Ottomanelli Bros is one of The 15 Best Places for Extra Virgin Olive Oil in the Upper East Side, New York.

1. Ottomanelli Bros

9.1
1549 York Ave (at E 82nd St), New York, NY
Deli · Yorkville · 16 tips and reviews

Kathy O.Kathy O'Shea: All fresh meats, homemade lunch specials, soups, semolina bread is the best! Fresh pasta, dairy, eggs,one stop shopping!

Indigo O.Indigo Ortiz: Great deli! More bang for your buck. Plz support small family businesses.

Tinkerella66 T.Tinkerella66 Thats right!!!: Family has been coming here for way over 40 years !

Milano Market is one of The 15 Best Places for Extra Virgin Olive Oil in the Upper East Side, New York.

2. Milano Market

8.9
1582 3rd Ave (at E 89th St), New York, NY
Gourmet Store · Upper East Side · 43 tips and reviews

Marino B.Marino Boccuzzi: FANTASTIC SANDWICHES! Fairly priced and sandwiches are huge! Also has great Italian meats, cheeses, and food to buy there as well highly recommend!

Deep G.Deep Gujral: Make a custom sandwich from the fresh meats such as black Angus steak, country ham, or pastrami!! Amazing!

Matt H.Matt H: Best chicken cutlets, meatballs and broccoli rab I've ever had.

Tevere is one of The 15 Best Places for Extra Virgin Olive Oil in the Upper East Side, New York.

3. Tevere

8.0
155 E 84th St (Lexington), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Upper East Side · 9 tips and reviews

StevenSteven: Love this restaurant. Reserve early. Everything tastes great

IBCIBC: Veal scaloppine w lemon and white wine is the winner dish.

Joe S.Joe Serure: Best veal Milanese

Felice 64 is one of The 15 Best Places for Extra Virgin Olive Oil in the Upper East Side, New York.

4. Felice 64

8.4
1166 1st Ave (at E 64th St), New York, NY
Wine Bar · Upper East Side · 38 tips and reviews

Paige C.Paige C: Even during restaurant week, the options were wonderful and the portions were a great size. I had the mussels and I couldn’t even finish them! Really good bread and wine as well. Do a tasting!

Morgan G.Morgan Green: Best for wine and apps only. Main courses are average.

Laurent B.Laurent Bouin: Try the gnocchi ai fromaggi and a Montepulciano wine.

Juice Generation is one of The 15 Best Places for Extra Virgin Olive Oil in the Upper East Side, New York.

5. Juice Generation

8.6
1486 3rd Ave (at 84th St), New York, NY
Juice Bar · Upper East Side · 47 tips and reviews

Dat Nikka P.Dat Nikka Piff: Citrus super C is amazing! Must buy if you stop by. Long lines always but moves fast so don't be petrified.

Molly K.Molly Kadish: Peanut butter split smoothie is unreal but has tons of sugar. Switch out the raw agave for blueberries for the same sweetness with less sugar/cals!

George W.George Weisgerber: The Coco Acai bowls are delicious as well as the Peanut Butter Split smoothie. Look at their nutritional chart though; quite a few items on the menu with very high calories per serving.

Paola's Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Extra Virgin Olive Oil in the Upper East Side, New York.

6. Paola's Restaurant

8.2
1295 Madison Avenue (92nd St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Carnegie Hill · 33 tips and reviews

Scott H.Scott Hamula: Rigatoni with spicy Italian sausage and Puccini mushrooms, and lemon tart for dessert. Wonderful!

Alessandro P.Alessandro Piol: Good crowd despite what Anand says ...

Anand B.Anand Bhatia: Extremely old crowd

Citarella Gourmet Market - Upper East Side is one of The 15 Best Places for Extra Virgin Olive Oil in the Upper East Side, New York.

7. Citarella Gourmet Market - Upper East Side

8.2
1313 3rd Ave (btwn 75th & 76th St.), New York, NY
Grocery Store · Upper East Side · 37 tips and reviews

Johanna F.Johanna Fuentes: If you ever see sausage stuffing available in the deli section -- BUY IT! Usually only available around the holidays but amazing. Also excellent chicken ravioli.

Gossip GirlGossip Girl: Stock up on snacks—rocky road ice cream and granny smith apples for N, please—at this gourmet grocery store. (It Had to Be You) Read more.

Brett F.Brett Fromme: Even more expensive than Whole Foods! Go here for the best meat and fresh seafood. The best fresh pesto sauce anywhere!

Quattro Gatti Ristorante is one of The 15 Best Places for Extra Virgin Olive Oil in the Upper East Side, New York.

8. Quattro Gatti Ristorante

7.7
205 E 81st St (at 3rd Ave.), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Yorkville · 10 tips and reviews

Brian G.Brian Gioia: One of my favorite Italian spots from my Upper East Side days. The Rigatoni Della Nonna is amazing.

