Casellula
(Now Closed)Wine Bar and American Restaurant$$$$
Hell's Kitchen, New York
The experts at Village Voice and Serious Eats recommend this place
157 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Cesar RazuriDecember 24, 2016Intimate setting with an attentive staff, but the real winner are the wine/cheese list and small bites made in the tiniest of a "kitchen" I've ever seen. Truly a Hell's Kitchen hidden gem.
I have this endearing (or annoying) need to try Mac and cheese anywhere I see it on the menu, it rocks here, and start with the crostini- fab selection of wines , great catch up spot with friends!
QQ TFebruary 5, 2015Pig's Ass sandwich! Waiters are knowledgeable about wine: ours recommended an wonderful Malbec that we loved so much, we ended up buying a whole case later!
Condé Nast TravelerOctober 25, 2016“One of the best cheese-centric wine bars in the city. I usually order a bottle or two, a large cheese board, and the must-have Pig’s Ass Sandwich.” - Edouardo Jordan, chef/owner of Salare in Seattle Read more
Ozgur K.March 28, 2017Great but really great neighborhood wine bar. Superb wine menu and out of this world cheese selection. Cozy, friendly and full of with nice people. Amazing service quality is a plus
Conrad FonsecaMay 30, 2015Absolutely fantastic. The best sandwich I've ever tasted, followed by the best Mac and Cheese ever, and the Grand Finale: Chocolate Cake like no other! Plus the ambience and staff: perfect!
Village VoiceOctober 2, 2014The main attraction of this tiny Hell's Kitchen spot is The Pig's Ass Sandwich -- a sandwich so important to the restaurant's brand that Casellula trademarked its name. Read more
Serious EatsMarch 6, 2013Must-Haves: Domestic Darlings cheese flight, chistorras in a blanket, stuffed Peppadew peppers, endive salad, goose breast reuben, mac and cheese, goat cheese hazelnut truffles
Alex ShalanApril 8, 2013Casellula Cheese & Wine Cafe is a gem in HK! The staff is friendly, welcoming & they know wine! They're always helpful about what you want to drink. I've never eaten the food, but it looks delicious!
Santi AmayaDecember 20, 2015Fantastic place for a small group of friends or a date. Come, enjoy good wine, try the peppadews, try the pork buns, try the endive salad--try it all!
Casellula can only be described as a place I'd only take my favorite people. The staff is superlative, the food is incredible and the wines are a cost/value equation. Love, love, love.
Heli L.July 15, 2013Their food has so much thinking and working done before it ends up front of you. Handmade and surprising combinations. Yes, lot of big words and this place is worth of all the praise.
Marie La RueAugust 5, 2022Hk cheese emporium. Excellent wine selection. Charcuterie plate is a standout. Watermelon salad so fresh.
Ashley EderyDecember 2, 2015Fantastic spot. Perfect for a date night. Staff knows what they are doing... Gave them pick the cheeses. They'll come up with amazing pairings.
Nancy ChungMay 18, 2016Beef buns are great! The cheese platter with curry brittle is fantastic. The wines are delicious and tasty. Great place to snack and wine
Vivek PradhanJune 27, 2013Wine goes without saying, and of course the cheese is excellent - but the rest of the food is great too. One of the best and most chill wine bars in the city.
ValtteriJuly 15, 2013+1 for the Pig's Ass Sandwhich. The aioli is simply wonderful! The cheeses come with really ingenious flavor combos with a lot of layers. These guys are craftsmen!
PatrickJune 9, 2015Really nice place to begin or end a night out with a small group. Everything on the menu is fantastic and the people are great.
Todd HeughensDecember 6, 2018Exceptional selection of wines by the glass and truly delicious small plates to accompany them (rather than the other way around). ; )
New York HabitatNovember 18, 2011Get the pig's ass sandwich. Thrown off by the name? Don't be. Fiscalini cheddar, fol epi, pickles, and chipotle aioli. Think of it as a really good twist on a cuban sandwich.
Gus BorrmannSeptember 20, 2015Pig's Ass Sandwich needs to be eaten with the sauce: it's fantastic! Chocolate Cake is a marvelous surprise - extra smooth, delicate taste.
