Osteria Cotta is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

1. Osteria Cotta

8.9
513 Columbus Ave (btwn W 84th & W 85th St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Upper West Side · 157 tips and reviews

Duncan H.Duncan Howsley: The Tartufo pizza with truffle oil is fantastic, as is the Nutella & ricotta calzone. Well worth visiting this place if you're in the UWS and looking for something different to a standard Italian.

Danielle L.Danielle Landau: Rucola pizza with mozarella, cherry tomatoes, and arugula is excellent. Super thin crust and well dressed arugula!!

Thomas P.Thomas Pajor: The Pizza Rucola with a side of Brussels Sprouts was delicious and a perfectly sized dinner for a single person.

Patsy's Pizzeria is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

2. Patsy's Pizzeria

8.3
61 W 74th St (at Columbus Ave.), New York, NY
Pizza Place · Upper West Side · 55 tips and reviews

Alexandra L.Alexandra Ling: the portion sizes were larger than expected. order the insalate de argula salad & a pizza to keep you full and refreshed!

Mike F.Mike Friedlich: Amazing place. Plain Pizza is in top 3 favorite NYC pizzas & the caesar salad with salmon is outstanding. They give u a full piece of salmon with the salad, & it is the best salmon ive ever had.

Ann D.Ann Donnelly: More than just pizza - we also had salads, pasta and meat dishes - all very good.

Pizzeria Sirenetta is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

3. Pizzeria Sirenetta

9.2
568 Amsterdam Avenue (W 87th Street), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Upper West Side · 22 tips and reviews

Michelle MarieMichelle Marie: Pizzas are absolutely solid. Love the spinach/garlic/fontina/hot pepper pizza, chopped clams pizza and fennel sausage pizza.

Garrett B.Garrett Bailey: Pea salad fantastic, the pizza crust and sauce were perfect, highly recommend!

Cat M.Cat Meirelles Buchatskiy: $10 pizzas at happy hour! Great price for high quality Neapolitan pizzas. Crust was amazing - so soft and doughy.

Sal & Carmine's Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

4. Sal & Carmine's Pizza

8.3
2671 Broadway (between 101 & 102 Streets), New York, NY
Pizza Place · Upper West Side · 74 tips and reviews

Helen P.Helen Phillips: Amazing pizza...good n salty!

Asher S.Asher Sarnoff: Grew up here, had the best pizza all over, to me, this is the best pie I ever had. Period. Made by real Italians who have done it all their lives. DA BEST!!!

Alexandra T.Alexandra Tritz: The pizza is awesome ! A little salty but it doesn't really matter, it's cheap and delicious and made in front of you !

Celeste is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

5. Celeste

8.8
502 Amsterdam Ave (btwn W 84th & W 85th St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Upper West Side · 122 tips and reviews

Dustin W.Dustin Wingate: This place is simply amazing! Fantastic food (I recommend the Margarita pizza), fantastic service, and a fantastic experience. The owner is terrific and this place easy acquires its five star rating!

Omar H.Omar Haroun: Authentic, cozy Italian restaurant. Everything we had was amazing, in particular the veal special, the hand-made pasta, and the napoletana pizza. Great manhattan dining w/out the manhattan prices

JP P.JP Park: Great for dates, we came for brunch and the French toast was delicious. Skip the eggs. Will definitely be coming back for pizza and pasta

Cafe Fiorello is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

6. Cafe Fiorello

8.1
1900 Broadway (at W 63rd St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Lincoln Square · 121 tips and reviews

Caitlin C.Caitlin Clements: Margherita Pizza and Chocolate Mousse = perfection

Andrea H.Andrea Hong: First, make an opentable res bc this place is a Lincoln Center zoo. Then, get poured champagne upon arrival, fed passed freshly baked cookies, and stuffed on thin crust pizza (prosciutto + arugula!).

Martin H.Martin Hurst: Amazing thin crust pizzas - the meat supreme is out of this world. And the antipasto bar is full of amazing dishes: shrimp and scallop salad, lentil salad, burrata, roasted fennel. It's all amazing!

Freddie & Pepper's Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

7. Freddie & Pepper's Pizza

7.4
303 Amsterdam Ave (btw 73rd & 74th St), New York, NY
Pizza Place · Upper West Side · 52 tips and reviews

Keith W.Keith W: Best whole wheat pizza in city!!

Chuck W.Chuck Westfall: This is a great place for NY-style thin crust pizza by the slice, but by all means order a full pie if you can share it with friends or family. Great taste at affordable prices!

