Piccoli Trattoria is one of The 15 Best Places for Butternut Squash in Brooklyn.

1. Piccoli Trattoria

8.4
522 6th Ave (at 14th St.), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · South Slope · 54 tips and reviews

Lauren R.Lauren Richman: Everything was delicious! Try the homemade butternut squash ravioli.. It's fab!

Adam G.Adam Goldberg: Excellent! My faves - the polenta with mushrooms appetizer and the butternut squash ravioli entree.

ToninaTonina: Excellent butternut squash ravioli!!

Il Passatore is one of The 15 Best Places for Butternut Squash in Brooklyn.

2. Il Passatore

7.8
14 Bushwick Ave (at Metropolitan Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · East Williamsburg · 66 tips and reviews

Rob M.Rob Marceda: The arugula salad with figs, pecorino, pine nuts, strawberry and truffle vinigrette plus the butternut squash tortelli is one of the most amazing meals I've ever had and I'm a carnivore! Delicioso!!!!

Lizzie B.Lizzie Bellman: Make sure you have cash! Get the butternut squash tortellini! It's amazing!

Amy T.Amy Tremmel: Hands down favorite Italian restaurant in Williamsburg. Huge backyard, amazing food (butternut squash ravioli!), great prices. Cash only!

Llama Inn is one of The 15 Best Places for Butternut Squash in Brooklyn.

3. Llama Inn

9.0
50 Withers St (at Lorimer St), Brooklyn, NY
Peruvian Restaurant · Williamsburg · 157 tips and reviews

EaterEater: Peruvian restaurant with small plates. Items include chicken thighs and beef hearts on skewers, duck sausage with farro and butternut squash, and fluke ceviche

Dmtiry R.Dmtiry Romantsov: Favorite place for Peruvian food. Duck sausage with butternut squash is to die for and roast llama is delicious as well!

Raquelle J.Raquelle Jessie: Get the quinoa w the banana & the anticuchos and the sweet potato donuts

The Soup Bowl is one of The 15 Best Places for Butternut Squash in Brooklyn.

4. The Soup Bowl

8.0
319 7th Ave (Btwn 8th & 9th St), Brooklyn, NY
Soup Spot · Central Slope · 10 tips and reviews

Cassandra B.Cassandra Bradby: Amazing soups. The curried butternut and and acorn squash is amazing.

Arden G.Arden Ginsberg: Spinach potato tomato a great hearty soup

Madam Ciara J. G.Madam Ciara J. Grossman: Try the Serious Split Pea;)

Positano is one of The 15 Best Places for Butternut Squash in Brooklyn.

5. Positano

8.1
10018 4th Ave (101st Street), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Bay Ridge · 10 tips and reviews

Michele H.Michele Hughes: Delicious butternut squash ravioli

Aeolian-Skinner Princess P.Aeolian-Skinner Princess Pastore: The Sinatra pasta and the linguine Nero are awesome!

Mark B.Mark B: The food is wonderful. Try the Eggplant Siciliano app - perfect! Also, the Fioretti pasta entree. Downside, extremely noisy.

Mekelburg’s is one of The 15 Best Places for Butternut Squash in Brooklyn.

6. Mekelburg’s

8.4
325 Kent Ave (S 3rd St), Brooklyn, NY
Beer Bar · Williamsburg · 22 tips and reviews

Serena M.Serena May: Apple and butternut squash bisque with ginger Oreo foie gras ahhhh

Kelsey✨Kelsey✨: Great sandwiches and large assortment of snacks and craft beers. Order the duck banh mi and eat it at the park next door

Jen T.Jen T: Chocolate babka

Evelina Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Butternut Squash in Brooklyn.

7. Evelina Restaurant

9.3
211 Dekalb Ave (Adelphi), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Fort Greene · 45 tips and reviews

Claudia F.Claudia Filth: The butternut squash tempura, mafaldine, and semifreddo were amazing. I’m hoping they rotate a menu to always have news things to try at this restaurant.

Danny N.Danny Nathan: Meal was tasty. We a couple of apps, 2 pastas, and a fish. They were all delicious and easily fed four. Good cocktails as well.

Gianna N.Gianna Nebbia: This prosciutto di Parma Benedict is the best single brunch item I’ve ever had. Pappardelle with oxtail ragu was also very very good.

Lassen & Hennigs is one of The 15 Best Places for Butternut Squash in Brooklyn.

