Brooklyn Fare is one of The 15 Best Supermarkets in New York City.

1. Brooklyn Fare

9.1
431 W 37th St, New York, NY
Supermarket · Hell's Kitchen · 28 tips and reviews

Rewan P.Rewan Parti: Excellent take out food! Coffee is delicious. This is the best grocery store in the neighborhood. They have a bakery too. Everything is made fresh.

scott k.scott krause: Exactly what the neighborhood needed.

Sam W.Sam Wolfe: A fantastic "Whole Foods"-like addition to the neighborhood. Good ready meal selection (including a great vegetable lasagne).

Fairway Market is one of The 15 Best Supermarkets in New York City.

2. Fairway Market

9.0
2328 12th Ave (at 132nd St), New York, NY
Supermarket · West Harlem · 82 tips and reviews

Adrienne C.Adrienne Cooper: In the last couple of years I've been more about CSAs and Farmers Markets, but if I go just to a supermarket, I choose fairway. Great selection & value, and their coffee is some of the best around!

Serious EatsSerious Eats: Excellent full-service grocery in Harlem.

BravoBravo: Great produce, cheeses and seafood. -Carmen Gonzalez, Top Chef

New Kam Man is one of The 15 Best Supermarkets in New York City.

3. New Kam Man

8.6
200 Canal St (btwn Mott & Mulberry St.), New York, NY
Supermarket · Chinatown · 21 tips and reviews

Jeanise C.Jeanise Chaplin: Best marinated chicken feet ever!

Zoë W.Zoë Williams: Try the green tea Kit Kats!

Sallie Z.Sallie Zhang: Great japanese and korean cosmetics on the 2nd floor.

Brooklyn Fare is one of The 15 Best Supermarkets in New York City.

4. Brooklyn Fare

8.5
666 Greenwich St, New York, NY
Supermarket · West Village · 6 tips and reviews

Jessica W.Jessica Wickham: Great range of fresh foods, helpful and knowledgeable staff including butchers, fresh fish, bakery & cooked foods. They deliver within an 8 block radius for free. Highly recommend, good prices too

Jeeleighanne D.Jeeleighanne Duboius: Bit pricey but talk about variety. So much variety here.

Vania S.Vania S.: Excited to finally have a reasonably priced grocery store in the w village. Huge selection of anything you might want from budget to high-end. Only downside is that it's a Verizon dead zone. Wifi pls!

Fairway Market is one of The 15 Best Supermarkets in New York City.

5. Fairway Market

8.7
2127 Broadway (btwn 74th & 75th St), New York, NY
Supermarket · Upper West Side · 123 tips and reviews

Tom D.Tom Dawson: Great coffee selection. Try the Fairway dark organic blend

Scott S.Scott Stone: Go at off hours.

Gabe C.Gabe Chapa: Full contact grocery shopping - use your elbows!

Westside Market is one of The 15 Best Supermarkets in New York City.

6. Westside Market

8.3
2589 Broadway (at W 98th St), New York, NY
Supermarket · Upper West Side · 28 tips and reviews

Linden H.Linden Hillenbrand: Salad bar, meals, fresh fruit. Just about everything here is awesome. Except for how packed it gets. Definitely go, avoid the weekends.

Asher S.Asher Susswein: Chicken pot pie is amazing...Best ever...Can't imagine better.

Nancy K.Nancy Kang: Can't beat the prepared foods section at the WMs, & their salad bar rocks too... but for a few bucks less u can get just as good a salad at Corner Cafe just a few blks away (SE corner of Bway at 94th)

Super Foodtown is one of The 15 Best Supermarkets in New York City.

7. Super Foodtown

8.2
600 W 160th St (Broadway), New York, NY
Supermarket · Washington Heights · 6 tips and reviews

Gabriel Q.Gabriel Queiroz: Best grocery store in the area. The place is brand new, clean and has a good variety of products. Make sure you get a Club Card to get additional discounts.

Sung Han K.Sung Han Kim: Kimch, coffee, beer etc.

Linda S.Linda Sanchez: Definitely sign up for the rewards card. They have a lot of great deals but we have saved more from the card. It all adds up if you shop here often.

Westside Market is one of The 15 Best Supermarkets in New York City.

8. Westside Market

8.1
2171 Broadway (at 77th St.), New York, NY
Supermarket · Upper West Side · 23 tips and reviews

DMarie P.DMarie P: Neighborhood grocery. Open 24/7. Great fresh fruit and veggies.

