1. Osteria Cotta
7.9
513 Columbus Ave (btwn W 84th & W 85th St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Upper West Side · 174 tips and reviews
Solly Golbert: I like this place.... Great vibes, good pizza, outside searing, and nice wine selection. Dare I call it an upper west side gem?
Duncan Howsley: The Tartufo pizza with truffle oil is fantastic, as is the Nutella & ricotta calzone. Well worth visiting this place if you're in the UWS and looking for something different to a standard Italian.
Sammy L: The bruschetta the margarita pizza the Nutella calzone were all fantastic
2. Patsy's Pizzeria
8.0
61 W 74th St (at Columbus Ave.), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Upper West Side · 65 tips and reviews
Molly Yanity: Great, affordable Italian food. Even if there's a wait for two, get to the bar, share a salad, a pasta dish or pizza, and a bottle of wine and you will be satisfied and happy.
James Sahagian: Great pizza and salads with family. Friendly service in a casual atmosphere. Quite reasonable given its great location and proximity to Central Park.
Mike Friedlich: Amazing place. Plain Pizza is in top 3 favorite NYC pizzas & the caesar salad with salmon is outstanding. They give u a full piece of salmon with the salad, & it is the best salmon ive ever had.
3. Sal & Carmine's Pizza
7.7
2671 Broadway (between 101 & 102 Streets), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Upper West Side · 80 tips and reviews
Asher Sarnoff: Grew up here, had the best pizza all over, to me, this is the best pie I ever had. Period. Made by real Italians who have done it all their lives. DA BEST!!!
Alexandra Tritz: The pizza is awesome ! A little salty but it doesn't really matter, it's cheap and delicious and made in front of you !
Alex Robertson: the dough is just incredible, as is the organic feel of all the ingredients. the best pizza on the UWS, absolutely--and right next to xi'an famous foods!
4. Mama's Too
8.8
2750 Broadway (106th Street), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Upper West Side · 38 tips and reviews
Reagan Barbosa: New pizza spot in the neighborhood and it’s amazing. The thick, square slice of Sicilian style pepperoni was incredible. The best pizza place we have this area now.
Josh Loomis: some of the best pizza in the city. lucky to be walking distance from mamas too.
Michal Palmon: Amazing pizza. We tried the pear and blue cheese, cesse de peppe and margarita and they all were really good. Can’t wait to go back
6. Celeste
8.2
502 Amsterdam Ave (btwn W 84th & W 85th St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Upper West Side · 124 tips and reviews
ReALTO: Reasonably priced, high quality, delicious Italian--a gem of a restaurant nestled on a quiet stretch of Amsterdam Avenue. The homemade pasta is perfectly al-dente and the wood fired pizza is divine... Read more.
Omar Haroun: Authentic, cozy Italian restaurant. Everything we had was amazing, in particular the veal special, the hand-made pasta, and the napoletana pizza. Great manhattan dining w/out the manhattan prices
Lior Yanay: Super authentic Italian food! The pasta is great, but the pizza is amazing. One of the best sauces I had. The tiramisu is very good and not too sweet. Cash only, so come prepared.
Daniel M.: Get the Mezze sampler platter and an artichoke pizza. The bread is fantastic. One of the best mediterranean/middle eastern spots on the west side.
Nicole: Delicious moussaka, lamb tagine, and thin-crust pizzas. Outdoor seating as well as semi-outdoor tables. Kid-friendly, but no kids menu. The bread they bring out is warm and chewy/crispy. Perfect.
Joe Bramhall: Great place to sit outside, enjoy pizza and wine.
8. Cafe Fiorello
8.0
1900 Broadway (at W 63rd St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Lincoln Square · 145 tips and reviews
Andrea Hong: First, make an opentable res bc this place is a Lincoln Center zoo. Then, get poured champagne upon arrival, fed passed freshly baked cookies, and stuffed on thin crust pizza (prosciutto + arugula!).
Martin Hurst: Amazing thin crust pizzas - the meat supreme is out of this world. And the antipasto bar is full of amazing dishes: shrimp and scallop salad, lentil salad, burrata, roasted fennel. It's all amazing!
Bruna Martinelli: Pizza + chocolate mousse are awesome. Service, not so much.
9. Cafe Viva Gourmet Pizza
7.6
2578 Broadway, New York, NY 10025, United States (97th street), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Upper West Side · 27 tips and reviews
Crystal Scott: GREAT vegetarian and vegan pizza. My favorite is the Zen pizza. Their desserts are awesome, too.
Luisa Motta: Good, delicious, organic pizza. They have vegan & vegetarian pizza too! I had a slice of Bella - pesto sauce, mozzarella, spinach, onions & feta cheese. Delicious!
Rowan Quirk: Best vegan pizza that I've had in the city!
11. La Traviata
7.3
101 W 68th St (btwn Columbus Ave & Broadway), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Lincoln Square · 28 tips and reviews
Matty Magnin: The buffalo chicken pizza is fantastic, don't forget to add a side of blue cheese for dipping. They also don't have a minimum for credit cards. Great place overall.
Nick S: Small, hole-in-the-wall place- but the best pizza on the Upper West Side!
The Corcoran Group: A dumpy, hole-in-the-wall serving delicious slices of pizza (get two slices and a can of soda for $5). The Chicken Parmesan sandwich is big enough for two – order extra sauce.