8. Lassen & Hennigs

7.6
177 Water St (btw Pearl & Jay St), New York, NY
Bakery · 1 tip

Dustin L.Dustin Lee: Offers a wide range of food, including pastries, soups, sandwiches, pre-packed meals, coffee. A little expensive but overall good. Butternut squash soup is excellent

Dino is one of The 15 Best Places for Butternut Squash in Brooklyn.

9. Dino

7.9
222 Dekalb Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Fort Greene · 93 tips and reviews

carmel c.carmel christine: try the butternut squash ravioli! the sauce is amazeballs.

Archana M.Archana Mani: Love their special, butternut squash lasagne (surprisingly crispy) and pear gorgonzola salad (refreshingly tangy)

Kristina R.Kristina Rudic: Ragu is incredible. Don't miss out on it.

Henry's End is one of The 15 Best Places for Butternut Squash in Brooklyn.

10. Henry's End

8.3
72 Henry St (Orange St at Henry St), Brooklyn, NY
New American Restaurant · Brooklyn Heights · 34 tips and reviews

Vince W.Vince Wong: I ordered the prix fixe. The butternut squash bisque, Scottish salmon, and Apple Cobbler combo was wonderful.

Maggie L.Maggie LeVine: DEFINITELY get the walnut crusted chicken breast! Also, new location has outdoor seating - great for people (and dog) watching.

Yann S.Yann Schwermer: and be sure to say hi to bonnie - best waitress ever

Cent'Anni is one of The 15 Best Places for Butternut Squash in Brooklyn.

11. Cent'Anni

8.4
742 Franklin Ave (at Sterling Pl), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Crown Heights · 96 tips and reviews

alissa n.alissa nevita: Had the capellini pasta with butter and sage. Pasta was ok. Wanted to have the ravioli but it was only filled with butternut squash.

Beril E.Beril Esen: Their bread was stale. Not much of a taste difference between the butternut squash and potato gnocchi. Black linguini with seafood is a winner, but if you want homemade pasta, order the pappardelle.

Johann R.Johann R.: absolutely delicious food. the butternut squash gnocchi is to die for

Esme is one of The 15 Best Places for Butternut Squash in Brooklyn.

12. Esme

8.4
999 Manhattan Ave (at Huron St), Brooklyn, NY
New American Restaurant · Greenpoint · 52 tips and reviews

Lucie P.Lucie Pustova: Butternut squash risotto is key, burger is delicious, and they have really good cocktails.

Maria L.Maria Lambert: Savory French toast is amazing for brunch. Can't go wrong at dinner- everything is great. Menu has improved a lot since first few months they were open.

EaterEater: Check out recently opened Esme. They are serving chicken and buckwheat waffles, borscht "salad," and donuts for dessert. Read more.

Aita is one of The 15 Best Places for Butternut Squash in Brooklyn.

13. Aita

9.0
132 Greene Ave (Waverly), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Clinton Hill · 84 tips and reviews

Fodor's TravelFodor's Travel: Try the crispy butternut squash dressed in a surprisingly delicate coffee mayonnaise, or house-made cavatelli topped with shaved Parmesan and black truffles. Read more.

Sofia F.Sofia Figueroa: Well priced, quaint ambiance, veggie friendly. Yummy french toast!

The New YorkerThe New Yorker: “Aita is not a place to have the best meal of your life; it’s a place to sit and linger with friends and family, feeling comfortable and taken care of.” Read more.

Leuca is one of The 15 Best Places for Butternut Squash in Brooklyn.

14. Leuca

8.3
111 N 12th St, Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Williamsburg · 59 tips and reviews

Paola V.Paola Viscogliosi: Seriously everything is great! The ricotta starter, the chicken for two, the butternut squash hummus, the lobster is great but get it with melted butter and Chili , and the OG should be the OMG!!!

Carly D.Carly Dahl: Cabbage, urchin spaghetti, cauliflower fritto and steak all well-balanced and flavorful. Service was warm & impeccable. Space is gorgeous. 10/10!

RajRaj: Excellent service, eclectic but good Italian wine list, and starters are to die for. Suckling pig was over-brined when we were there however

Belli Osteria is one of The 15 Best Places for Butternut Squash in Brooklyn.

15. Belli Osteria

7.7
860 Fulton St (at Clinton Avenue), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Clinton Hill · 35 tips and reviews

Karina R.Karina Ruzinov: So delicious! The service was great and super fast. Get the butternut squash ravioli and tiramisu for dessert!

Morgan J.Morgan Jordan: Polenta is amazing! Service is even better!

JideJide: The Tartino dessert is everything! The way the warm chocolate ooZes out of the cake is just simple perfection. Mad good.