Chicago Diner is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in Chicago.

1. Chicago Diner

8.9
3411 N Halsted St (at Roscoe St), Chicago, IL
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · Lake View East · 205 tips and reviews

AmiAmi: The chocolate peanut butter cookie dough milkshake is incredible.

Tiffany C.Tiffany Chilvere: Chocolate peanut butter cookie dough milkshake is straight from heaven! I'm not vegan and it was hands down the BEST milkshake I've ever had!

Joe M.Joe Murphy Librarian: Try the special Baja fish tacos, and peanut butter chocolate cake!

Stan's Donuts & Coffee is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in Chicago.

2. Stan's Donuts & Coffee

8.8
1560 N Damen Ave (at N Milwaukee Ave), Chicago, IL
Donut Shop · Wicker Park · 131 tips and reviews

Kaitlin V.Kaitlin V.: lattés as big as your head and chocolate peanut butter pockets are awesome!

Drew Z.Drew Zilla: So good! Peanut Butter Chocolate Pockets are sooo delicious!

Monica Z.Monica Zarate: Pretzel donut and stumptown cold brew were amazing treats!

Stan's Donuts & Coffee is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in Chicago.

3. Stan's Donuts & Coffee

8.6
28 E Roosevelt Rd, Chicago, IL
Coffee Shop · South Loop · 22 tips and reviews

KaitlinKaitlin: Stuffed peanut butter chocolate donut, yum! And they have Stumptown and La Colombe coffee here, excellent choices!

A-BombA-Bomb: The chocolate old fashioned was phenomenal. The orange peel in it was a nice surprise!

markmark: Great selection and perfectly cooked doughnuts. Wide variety of chocolate items that can easily be dessert. Avoid the bagels though - for a bakery this good at doughnuts, the bagels are disappointing

First Slice Pie Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in Chicago.

4. First Slice Pie Cafe

8.2
4664 N Manor Ave, Chicago, IL
Pie Shop · Ravenswood Manor · 11 tips and reviews

Lynda C.Lynda Cadiente: Yummiest peanut butter chocolate pie! : P

Erin L.Erin Lapaz: Very friendly staff and a home-like atmosphere. The Mediterranean quiche is great!

Kelly L.Kelly Leonard: Try the chocolate cream pie. It's delicious.

Aje Café Sandwiches & Coffee is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in Chicago.

5. Aje Café Sandwiches & Coffee

8.5
2942 N Clark St (at W Wellington Ave), Chicago, IL
Café · Lake View East · 30 tips and reviews

ShouaShoua: Great spot to study or meet up with a friend. Serves Rishi teas and Meteopolis coffee. Chocolate peanut butter cookie is delicious! This place is a hidden gem.

Nina N.Nina Newman: Veggie breakfast sandwich is great! So is their chai lattee :) very fresh

Erik C.Erik Cooper: Their food and drinks are great! This is a great independently owned neighborhood coffee shop and cafe, skip the line at caribou and Starbucks and come here. The owners are super friendly.

Cone Gourmet Ice Cream is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in Chicago.

6. Cone Gourmet Ice Cream

8.4
1047 W Madison St (btwn Morgan St & Aberdeen St), Chicago, IL
Ice Cream Parlor · Near West Side · 34 tips and reviews

Dustin H.Dustin Haley: Very rich and creamy! Had the chocolate peanut butter and it was great. They have other more adventurous flavors too if you're into that

ThrillistThrillist: There’s this Hair of the Dog sundae with Guinness, Baileys & Jameson ice cream covered in chocolate syrup and with crumbled Cadbury flake sprinkled on top. Read more.

Shanlie Ann 🍃 @.Shanlie Ann 🍃 @chi_shan: Guinness, Cake Batter and Shortbread! Slainte! Next time Jameson:)*

Vincent is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in Chicago.

7. Vincent

8.3
1475 W Balmoral Ave (btwn Clark St & Glenwood Ave), Chicago, IL
New American Restaurant · Andersonville · 38 tips and reviews

AskMenAskMen: V-Day Dinner at Vincent - Make a reservation for V Day & drop in for a 5-course prix fixe menu ($95/couple) that includes oysters, foie gras, apple salad, pork loin, & chocolate peanut butter mousse. Read more.

Melody L.Melody Legge: Small. Dark with lots of candies. Cozy. Great atmosphere. Friendly staff. Amish chicken was delightful. Want to go back and try the cheese selection.

Chicago magazineChicago magazine: Try the Mussels Sambal

Trader Joe's is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in Chicago.

