1. Luke's Lobster
8.4
426 Amsterdam Ave (btw W 80th & 81st St), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Upper West Side · 100 tips and reviews
Julie Qiu: Try the A Taste Of Maine Combo - Half lobster roll, half crab roll, half shrimp roll, full gloriousness
Phanessa: Great location, has indoor and outdoor seating. One of the best, affordable Lobster Rolls in the city. Served cold, healthy portion of large chunks of sweet meat. Bread doesn't overpower the lobster.
Vuk Milanovic: Lobster roll and crab roll are great. Shrimp roll is kinda lacking. Great spot for a quick (and healthy!) meal. Few seats inside.
2. Crave Fishbar
7.9
428 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY
Restaurant · Upper West Side · 29 tips and reviews
Saeed: happy hour, 1$ for oysters east coast and west coast👍🏻👌🏻😋, spicy tequila is a great drink👌🏻👌🏻
Andrea: Best oyster happy hour! Don’t mess around and come on Mondays when they have $35 wine bottle deals.
Edith C: Oyster happy hour of course! Prices have gone up but they’re still only from $1-1.5 each oyster. Definitely try the oyster and fish sliders
3. RedFarm
8.4
2170 Broadway (btwn 76 & 77th St), New York, NY
Chinese Restaurant · Upper West Side · 130 tips and reviews
Christy Mommsen: Get the shiso cucumber. not a cocktail person, but a must do! Highly recommend shrimp stuffed jalapeños if you like spicy & the pork and crab dumplings. it is as good as the village! But bigger.
John A: Wow! This place is good! Great Chinese food, farm to table, fun UWS atmosphere. Any dumpling is good, and Thai curry clams & mussels is spicy and tasty. Full bar. Drink: sangria.
Amanda Williams: My favorite UWS restaurant! Highlights are the delicious dumplings like Pac Man and crispy crab but the unique tuna salad and crunchy beef tartlets are also not to be missed! Focus on the dum sum!
4. Atlantic Grill
7.8
49 W 64th St (btwn Broadway & Central Park W), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Lincoln Square · 62 tips and reviews
Barbara Bilodeau: The Lobster Maki is the best sushi roll I have ever eaten.
Trae F: Lobster bisque and shrimp tempura/spicy tuna roll were a great snack before a big Thanksgiving dinner.
Zoë: FANTATIC oysters, beet and whipped ricotta salad, prosciutto wrapped ahi tuna with figs. To die for.
5. The Smith
8.4
1900 Broadway (at W 63rd St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Lincoln Square · 345 tips and reviews
Gabriella: I tried the Fried Oyster, the Crispy Calamari, the Mussels and believe me, everything was AWESOME! I am glad i came here! (The service by Andy was great too)
The Corcoran Group: The newest of the 3 Smith restaurants, this one is a welcome addition to the area. We love to start with the potato chips and blue cheese fondue, followed by the lobster roll or roasted chicken salad.
Camilla: Their lobster roll is really fresh and their black pasta with shrimp is really nice as well! Nice and quick staff. Sat outside and enjoyed the view of the opera.
6. Pier I Cafe
8.9
W 70th St (at Riverside Blvd), New York, NY
Café · Lincoln Square · 179 tips and reviews
Jocelyn Kolkin: Get the lobster roll, it's a great roll and comes with fries!
Sativa Verte: Dog friendly place to stop for a bite; don't forget to get ur pooch a hot dog! Also u eat lobster roll meal yum yum!
Toby Crabtree: lobster roll, sangria, and a view of the hudson
9. The Ribbon
8.7
20 W 72nd St (Central Park West and Columbus Avenue), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Lincoln Square · 89 tips and reviews
Sam Krasnik: Oyster egg shooters and the prime rib
Kathleen Corless: The ox burger is outstanding, good prime rib and if they have special fried oysters do not pass them up!
Scott Bressler: Prime rib was great. Lobster delicious but small. Spaetzle! There are a few TVs at the bar, large counter seating area in middle, and great window/sidewalk-side seats that are open during the summer.
11. Fred's Restaurant
8.2
476 Amsterdam Ave. (at W 83rd St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Upper West Side · 152 tips and reviews
Crystal Hermosillo: Everything I've had here is great! Lobster pasta, Penne pesto pasta, steak, Mac n cheese!! Don't forget to try the brownie dessert!
Todd: Lobster ravioli is amazing!
The Corcoran Group: Sit, relax and enjoy a delicious prix fixe Sunday brunch – start with the complimentary cinnamon bread followed by either Crab Cake Benedict or the Quiche.
12. Dive Bar
7.5
732 Amsterdam Ave (btwn 95th & 96th St), New York, NY
Dive Bar · Upper West Side · 120 tips and reviews
Elise Abdalla: The ambiance fits the name - a dive, but surprisingly delicious food! Must try the lobster mac and cheese or the shrimp caesar salad - my favorites :)
Sara Bost: The best deal in NYC: huge pot of steamed mussels, fries and a pint of Stella for $12! WHAT?! Yes, it's true.
Candice: Great mussels, wings, mozzarella sticks, and much more
Joe Masilotti: Can't miss dishes: chicken scarpariello wings, baked clams, and linguine in white clam sauce.
Harvey Weissman: Best white clam sauce around!
Asha: So so good! Came for graduation dinner (great for big groups). HUGE portions. Order calamari, mussels, chicken marsala, shrimp scampi, and tiramisu. Best meal you'll have!
New York Habitat: A cozy French bistro in the Upper West Side, Cassis is good for a late evening meal. Their unique lobster roll is one of the best in the city!
The Corcoran Group: An unassuming bistro that starts your meal with complimentary pate! Try the Steak Frites, the Lobster Roll or the Coque au Vin. It gets a bit noisy here and the bill sure can add up!
Jason Fredricks: Mussels with the pernod cream sauce is a must have appetizer. Duck and rack of lamb were cooked to perfection. Dessert was so-so but everything else was excellent.