Sookie T.Sookie Tex: A very knowledgeable and helpful staff

NEIGHBORLY N.NEIGHBORLY NOTARY: Try Maria's homemade lemon slaw. It's like eating a mojito (without the booze). Cabbage, parsley, lemon & sugar.

Morton Williams is one of The 15 Best Supermarkets in New York City.

9. Morton Williams

7.8
1211 Madison Ave (at 87th), New York, NY
Supermarket · Carnegie Hill · 1 tip

Peter F.Peter Fung: Why is this so overpriced. Just because it's in Manhattan. Fleecing of Manhattan. Give man overpriced goods and man will strive to buy it like black pearls.

Manhattan Fruit Exchange is one of The 15 Best Supermarkets in New York City.

10. Manhattan Fruit Exchange

7.7
75 9th Ave (btwn W 15th & W 16th St), New York, NY
Supermarket · Chelsea · 31 tips and reviews

Han Y.Han Yu: May carry quenepas in the summer. The delicious and rare Spanish Lime is like a cross between a lychee and a lime, with tart, tangy, creamy pulp.

Hristo H.Hristo Hristov: Love the salad bar here @ 4.99 lbs it's a steel. Over $10 u can pay by card

Charles S.Charles Stark: Best produce. Great prices.

St. Mark's Market is one of The 15 Best Supermarkets in New York City.

11. St. Mark's Market

7.8
21 Saint Marks Pl (btwn 2nd & 3rd Ave), New York, NY
Supermarket · East Village · 41 tips and reviews

Lauren S.Lauren SK: 24-hours, clean, with great variety. It doesn't get better than this!!

The New York Daily NewsThe New York Daily News: PHOTO: In the 1960s this was the Electric Circus nightclub, an experimental hang-out that featured bands like the Velvet Underground. Check out the fancy digs on these party-goers in 67, at the link! Read more.

Gregg D.Gregg D: The best market in the East Village I'm tellin' ya! The deli counter sandwiches are unbelievable!! Try the chicken cutlet sandwich!!!!

Morton Williams is one of The 15 Best Supermarkets in New York City.

12. Morton Williams

7.6
140 W 57th St (6th and 7th Avenue), New York, NY
Supermarket · Theater District · 23 tips and reviews

Roberto M.Roberto Marchi: Best supermarket in the neighborhood!

MatthewMatthew: This clean supermarket, located near the Carnegie Hall, offers 2 floors of grocery items and a small cold/hot buffet ($7/lb). Head upstairs (open until 11 pm) for decent seatings with free WiFi.

Sam M.Sam Meyer: New (Oct 2012) & gorgeous location. Well-stocked, and the prepared foods aren't bad. Cafe seating upstairs.

Ideal Marketplace is one of The 15 Best Supermarkets in New York City.

13. Ideal Marketplace

7.3
New York, NY
Supermarket · Chelsea · 2 tips and reviews

Reginald L V.Reginald L Valentine Sr: Great shopping reasonable prices

Michelle W.Michelle Wiles: It always looks closed. But it's not

Zeytuna is one of The 15 Best Supermarkets in New York City.

14. Zeytuna

7.3
59 Maiden Ln (at William St), New York, NY
Supermarket · Financial District · 57 tips and reviews

Marlo C.Marlo Colquhoun: Try their taco bowls..yummy

The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group: More delicious and affordable than any other place in the area – go to the salad bar and load up on the Chicken Curry Salad and the Grilled Mixed Vegetable Salad.

Megan C.Megan C: Now has wifi! Given that Zeytuna's dining area's in the basement, the recently-available wifi thing rules.

Key Food is one of The 15 Best Supermarkets in New York City.

15. Key Food

7.3
1769 2nd Ave (btwn 92nd & 93rd St.), New York, NY
Supermarket · Yorkville · 12 tips and reviews

Alvin S.Alvin Suarez: They have the most helpful, friendly and professional staff. I've been shopping here since I was a kid. Still love this place. The prices and selection are also fantastic.

Samantha T.Samantha Tananbaum: Great selection, best prices in the neighborhood, and by far the friendliest staff. The owners are the nicest guys! Love this place, and so sad a rent hike will force them out in Sept.

Jared H.Jared H: Great selection and cheapest option in the neighborhood.