Amie R.Amie Romano: bomb buffalo chicken pizza and perfect location next to levain for dessert afterwards ;)

Bodrum Mediterranean Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

8. Bodrum Mediterranean Restaurant

8.3
584 Amsterdam Ave (at W 88th St), New York, NY
Turkish Restaurant · Upper West Side · 44 tips and reviews

Daniel M.Daniel M.: Get the Mezze sampler platter and an artichoke pizza. The bread is fantastic. One of the best mediterranean/middle eastern spots on the west side.

NicoleNicole: Delicious moussaka, lamb tagine, and thin-crust pizzas. Outdoor seating as well as semi-outdoor tables. Kid-friendly, but no kids menu. The bread they bring out is warm and chewy/crispy. Perfect.

Joe B.Joe Bramhall: Great place to sit outside, enjoy pizza and wine.

Motorino is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

9. Motorino

8.2
510 Columbus Ave, New York, NY
Pizza Place · Upper West Side · 14 tips and reviews

Joe B.Joe Bramhall: Meatballs to die for! Great pizza! Thank you Motorino for coming to our neighborhood.

Mark L.Mark Lee: Amazing Neapolitan style pizza that comes from a wood fired brick oven. Try the clam pizza!

Cristina S.Cristina Salz: Fabulous pizza

Cafe Viva Gourmet Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

10. Cafe Viva Gourmet Pizza

8.0
2578 Broadway (97th street), New York, NY
Pizza Place · Upper West Side · 26 tips and reviews

Natalie B.Natalie Baby: best whole wheat pizza in town.

Crystal S.Crystal Scott: GREAT vegetarian and vegan pizza. My favorite is the Zen pizza. Their desserts are awesome, too.

Luisa M.Luisa Motta: Good, delicious, organic pizza. They have vegan & vegetarian pizza too! I had a slice of Bella - pesto sauce, mozzarella, spinach, onions & feta cheese. Delicious!

Two Boots Upper West Side is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

11. Two Boots Upper West Side

7.4
2547 Broadway (btw 95th St & 96th St), New York, NY
Pizza Place · Upper West Side · 37 tips and reviews

Jen M.Jen Mata-McMahon: The best pizza in town Try the Newman!

Alex S.Alex Stein: Try the Sicilian Pizza - Delicious, and only $.25 more than a regular slice!

Nancy L.Nancy Lafontant-Whiting: Love this place and unique pizzas. The "grandma Bessie " is great. They don't cook it to death like other pizzerias.

Bettola is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

12. Bettola

7.5
412 Amsterdam Ave (btwn W 79th & 80th Sts), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Upper West Side · 25 tips and reviews

EstellaEstella: great traditional pizzas! lovely bases

Jon D.Jon Dube: Best pizza on UWS

Lauren I.Lauren Ianuzi: very cute place on UWS with delicious wood fired pizzas, wide selection of wine by the bottle, but not by the glass. desserts were great as well.

Numero 28 Cucina is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

13. Numero 28 Cucina

8.2
660 Amsterdam Ave (Btwn 92nd & 93rd), New York, NY
Pizza Place · Upper West Side · 14 tips and reviews

Jane L.Jane Lubart: Authentic Napolitan pizza on the U W S. We will be back.

Spencer A.Spencer Ante: It's pricey but worth it if you are in the mood for a little upscale thin crust pizza

Seth B.Seth Borus: The best pizza on the UWS hands-down!!! And the food is great too. No contest.

Macchina is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

14. Macchina

7.4
2758 Broadway (W.106th street), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Manhattan Valley · 13 tips and reviews

Stephanie W.Stephanie Wu: highly recommend the spinach pizza. each pizza is cut into 4 small slices so it's perfect for one person. good selection of $12 cocktails as well.

Christine S.Christine Shepherd: Fresh ingredients. Enjoyed the tomato salad, and of course a pizza!

JP P.JP Park: Pizza and meatball appetizer every time. It's a bit pricey but good for a nice night out

Noi Due is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

15. Noi Due

8.1
143 W 69th St (at Broadway), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Lincoln Square · 26 tips and reviews

Craig E.Craig Elimeliah: Amazing iced coffee. Pizza is heaven.

Alexander T.Alexander Taub: Food is delicious. Dream of the pizza and the tomato sauce that is to die for!

The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group: Not the most authentic Italian restaurant, but if you’re keeping Kosher, it’s a must! Start with the Sigari, the Arugula & Gorgonzola Salad and the Napoletana pizza.