Magnolia Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in the Upper West Side, New York.

1. Magnolia Bakery

8.7
200 Columbus Ave (at W 69th St), New York, NY
Bakery · Lincoln Square · 280 tips and reviews

Danielle N.Danielle Nicole: Don't skip anything, get everything. Especially the banana pudding, cakes, cupcakes, pie, and hot chocolate. Oh and don't forget the cookies and dessert bars.

NooraNoora: Okay. You wanna know how heaven tastes like? Then try their red velvet cheesecake. Out of this world! The key lime cheesecake (pictured) was delicious too! Would go back, preferably every day.

Michael F.Michael Fox-Rabinovitz: Great cakes and muffins, incredible variety. Banana pudding still rocks

Peacefood Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in the Upper West Side, New York.

2. Peacefood Cafe

8.5
460 Amsterdam Ave (82nd St), New York, NY
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · Upper West Side · 218 tips and reviews

The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group: Non-vegans do not fear, this eatery makes delicious food that carnivores still like. We recommend the chick pea fries or the chocolate ganache cake – made with silken tofu

I A.I Amos: Yes, the chickpea fries are delicious. But also, the tempeh avocado sandwich, and also also also the carrot cake.

Daniel S.Daniel Schauenberg: The vegan cheeseburger and their carrot cake are both amazing

Milk Bar UWS is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in the Upper West Side, New York.

3. Milk Bar UWS

7.8
561 Columbus Ave (at W 87th St), New York, NY
Dessert Shop · Upper West Side · 113 tips and reviews

Liza S.Liza Solarz: The birthday cake truffle will change your life. 🙏

CarolynCarolyn: Everything is delicious! Order the cookies and cake truffles.

Leanne A.Leanne Alyssa: Cereal milk is super popular but it isn't amazing. Definitely go for birthday cake truffles!!

Silver Moon Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in the Upper West Side, New York.

4. Silver Moon Bakery

8.4
2740 Broadway (at W 105th St), New York, NY
Bakery · Upper West Side · 80 tips and reviews

David P.David Prince: Like the NY Times commercial, my wife likes the Blueberry scone and I like the wheatberry roll. Good King Cakes for Mardis Gras too.

NYU WagnerNYU Wagner: We've heard they have some excellent King Cake!

Zhen Z.Zhen Zhang: Definitely try the chocolate crusted cheese cake with fruits on the top

By the Way Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in the Upper West Side, New York.

5. By the Way Bakery

8.1
2442 Broadway (btwn W 90th & W 91st St), New York, NY
Bakery · Upper West Side · 31 tips and reviews

Felicia M.Felicia M: Fantastic cookies & cakes. Stump town coffee. Lovely owner. What's not to like? Get the sour cherry cake.

Ernie B.Ernie Bello: The mini bundt cake I had was so moist, excellent. Their baked goods are all dairy free.

HectorHector: The cakes are amazing! Try the raspberry lemon. Make sure to order at least 48hr in advance if you need a special cake - they usually have some available same day. Friendly staff :)

Nougatine at Jean Georges is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in the Upper West Side, New York.

6. Nougatine at Jean Georges

8.4
1 Central Park W (at Broadway), New York, NY
French Restaurant · Lincoln Square · 101 tips and reviews

Lady Gel @.Lady Gel @gastronomicas_: Impecable service & food! Try the restaurant week menu. Go for tuna tartare app, slow cooked salmon main, and hot chocolate cake des - totally worth it! I also enjoyed watching all the kitchen action.

J Z.J Z: Loved the parsnip soup with coconut and lime, slow cooked salmon, fusilli with mushroom bolognese and pecorino, and warm chocolate cake. Fluke sashimi was a little underwhelming in comparison.

Sarah E.Sarah E: Amazing foie gras appetizer, pumpkin cheesecake, and service and ambiance for business lunch or dinner. Impeccable french style seasonal dishes.

Breads Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in the Upper West Side, New York.

7. Breads Bakery

9.3
1890 Broadway, New York, NY
Bakery · Lincoln Square · 46 tips and reviews

Diane C.Diane Chang: Tunisian sandwich, chocolate rugelach, and cheesecake were all delicious!!!

BaturalpBaturalp: Everything is delicious and fresh here. I regularly get their burekas, cookies and cakes. Never disappointed.

Margarita K.Margarita Krup: Really good bakery. I love everything here but especially the cinnamon and raisin babka and the lemon cake.

16 Handles is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in the Upper West Side, New York.

8. 16 Handles

8.3
325 Amsterdam Ave (btwn W 75th & 76th St), New York, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · Upper West Side · 50 tips and reviews

Christopher C.Christopher Caswell: Say 'no' to the Cheesecake flavor.