8. Trader Joe's

9.0
667 W Diversey Pkwy (at N Orchard), Chicago, IL
Grocery Store · Park West · 73 tips and reviews

Alex B.Alex Brehm: Shop during the day to avoid lines + get some dark chocolate peanut butter cups and you'll go home happy.

MoonchildMoonchild: Amazing place to get good quality organic food for a really reasonable price.

👥 CJI👥 CJI: My first time to discover the great ORGANIC savings I can get from here. Move over "Whole Foods"... This is my new Grocery Home.

First Slice Pie Café is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in Chicago.

9. First Slice Pie Café

8.9
5357 N Ashland Ave (at W Balmoral Ave), Chicago, IL
Pie Shop · Andersonville · 21 tips and reviews

Leia N.Leia Nichole: The blueberry cheesecake pie was AMAZING. Love this spot, tucked on Ashland and begging you to stop in. Homey, friendly, generous.

MightybytesMightybytes: First Slice is not just a great place to get a slice of pie. Buy healthy meals for your busy family, and you'll pay for the same meals to go to Chicago’s hungry and homeless. Read more.

Brenda M.Brenda Magnetti: This non-profit feeds more than me. They serve 500 meals a week to those who can't afford groceries. You had me at hello!

Kopi Café is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in Chicago.

10. Kopi Café

8.4
5317 N Clark St (at Summerdale), Chicago, IL
Café · Andersonville · 58 tips and reviews

BessieBessie: Their Mexican Hot Chocolate is the best I can imagine. Don't miss the vegan chocolate peanut butter picks if they have them, too!

AlexAlex: Totally chill place to sit on floor cushions and pass time. Great coffee, juice, vegetarian sandwiches. Writer Aleksandar Hemon is a regular.

Victoria G.Victoria Garcia: Black chai shake! Enough said! I can't wait to go back!

Chicago Diner is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in Chicago.

11. Chicago Diner

8.8
2333 N Milwaukee Ave (at W Fullerton Ave), Chicago, IL
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · Logan Square · 84 tips and reviews

Jeiran H.Jeiran Hasan: Chocolate peanut butter milkshake was outstanding!

Beth G.Beth Glaysher: Vegan Chai was 💰, saiten Thai chili chicken was 🔥, and the mushroom gf burger was 💣. This place was great!!

T S.T Sussman: The vegan milkshakes are amazing.

Wildfire is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in Chicago.

12. Wildfire

8.6
159 W Erie St (btwn La Salle St & Wells St), Chicago, IL
Steakhouse · River North · 77 tips and reviews

TamaraTamara: If you want to try desert, the key lime pie, the chocolate peanut butter pie, and the apple pie are superb. The homemade Ice cream sandwich, however, isnt very good.

Sandy P.Sandy Piehl: Fish, steaks, chopped salad is my all time favorite.😃

MafiaHairdresser J.MafiaHairdresser Jon-David: I love the the Trio of Medalions! Love.

Firecakes Donuts is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in Chicago.

13. Firecakes Donuts

9.2
68 W Hubbard St (at N Clark St), Chicago, IL
Donut Shop · Near North Side · 165 tips and reviews

Emily J.Emily Jurlina: The peanut butter chocolate mini doughnut is my favorite.

Eric B.Eric Blasius: Any of the donuts are good- try the espresso creme!

ThrillistThrillist: Firecakes' donut ice cream sandwich is held together with chocolate espresso or vanilla bean gelato, and adorned with rich chocolate, caramel sauces, and cocoa nibs. Hell to the yes. Read more.

Coda Di Volpe is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in Chicago.

14. Coda Di Volpe

9.0
3335 N Southport Ave (at Henderson St), Chicago, IL
Italian Restaurant · Lakeview · 17 tips and reviews

Uddyami A.Uddyami Agrawal: Food is fabulous!! Vegetarian people this is a great find. Pizzas are unique and delicious. Don't skip the dessert. Pic is of budino (butterscotch)

Drew D.Drew Davis: Probably the best Neapolitan style pizza in Chicago.

Rick B.Rick Bendix: Delicious pizzas

Alice & Friends' is one of The 15 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in Chicago.

15. Alice & Friends'

8.6
5812 N Broadway St, Chicago, IL
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · Edgewater · 6 tips and reviews

Gardenia C. H.Gardenia C. Hung: When you order Herbal Tea with Alice & Friends, be ready to wait a while, before you can enjoy you cup of fresh herbal tea!

mark r.mark roth: I feel entitled to eat dessert first here! Try it.

E. Joseph R.E. Joseph R.: The wonton soup is really good