Christophe P.Christophe Pradier: Great service, chilled environment

Christophe P.Christophe Pradier: Rigatoni a la nonna is tasty

Luna Rossa is one of The 15 Best Places for Extra Virgin Olive Oil in the Upper East Side, New York.

9. Luna Rossa

7.6
347 E 85th St (btw 1st & 2nd), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Yorkville · 8 tips and reviews

JosetteJosette: Fried artichokes, homemade pasta, gluten free chocolate cake

Ladii D.Ladii Dimplezzz: Hands down one of my favorite italian restaurant. They are a bit pricey but trust me, once you try their food, it will all be worth it.

Lisa F.Lisa F: Excellent beef carpaccio, seafood over black pasta, fig gnocchi and creme brûlée.

Greek Eats is one of The 15 Best Places for Extra Virgin Olive Oil in the Upper East Side, New York.

10. Greek Eats

7.8
1229 1st Ave, New York, NY
Greek Restaurant · Upper East Side · 23 tips and reviews

Jon S.Jon Spiegel: A very good Greek gyro sandwich stuffed with French fries. Great clean atmosphere with a friendly staff.

Erica D.Erica Delaney: The kebabs are well seasoned and typically cooked to perfection. The spreads (all 4) are absolutely delicious. The halloumi with fig is a little sweet for my taste, but authentic.

Brian S.Brian Strauss: It’s like a healthy Greek MacDonalds. The hummus is good!

Anassa Taverna is one of The 15 Best Places for Extra Virgin Olive Oil in the Upper East Side, New York.

11. Anassa Taverna

8.4
200 E 60th St, New York, NY
Mediterranean Restaurant · Upper East Side · 56 tips and reviews

Jenny K.Jenny K: Delicious food, prompt service and wonderful atmosphere. Highly recommend the striped bass and walnut cake. A lovely new addition to neighborhood!

Jodi G.Jodi Goodman: Incredible restaurant very reasonably priced with a dope atmosphere. Even a dj. Also next door to bloomies and Dylan's candy bar :)

DaynaDayna: Phenomenal! Packed on a Tuesday! Ask for Demitrios and tell him Dayna said s'agapo

Sant Ambroeus is one of The 15 Best Places for Extra Virgin Olive Oil in the Upper East Side, New York.

12. Sant Ambroeus

8.8
1000 Madison Ave (btwn 77th & 78th St.), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Upper East Side · 94 tips and reviews

Chiquitita 🍭Chiquitita 🍭: Avocado toast poached egg, brioch and cornetti, espresso sant anbroeus, flourless chocolate

Junior R.Junior Richie: Amazing sea food risotto, better if u also order a glass of chardonnay!

New York HabitatNew York Habitat: A slice of Italy on Madison Ave, come here for your sweet tooth fix. Try the Sant Ambroeus - chocolate mousse cake with a chocolate custard center.

Amaranth is one of The 15 Best Places for Extra Virgin Olive Oil in the Upper East Side, New York.

13. Amaranth

7.8
21 E 62nd St (btw Madison & 5th), New York, NY
Mediterranean Restaurant · Upper East Side · 35 tips and reviews

WheelerWheeler: The Organic Sirloin Streak with Mixed Greens and Peppercorn Sauce is to die for...absolutely to die for!

Gossip GirlGossip Girl: A favorite of Upper East Side society, this café is where Avery Carlyle began her ascent to reign as Queen Bee of Constance Billard. (The Carlyles: Love the One You’re With) Read more.

Alexander G.Alexander Golubev: Found Amaranth after the first week @ Manhattan and showed it to my "future" NY living wife. We both have been delighted by the cuisine and atmosphere.

Bluestone Lane is one of The 15 Best Places for Extra Virgin Olive Oil in the Upper East Side, New York.

14. Bluestone Lane

8.7
1085 5th Ave (at 5th Ave), New York, NY
Café · Carnegie Hill · 93 tips and reviews

Sravanti T.Sravanti Tekumalla: The perfect place to people watch on the UES when it’s warm out. Get the half and half avo toast and granola!

Atticus L.Atticus L: I don't care if its because Jesus told them to... The service is unbeatable! <3

Eshrefe S.Eshrefe Shehu: This cafe is a very nice spot to visit in every season. Love that it's located in the annex of the church facing Central Park and near to the Guggenheim Museum. Avocado toast and coffee is delicious.

Mansion Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Extra Virgin Olive Oil in the Upper East Side, New York.

15. Mansion Restaurant

8.3
1634 York Ave, New York, NY
Diner · Yorkville · 65 tips and reviews

Wejdan ✨Wejdan ✨: Love the egg Benedict, some times I get it with turkey bacon and just as good. The waffle is so good!

Ruben B.Ruben Brosbe: The York Ave is without a doubt the best item on a very solid menu

Anna O.Anna Osgoodby: One of my favorite diners around the UES. The staff is great, the menu selection can't be beat and the food is delicious!