Sullivan Street Bakery is one of The 7 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Chelsea, New York.

1. Sullivan Street Bakery

8.9
236 9th Ave (at 24th St), New York, NY
Bakery · Chelsea · 142 tips and reviews

Time Out New YorkTime Out New York: For little more than a Hamilton, you can load up on a panino built atop a trusty loaf—the combo of salty prosciutto, rich buffalo mozzarella and pickled shishito peppers is a standout. Read more.

Serious EatsSerious Eats: Great bread, tasty sandwiches, and some standout sweets. Don't miss the pizza bianca.

Village VoiceVillage Voice: As far as filled donuts are concerned, we're hard-pressed to find a finer specimen than the bomboloni. Treat yourself to the vanilla custard one; a delight you won't forget!

da Umberto is one of The 7 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Chelsea, New York.

2. da Umberto

8.9
107 W 17th St, New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Chelsea · 37 tips and reviews

Shaun S.Shaun Stewart: Great lunch spot for a quiet meeting; amazing pasta - fantastic service and not that crowded during the day. The pasta with corn and bacon iS my go to

SimonSimon: amazing food - get the truffle mushroom ravioli and the chicken parm (off menu). Great place for the fam, date or just a great Italian meal

Kate H.Kate Huyett: Get the agnolotti with squash, the ravioli with mushrooms and truffles, the bolognese pappardelle. Pasta is all out of this world.

Le Zie Bar is one of The 7 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Chelsea, New York.

3. Le Zie Bar

8.2
172 7th Ave (btwn 20th & 21st St), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · Chelsea · 9 tips and reviews

Elizabeth B.Elizabeth Burstein: Great vibe and service, speakeasy behind a restaurant, loves the passion fruit martini and the spice cocktails!

Melissa W.Melissa Wilfley: Very cute, small intimate bar in the back. Sort of like a speakeasy

Nate S.Nate S: What a gem! Tucked behind a restaurant, enter on 20th for a speakeasy vibe. Good for dates if you can snag a spot (space is very limited).

Pepe Giallo is one of The 7 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Chelsea, New York.

4. Pepe Giallo

8.5
195 10th Ave (btw 21st and 22nd), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Chelsea · 103 tips and reviews

Edward F.Edward Fabila: their Prosecco is bubbly, crisp and divine...order a bottle! From pasta to desserts, everything is top notch and delicious

Josh W.Josh Whelchel: Move your bread close to the candles so they catch on fire and strike up conversation with your neighbors.

KatyaKatya: Old school Italian at old school prices! Hands down fav dinner spot in Chelsea. Try the gnocchi or the black fettuccini (if they have it as a special).

Le Zie 2000 Trattoria is one of The 7 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Chelsea, New York.

5. Le Zie 2000 Trattoria

7.7
172 7th Ave (btwn W 20th & W 21st St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Chelsea · 73 tips and reviews

Carina H.Carina H: The specials are always great... tonight's saffron taglierini with crab meat, cherry tomatoes, and zucchini was especially fantastic

john c.john clay: hand rolled pici

Ping H.Ping Ho: best sausage pasta! meatballs are also fab

Ovest Pizzoteca by Luzzo's is one of The 7 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Chelsea, New York.

6. Ovest Pizzoteca by Luzzo's

8.1
513 W 27th St (btwn 10th & 11th Ave), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Chelsea · 123 tips and reviews

ChristaChrista: nice little place tucked away on 27th. good arancini. i only had the ovest pizza but it was delicious. staff was knowledgable about wine and was able to make good recommendations.

Serious EatsSerious Eats: If you're familiar with Luzzo's, one of major differences at Ovest is that Ovest serves a variety of panini.

Nicholas R.Nicholas R: Good place to kill time before Sleep No More. Friendly bartenders.

Old Homestead Steakhouse is one of The 7 Best Places for Buffalo Mozzarella in Chelsea, New York.

7. Old Homestead Steakhouse

8.0
56 9th Ave (btwn 14th St & 15th St), New York, NY
Steakhouse · Chelsea · 150 tips and reviews

Gansevoort Hotel GroupGansevoort Hotel Group: Fun fact: first steakhouse in Manhattan

Pam A.Pam Arendall-Arnais: Get the truffle Mac-n-cheese!

TeresaTeresa: Truffle mac and cheese is a must!!