Osteria Cotta is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

1. Osteria Cotta

8.8
513 Columbus Ave (btwn W 84th & W 85th St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Upper West Side · 146 tips and reviews

Rory P.Rory Parness: The arancini are some of the best I've had and a good warm up while you wait for your pizza appetizer. Share a couple of fresh pastas and sides (cauliflower is excellent) and save room for dessert

Duncan H.Duncan Howsley: The Tartufo pizza with truffle oil is fantastic, as is the Nutella & ricotta calzone. Well worth visiting this place if you're in the UWS and looking for something different to a standard Italian.

Danielle L.Danielle Landau: Rucola pizza with mozarella, cherry tomatoes, and arugula is excellent. Super thin crust and well dressed arugula!!

Sal & Carmine's Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

2. Sal & Carmine's Pizza

8.3
2671 Broadway (between 101 & 102 Streets), New York, NY
Pizza Place · Upper West Side · 70 tips and reviews

Glenn Y.Glenn Young: I love the pizza here--always good.

Asher S.Asher Sarnoff: Grew up here, had the best pizza all over, to me, this is the best pie I ever had. Period. Made by real Italians who have done it all their lives. DA BEST!!!

Alexandra T.Alexandra Tritz: The pizza is awesome ! A little salty but it doesn't really matter, it's cheap and delicious and made in front of you !

Pizzeria Sirenetta is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

3. Pizzeria Sirenetta

9.0
568 Amsterdam Avenue (W 87th Street), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Upper West Side · 18 tips and reviews

Michael F.Michael Fox-Rabinovitz: Great neighborhood place, focus is on creative pizza and pasta, super friendly staff

Michelle MarieMichelle Marie: Pizzas are absolutely solid. Love the spinach/garlic/fontina/hot pepper pizza, chopped clams pizza and fennel sausage pizza.

Garrett B.Garrett Bailey: Pea salad fantastic, the pizza crust and sauce were perfect, highly recommend!

Patsy's Pizzeria is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

4. Patsy's Pizzeria

8.1
61 W 74th St (at Columbus Ave.), New York, NY
Pizza Place · Upper West Side · 48 tips and reviews

Nataneh S.Nataneh Schechter: order the fried eggplant and zucchini and schmooze over some wine, while you wait for some of the best pizza you'll ever eat.

Molly Y.Molly Yanity: Great, affordable Italian food. Even if there's a wait for two, get to the bar, share a salad, a pasta dish or pizza, and a bottle of wine and you will be satisfied and happy.

Alexandra L.Alexandra Ling: the portion sizes were larger than expected. order the insalate de argula salad & a pizza to keep you full and refreshed!

Celeste is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

5. Celeste

8.8
502 Amsterdam Ave (btwn W 84th & W 85th St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Upper West Side · 121 tips and reviews

Dustin W.Dustin Wingate: This place is simply amazing! Fantastic food (I recommend the Margarita pizza), fantastic service, and a fantastic experience. The owner is terrific and this place easy acquires its five star rating!

ReALTOReALTO: Reasonably priced, high quality, delicious Italian--a gem of a restaurant nestled on a quiet stretch of Amsterdam Avenue. The homemade pasta is perfectly al-dente and the wood fired pizza is divine... Read more.

Omar H.Omar Haroun: Authentic, cozy Italian restaurant. Everything we had was amazing, in particular the veal special, the hand-made pasta, and the napoletana pizza. Great manhattan dining w/out the manhattan prices

Grandaisy Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

6. Grandaisy Bakery

8.2
176 W 72nd St (at Amsterdam Ave), New York, NY
Bakery · Lincoln Square · 44 tips and reviews

Roger S.Roger Schonfeld: The pizzas are excellent... try the bianca and the pecorino, but the cauliflower is my favorite.

Lisa P.Lisa Paravano: fave double macchiato & delish roman pizza..

Chelsea B.Chelsea Balkan: Such a cute place. Great paninis and pizza. The cavolfiore pizza, bresaola panini and sopressetta panini are some of my favorite

Cafe Fiorello is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

7. Cafe Fiorello

8.1
1900 Broadway (at W 63rd St), New York, NY
Pizza Place · Lincoln Square · 121 tips and reviews

Jonathan G.Jonathan Goldberg: Chocolate mousse is awesome! Between November & December they have an amazing truffle pizza

Caitlin C.Caitlin Clements: Margherita Pizza and Chocolate Mousse = perfection

Andrea H.Andrea Hong: First, make an opentable res bc this place is a Lincoln Center zoo. Then, get poured champagne upon arrival, fed passed freshly baked cookies, and stuffed on thin crust pizza (prosciutto + arugula!).

