Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams is one of The 11 Best Places for Caramel in Columbus.

1. Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams

9.1
714 N High St (at E Lincoln St), Columbus, OH
Ice Cream Parlor · 116 tips and reviews

Eli S.Eli Smith: Sweet corn and blackberry is my fav. salty caramel is good too

Evan W.Evan Weiss: Amazing ice cream that's easily worth the price. Salty caramel is a good place to start.

Kim F.Kim Frazier: Tried several flavors...salted caramel is their famous flavor..its very strong...the pistachio is great! The bramelberry is like a blackberry cobbler! Always a long line

Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams is one of The 11 Best Places for Caramel in Columbus.

2. Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams

8.7
1281 Grandview Ave, Columbus, OH
Ice Cream Parlor · 48 tips and reviews

Sarah G.Sarah Griffith: The fortune cookie sundae is the the best sundae. Ever. Subsititue the cornflake crunch for the walnut ice cream- and caramel for the coconut sauce... Perfection!

Tara M.Tara Meadors: Mix flavors. A dark chocolate with the salty caramel is delicious! Prepare for a wait, but it is definately worth it!

gretchen s.gretchen stahl: Usually get a scoop dark choc and a scoop salty caramel, but all are great! Try the backyard mint. True mint flavor rather than peppermint

5 Bean Coffee is one of The 11 Best Places for Caramel in Columbus.

3. 5 Bean Coffee

8.6
2087-A OH Rt 256 (at Farmsbury Rd.), Reynoldsburg, OH
Coffee Shop · 22 tips and reviews

Jason H.Jason Heitmeyer: Hot drink- Carmel Mocha. Blended drink- Caramel Kiss. My favorites!

Tracy H.Tracy Heitmeyer: Try the 5 Bean Mocha! White chocolate, espresso, milk and caramel drizzles. Great hot or even better in the blender. Try the light protein powder if you want less calories + protein.

Rae W.Rae Whitlock: Frozen caramel pecan. Get it.

Johnson's Real Ice Cream is one of The 11 Best Places for Caramel in Columbus.

4. Johnson's Real Ice Cream

9.3
2728 E Main St (btwn S Roosevelt & S Gould Rd), Columbus, OH
Ice Cream Parlor · 17 tips and reviews

George S.George Sly: Hands down, they have THE best Salty Caramel Chocolate Pretzel!!!

Paul H.Paul Haggard: Grab a cone with salty caramel chocolate pretzel or lemon ice cream and sit outside on the patio. Come Thursday's for music!

jireselljiresell: First time here! Good value for really good ice cream! Try the salty caramel pretzel ice cream. Unique and delicious!

Crimson Cup Coffee & Tea is one of The 11 Best Places for Caramel in Columbus.

5. Crimson Cup Coffee & Tea

8.7
4541 N High St (W. Weisheimer Rd.), Columbus, OH
Coffee Shop · 27 tips and reviews

Judi R.Judi Remenyi: Awesome Carmel pecan frap skinny w extra shot of espresso! Love it!

Rasa D.Rasa Devadiga: Amazing coffee!!! And a drive through!!! Crimson cup mocha wow!! Carmel latte!!! Awesome!!

Lara C.Lara Conrad: Have the barista explain the single brew process. Fascinating. Precision coffee brewing.

Basi Italia is one of The 11 Best Places for Caramel in Columbus.

6. Basi Italia

8.6
811 Highland St (Buttles), Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 31 tips and reviews

Sabrina G.Sabrina Grondhuis: Parmesan Creme Brulee is delicious! So unique!

Melissa E.Melissa E: Great specials options to go with. The Parmesan creme brûlée and zucchini apps were good choices.

Scioto ValleyScioto Valley: The cozy atmosphere, tasty cuisine and ever-changing wine list make this the perfect spot in Columbus for date night.

Starbucks is one of The 11 Best Places for Caramel in Columbus.

7. Starbucks

7.7
1187 Polaris Pkwy, Columbus, OH
Coffee Shop · Polaris · 32 tips and reviews

Alexandra F.Alexandra Francisco: Triple grande iced Caramel macchiato with one pump vanilla and extra caramel....Delish!!!!

Tracey W.Tracey Ward: Upside down caramel macchiato cold! You don't have to stir! Get a gold card!

"Aunt Blabby" M."Aunt Blabby" Mitchell: Omg the salted Carmel cake pops are sinful but oh so good

Handel's Homemade Ice Cream is one of The 11 Best Places for Caramel in Columbus.

8. Handel's Homemade Ice Cream

9.0
5665 Feder Rd, Columbus, OH
Ice Cream Parlor · 15 tips and reviews

NatashaNatasha: Delicious ice cream! Chocolate malt with caramel is the best!

Katie J.Katie Jaspers: The salty caramel truffle ice cream is out of this world.

R. H.R. H.: Best ice cream in the area.

Starbucks is one of The 11 Best Places for Caramel in Columbus.

9. Starbucks

8.1
6264 East Broad Street, Columbus, OH
Coffee Shop · 21 tips and reviews

Robin C.Robin Corsey: Soy xtra carm carmel mach. yum

Manda D.Manda Doorley: Iced caramel nonfat coffee is a great refreshing drink when it's hot!

Captain_America ..Captain_America .: The new Mocha Cookie Crumble Frappe is amazing!

Schmidt's Fudge Haus is one of The 11 Best Places for Caramel in Columbus.

10. Schmidt's Fudge Haus

8.3
220 E Kossuth St (5th St), Columbus, OH
Candy Store · 6 tips and reviews

J H.J Hamlin: Sea salt topped chocolate covered homemade caramel

Francie G.Francie Griffith: The house made caramels will make you cry once they are gone. You will miss them terribly!!!

jireselljiresell: Who doesn't love homemade fudge, candies and peanut brittle!

Harvest Moon Craft Kitchen is one of The 11 Best Places for Caramel in Columbus.

11. Harvest Moon Craft Kitchen

8.7
7 N High St, Canal Winchester, OH
Café · 32 tips and reviews

Mike W.Mike Waclo: The Caramelized Pear and Brie Bison Burger is out of this world. Try it on a pretzel roll if you're feeling frisky.

Niki B.Niki B: I love getting the hazelnut swirl frescante! Its like nutella and coffee!

Becky T.Becky Tippie: One of the best places for lunch, coffee, or cocktails. The atmosphere is delightful and casual. Specialty lattes and coffees are the best. Roasted veggie sandwich is one of my favorites!