Very good wine and cheese selection. The grilled cheese sandwich with ham is delicious
Nicolette RomeroApril 10, 2015Obsessed with the peppadew peppers. Don't leave without trying them! Great wine, but weak pours. Come on guys...fill her up! 🍷🍷
Nancy HeOctober 15, 2014Great date place, small and cozy. Great wines and good food. Recommend Spanish white anchovy, frisee salad and pig's ass sandwich.
Amazing selection of wines and wonderful small plates, including cheese flights. Wonderful atmosphere and super friendly staff! Couldn't have asked for a better experience!
Chocolate cake. CHOCOLATE CAKE. And everything else. Let them recommend wine, cheese and accompaniments. They're experts.
Adam FalksonJanuary 26, 2013They offer very unique pairings with their cheeses. Stuff like white chocolate and green tea fudge and marshmallows with beet dust. Delicious.- Serious EatsAugust 24, 2011Pig's Ass Sandwich: Thin shavings of Fiscalini Cheddar, nutty Fol Epi, and, er, pig's ass, with house-made bread and butter pickles whose bright crunch lightens each bite. Read more
BravoNovember 22, 2010When you visit this place you must get the pig ass sandwich. The cheese list is one of the best and open late night for after work snacks. -Ed Cotton, Top Chef
Gabriel ComotiNovember 5, 2014Great cheese and wine selection. Try the pig ass and the brisket sandwich
Carlos VillelaOctober 1, 2016Excellent for dates! Custom cheese and wine pairings and meticulous staff, without breaking the bank.
Brittney GilbertNovember 19, 2010Unique accompaniments, fantastic selection with choices I don't usually see (chance to try new cheese!) and the servers are as sweet as pie. Chocolate with a bleu? Never knew til here.
Angelina ZeppieriJune 26, 2022Big selection of cheeses and pairing options for wine. The grilled cheese was delicious too
Louis BruscoFebruary 16, 2012Casellula offers a huge selection of fromage to pair with their varied wine list. There are a few curated tasting boards, but mix-and-match is the way to go.
Joanna FlammJanuary 24, 2011Each cheese comes with its own special garnish; everything from apple chutney to cardamom popcorn. Let Demetri choose your flight of cheeses and settle in with a glass of wine.
Krista MilanoMay 5, 2013Intimate little spot that has an amazing spread of charcuterie and cheeses that complement their wines so seamlessly - perfetto!
Jen DonatoMarch 20, 2019cheese flights, pig’s aaaaaasssssss sandwich, all the wines and if you like orange wine you’re in luck
The chocolate cake is to die for! Anywhere else 3 day old cake would sound horrible but with organic cream it is ridiculously amazing!
Nicole T.December 29, 2012Make sure you know what kind of wine you like, the server had a little 'tude' when we asked her to make suggestions. Also be prepared to switch seats a lot. They asked us to move twice. Frustrating!
Colin LeeMarch 22, 2016Came here for v-day. Cheese plate selection is great. Seats are a bit limited; but bar seating is available
Michelle SOctober 25, 2011The pig's ass sandwich is ridiculously delicious - once you get past the unappetizing name. Think of it as an upscale Cuban with pork shoulder and no ham.
Daniel HakimiAugust 28, 2015Pear cider, and a soft French cheese they serve with pine nuts and hummus.
This place is my jam. They carefully pair their cheese with a variety of accompaniments. No boring quince paste here. The restaurant is really tiny and tables are reserved for those ordering food.
Penn AppetitJuly 23, 2012Order the popcorn to start. You cannot go wrong with the cheeses. They each come with their own accompaniment.
Karla PerezFebruary 20, 2012the pig's ass, sorry, wasn't as amazing as I would have imagined. bread was read tho. my advice, pass if u don't love all pork meat, always
Bridget GaelAugust 26, 2022Cute, hidden & quiet wine and cheese bar off the theatre district w funky vibes
Ruthy GJanuary 9, 2013Pair the pig ass sandwich with a dry and light white wine, say the italian Il bucco), for a fantastic time
301 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 5:00 PM–2:00 AM
(212) 247-8137
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
No
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Drinks
Beer, Wine
See More
You might also like
Appears on 1,008 lists
Created by New York Habitat
76 items • 735 followers
Created by Winespoke
137 items • 801 followers
Created by Foursquare City Guide
15 items • 128 followers