Talia B.Talia Barkai: Heath and birthday cake are the best!!!

JohnJohn: I have tried every flavor 150 times. Whether you like fruity or creamy flavors; my favorite flavor is Angel Food Cake.

Alice's Tea Cup is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in the Upper West Side, New York.

9. Alice's Tea Cup

8.4
102 W 73rd St (btwn Columbus & Amsterdam Ave), New York, NY
Tea Room · Upper West Side · 205 tips and reviews

Vanessa A.Vanessa Arce: Yummy Carrot cake!

Katie Y.Katie Younger: Pink lemonade cake is to die for! Try it!

Joyce M.Joyce M.: Most adorable place ever. The albacore tuna and banana nutella cake are NOM NOM NOMMY. :) Perfect tea party place!

Levain Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in the Upper West Side, New York.

10. Levain Bakery

9.3
167 W 74th St (at Amsterdam Ave), New York, NY
Bakery · Upper West Side · 857 tips and reviews

Susie S.Susie Sitzer: Try the dark chocolate peanut butter chip cookie or even the coffee cake if they're out of their cinnamon rolls.

Mike C.Mike Campton: Walnut Choc chip, sourdough coffee cake and scones were all amazing!

Hong Kyu P.Hong Kyu Park: Banana cake and the scones are nice and moist, great with coffee. Should have named the place not Levain, but Devine

Coolhaus Ice Cream Truck is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in the Upper West Side, New York.

11. Coolhaus Ice Cream Truck

8.2
New York, NY
Food Truck · Upper West Side · 72 tips and reviews

Terri R.Terri R: So good! Flapjack/hot cake cookie with chicken and waffles ice cream!

Michael E.Michael Edison: Don't waste ur time w/the Vegan Carrot Cake cookie. It tastes just like an oatmeal cookie...nothing like actual carrot cake.

Kelsey L.Kelsey Lee: In the fall, get the pumpkin pie ice cream with pieces of real pie crust, sandwiched between the hot cake cookies - unbelievable.

Jean-Georges is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in the Upper West Side, New York.

12. Jean-Georges

8.4
1 Central Park W (btwn W 60th & W 61st St), New York, NY
French Restaurant · Lincoln Square · 286 tips and reviews

BellieBellie: This one is to stock up on some decadency. The dishes are great, made with care, and after you had their signature warm chocolate cake - you can stroll it off in Central Park.

Snileshsingh s.Snileshsingh singh: Order Cake in Ghaziabad @ http://www.cakengift.in/by-city/cake-delivery-in-ghaziabad-336.html , Order Cake in Faridabad @ http://www.cakengift.in/by-city/cake-delivery-in-faridabad-337.html

Co G.Co G: The lunch prix fixe is not that bad. I had the pache meatballs which was very filling and tomato soup. Chocolate cake is to die for! House made sodas are delicious. Waitstaff is very attentive.

Paris Baguette is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in the Upper West Side, New York.

13. Paris Baguette

7.7
2568 Broadway (btwn W 96th & W 97th St), New York, NY
Bakery · Upper West Side · 14 tips and reviews

Michael F.Michael Fox-Rabinovitz: Pastries cakes baguette

Shatha K.Shatha Khaled: Cheesecake!!!

Shahab M.Shahab Mansoorbaghaei: Chocolate cake, Strawberry cheesecake, Tiramisu

Maison Pickle is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in the Upper West Side, New York.

14. Maison Pickle

9.0
2315 Broadway (W 84th St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Upper West Side · 89 tips and reviews

Jeff S.Jeff Solomon: The French dips are sloppy but excellent. Try the Oreo cookie cheesecake for desert

Colin L.Colin Lee: Jacobs pickle is temporarily close because of a fire, hence they send ppl here. The lamb sandwich and Oreo icebox cake were great

AngieAngie: Don't sleep on the chicken & shrimp francese! Absolutely delicious. The sauce was buttery & amazing. The vanilla layer cake wasn't great, but I forgive them because the food & service were fantastic.

Malecon Restaurant II is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in the Upper West Side, New York.

15. Malecon Restaurant II

8.5
764 Amsterdam Ave (btw 97th St & 98th St), New York, NY
Latin American Restaurant · Upper West Side · 44 tips and reviews

Johanna F.Johanna Fuentes: So many great things to order - where to begin. The roast chicken of course. Incredibly authentic and delicious. Pork mofongo is great (with the sauce). Try the Tres Leches for dessert, one of the bes

José L. R.José L. Rodriguez: The rotisserie chicken is by far the best in the city. Another item not to be missed is the Tres Leches dessert. It is so good you'll flip after tasting it.

Greg L.Greg Levitt: Solid all around fare. Mofongo is very good.