Freddie & Pepper's Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

8. Freddie & Pepper's Pizza

7.3
303 Amsterdam Ave (btw 73rd & 74th St), New York, NY
Pizza Place · Upper West Side · 51 tips and reviews

Chuck W.Chuck Westfall: This is a great place for NY-style thin crust pizza by the slice, but by all means order a full pie if you can share it with friends or family. Great taste at affordable prices!

Amie R.Amie Romano: bomb buffalo chicken pizza and perfect location next to levain for dessert afterwards ;)

Madeline M.Madeline McDavid: Best New York style pizza on the UWS. Classics are great, but their bacon pizza is to die for.

Bodrum Mediterranean Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

9. Bodrum Mediterranean Restaurant

8.3
584 Amsterdam Ave (at W 88th St), New York, NY
Turkish Restaurant · Upper West Side · 43 tips and reviews

Daniel M.Daniel M.: Get the Mezze sampler platter and an artichoke pizza. The bread is fantastic. One of the best mediterranean/middle eastern spots on the west side.

Beth B.Beth Bates: Get the merguez sausage thin crust pizza--the combo of fennel with the lamb sausage is delicious.

NicoleNicole: Delicious moussaka, lamb tagine, and thin-crust pizzas. Outdoor seating as well as semi-outdoor tables. Kid-friendly, but no kids menu. The bread they bring out is warm and chewy/crispy. Perfect.

Two Boots Upper West Side is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

10. Two Boots Upper West Side

7.4
2547 Broadway (btw 95th St & 96th St), New York, NY
Pizza Place · Upper West Side · 34 tips and reviews

Jen M.Jen Mata-McMahon: The best pizza in town Try the Newman!

Alex S.Alex Stein: Try the Sicilian Pizza - Delicious, and only $.25 more than a regular slice!

Nancy L.Nancy Lafontant-Whiting: Love this place and unique pizzas. The "grandma Bessie " is great. They don't cook it to death like other pizzerias.

Numero 28 Cucina is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

11. Numero 28 Cucina

8.3
660 Amsterdam Ave (Btwn 92nd & 93rd), New York, NY
Pizza Place · Upper West Side · 13 tips and reviews

Jane L.Jane Lubart: Authentic Napolitan pizza on the U W S. We will be back.

Spencer A.Spencer Ante: It's pricey but worth it if you are in the mood for a little upscale thin crust pizza

Seth B.Seth Borus: The best pizza on the UWS hands-down!!! And the food is great too. No contest.

Motorino is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

12. Motorino

8.1
510 Columbus Ave, New York, NY
Pizza Place · Upper West Side · 9 tips and reviews

Joe B.Joe Bramhall: Meatballs to die for! Great pizza! Thank you Motorino for coming to our neighborhood.

Mark L.Mark Lee: Amazing Neapolitan style pizza that comes from a wood fired brick oven. Try the clam pizza!

Cristina S.Cristina Salz: Fabulous pizza

Cafe Viva Gourmet Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

13. Cafe Viva Gourmet Pizza

7.7
2578 Broadway (97th street), New York, NY
Pizza Place · Upper West Side · 22 tips and reviews

Rosalind S.Rosalind Streeter: Really good vegetarian and vegan pizza. Not much more expensive than the famiglia up the street!

Natalie B.Natalie Baby: best whole wheat pizza in town.

Crystal S.Crystal Scott: GREAT vegetarian and vegan pizza. My favorite is the Zen pizza. Their desserts are awesome, too.

Uno Pizzeria & Grill - New York is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

14. Uno Pizzeria & Grill - New York

7.1
432 Columbus Ave, New York, NY
American Restaurant · Upper West Side · 44 tips and reviews

lizzy b.lizzy b: Kids' "make your own pizza" is a MUST!

lizzy b.lizzy b: The artisanal mushroom flatbread pizza is delicious.

Find a D.Find a Dressmaker: Gluten free pizza is awesome! So is fig, goat cheese & broccoli!

Pappardella is one of The 15 Best Places for a Pizza in the Upper West Side, New York.

15. Pappardella

8.2
316 Columbus Ave (at W 75th St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Upper West Side · 50 tips and reviews

Karen U.Karen Uriot: The bread is good. The gnocchi and the penne with spinach very tasty. May be too much expensive regarding the quantity of food (pizzas seem small). Try "il caffé" !

Christopher T.Christopher Thorpe: Excellent pizzas and orchiette baresi. Definitely come again.

Ali W.Ali Watts: awesome brunch - pizza was amazing but panini isn't a traditional i.e. not presses so bread was a bit much Read more.