mike B.Mike Barker: Free blues music 🎵🎸🎷🎼

Angelo's Pizza is one of The 11 Best Places for Homemade Desserts in the Theater District, New York.

3. Angelo's Pizza

7.2
1697 Broadway (53rd St.), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Theater District · 44 tips and reviews

Chris S.Chris Simon: Salad, sausage pizza & pasta always a solid lunch & stuffed as usual!

Examiner.comExaminer.com: Top eats for cheap in Midtown. Their brick oven pizza is what New York is all about. Read more.

Serious EatsSerious Eats: When you're already in Midtown, this is the perfect place for a casual meal.

Angelo's Pizza is one of The 11 Best Places for Homemade Desserts in the Theater District, New York.

4. Angelo's Pizza

7.9
117 W 57th St, New York, NY
Pizzeria · Theater District · 95 tips and reviews

AnnaAnna: Great pizza, friendly staff. Angelo's is on point.

Dustin G.Dustin Gavin: This restaurant is worth a visit. The pizza and pasta are perfect and arw the reasons why I stop in every time I'm in NYC.

TalalTalal: The taste and the look of the mozzarella cheese melting on top of their pizza make you cry every time you leave the place 😭

Sardi's is one of The 11 Best Places for Homemade Desserts in the Theater District, New York.

5. Sardi's

7.8
234 W 44th St (btwn Broadway & 8th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 102 tips and reviews

Kathryn P.Kathryn Phillips: A cup of after dinner coffee is worth it here! Really good coffee

Chris P.Chris Phillips: This place is a pre-theater tradition. Get a drink at the bar upstairs and dive into the free cheese and Ritz.

Maria C.Maria Costa: feel like an adult by ordering a martini

Pongsri Thai is one of The 11 Best Places for Homemade Desserts in the Theater District, New York.

6. Pongsri Thai

244 W 48th St (btwn Broadway & 8th Ave.), New York, NY
Thai Restaurant · Theater District · 70 tips and reviews

NickMackNickMack: Their Rad Na noodles are amazing. Quick service and very pleasant staff. The crispy banana fritters are delicious. Perfect end to a meal.

Serious EatsSerious Eats: Pongsri has a good selection of lunch specials, but you may also order from the extensive dinner menu at any time.

Rhea G.Rhea Galsim: I was a bit skeptical if the Pad Thai was good but it was ridiculously delicious!

Trattoria Trecolori is one of The 11 Best Places for Homemade Desserts in the Theater District, New York.

7. Trattoria Trecolori

7.2
254 W 47th St (btwn Broadway & 8th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 94 tips and reviews

Ashley A.Ashley A: Love the food and GREAT service. Staff was extremely polite and helpful. The best Fettuccine Alfredo with chicken (maybe because I was starving).

Court P.Court Passant: Great pre theater dinner!

New York HabitatNew York Habitat: Fantastic place for dinner around Times Square or if you need somewhere to eat before a show. Go for the classics here, we love the chicken parm.

Pazza Notte is one of The 11 Best Places for Homemade Desserts in the Theater District, New York.

8. Pazza Notte

8.0
1375 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Midtown East · 141 tips and reviews

JasonJason: Risotto de Funghi and Truffle Pizza are great, as is the Chicken Parmesan. Two for one martinis can't be beat! 🍸

KellzKellz: Truffle fries & 2 for 1 martinis. That's all!

NicoleNicole: Happy Hour-2 for 1 martinis and really delicious pizza.

Guy & Gallard is one of The 11 Best Places for Homemade Desserts in the Theater District, New York.

9. Guy & Gallard

240 W 40th St (btwn 7th & 8th Ave), New York, NY
Café · Theater District · 35 tips and reviews

Amrisa B.Amrisa Bhagwandin: Frozen chai lattes are amazing!

Tyshawna M.Tyshawna Maddox: No outlets to plug in laptop, but the whole wheat penne pasta is worth the trip!

Ville G.Ville Grahn: The breakfast omelettes are great and very reasonable priced ($ 4,95 for an omelette, potatoes and two toasts).

B.B. King Blues Club & Grill is one of The 11 Best Places for Homemade Desserts in the Theater District, New York.

10. B.B. King Blues Club & Grill

237 W 42nd St (btwn 7th & 8th Ave), New York, NY
Jazz and Blues Venue · Theater District · 163 tips and reviews

Meryl P.Meryl Pearlstein: Excellent chopped salad and shrimp cocktail

Concert Ticket AgencyConcert Ticket Agency: Come here for the blues, not the food. Bring cash for the beer bucket guy if it's crowded, you may never make it back from the bar!

VH1VH1: The best view is from either a booth or right up front. If you grab a booth, be sure to have the 38oz sharing steak. – Pete from One eskimO

O'Lunney's is one of The 11 Best Places for Homemade Desserts in the Theater District, New York.

11. O'Lunney's

145 W 45th St (btwn 6th & 7th Ave), New York, NY
Pub · Theater District · 134 tips and reviews

Ed F.Ed Figarsky: Shared the sliders and chicken pot pie. Oh yeah, and the wings! Nice place to wind down, drink up and get fed.

Kyle B.Kyle Baird: donell is an awsome bartender ask for him

Carrie B.Carrie Brown: I very highly reccomend. Great food, service & atmosphere. Owner Mr. O'Lunney bought us a beer and was very kind.