The 13 Best Places for Peanut Butter Pie in New York City

Stone Newman: Can't go wrong with the Peanut Butter Pie!

Christina Carr: Try the hot buttered grapefruit toddy...delish! And you have to have the peanut butter pie.

Oscar Parada, Jr.: The bartenders were awesome when we went there (11/7/2015). Their nachos were very delicious and their peanut butter pie with a side of choco ice cream put us over the edge. Great place! Will be back!

Jon Lombardo: Get the Pumpkin Pie. Peanut Butter pie also amazing as well.

Tiantha Fields: I love their chocolate peanut butter pie. Not sure I will return to this location because of the way I was served, and the presentation of the pie the last time I purchased a piece.

Yvonne Diaz: Banana cake, banana pudding, snickerdoodles are yum

Danielle Irizarry: Personal faves: fried green tomato, deviled eggs, wango tango wings, peanut butter pie. Serious wings.

David Schorr: Best chain bbq in NYC. Peanut butter pie. Do it.

Yelimar Rodriguez: The Jerk Salmon, Mac n' Cheese, and were delish. The peanut butter pie was to die for.

Sarah Seeds: Awesome desserts :) I love the chocolate peanut butter pie! mmmmm.

Hana Slevin: Pierogies - I loved the goat cheese & arugula, and the sweet potato. And good God that peanut butter pie...

Eliza Pilonieta: The 3 bean chilli is killer!!!! so is the lamb and feta burger

Rob Markowitz: Peanut butter pie is awesome!

Bill Stanton: The best diner in Manhattan! Fresh carved turkey, homemade everything. Gets crowded but worth the wait.

Jeremy Smith: Hands down the best diner in the UWS.

arkatPDA Bouchard: Coffee is awful. Good banana pudding and peanut butter pie

Rachel Clark: The white chocolate fudge brownie is so good and has an amazing texture.

The New York Times: Skip the infamous cupcakes at this NYC standby and give the banana pudding a try.

Mike Chau: Try the Peanut Butter Pie With Oreo Crust

Doroulini: Great variety of cupcakes! I tried the red velvet and it was really tasty and fresh.

J Crowley: Get a slice of the Black and White cake To Go. Bring it home as a surprise treat for your wife. It will totally erase all the shit you're in trouble for. Yeah, it's that good.

Roger Schonfeld: We've enjoyed the jazz brunch. Nice food and the performer is great.

Serious Eats: Bottom line? Go to Smoke. Patricia Williams has proven that great jazz and great food are not incompatible.

Bree Sweet: Wish I could live there!

Carly Levine: Go for the peanut butter pie sundae...actually called the "Can't Say No" sundae...it's out of this world and my favorite dessert of all time. From anywhere. Ever.

ilayda kilic: It's famous with it's frrrozen hot chocolate.Also Try humble pie it's a creamy peanut butter pie.

Mariana Pantalena: Gigantic portions! Frozen chocolate is the best!

Roger Ehrenberg: Try the peanut butter pie. Absolutely, positively sublime... (via Scoville) Read more.

Loriah Pope: So glad we came here! We got the chocolate cake and the key lime pie. The chocolate cake was so moist and the key lime pie was exactly the right balance of sweet and tart.

Mazda: It all began with two friends from business school, a sweet tooth, and a dream.

Uwe Peters: Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie is excellent

Danger Gray: Smoked salmon Egg Benedict with spinach was absolutely delicious. The OJ too.

Lisa Kelsey: a good breakfast place

Yanin De Jesus: The best plate is their brisket. And I love their Maple Butter abd Biscuits. I pick only biscuits for my sides!

James Sims: The hush puppies will weigh you down all night, but they are oh so worth it.

Dan Pennacchia: If you go to Virgil's you have to check out the Trainwreck Fries.

Carolina Ribeiro: Great dinner atmosphere and music selection. Their burger is to die for! Only problem is they don't take cards.

Talia Goldberg: Breakfast all day. The ideal brunch spot.

caroline lewis: Cash only