1. Juliana's Pizza
8.8
19 Old Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · DUMBO · 322 tips and reviews
Stephanie Gladden: Pasty Grimaldi is back and in his original location. Super delicious. Margarita pizza is perfect. Must try the raspberry choc. chunk icecream sandwich!
Jack Harrison: A 'small' margherita is more than enough for two to share for lunch, and is *hands down* the best pizza you'll ever put in your body.
Charlottes: Great margarita pizza and one I never would have picked but chosen by my friend and regular, with sasauge and broccoli which was delicious. Agree with other commenters, small is huge!
2. Barboncino
9.2
781 Franklin Ave (btwn St Johns & Lincoln Pl), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Crown Heights · 227 tips and reviews
Nikolas Floros: Try the montenegroni and a margarita pizza
Kyle Turman: Best pizza in Crown Heights. Dough, sauce, and toppings are all top notch. Meatballs appetizer is amazing and even their Margherita pizza is fantastic.
Cole Kennedy: Oh my goodness. This is good pizza. Best pizza in the neighborhood, even. Start with the excellent margherita and explore the menu from there.
3. Roberta's Pizza
9.2
261 Moore St (at Bogart St), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · East Williamsburg · 864 tips and reviews
Katherine M.: Back patio + warm afternoon + great margherita pizza + well-chosen beer selection = bliss. In a sketchy area that is quickly gentrifying.
ZenFoodster: Amongst my fave pie joints in NYC! A perfectly thinner crust than most - Margherita w/ red onion & soppresata had tasty, sweet sauce & held up perfectly! Pizzas taste great on own w/o chili oil.
Rewan Parti: Their famous original and margarita pizza are awesome! They can have a long wait sometimes. Do try the Pilsner on tap!
5. Ops
9.1
346 Himrod St (Wyckoff Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Bushwick · 51 tips and reviews
Emily Wilson: A perfect restaurant; a haven for casual dining — ask your server about what's available (antipasti, natural wine), order at least one Margherita pie, and stay for a while. Everything here rocks.
Elvis Rodricks: Thought their Margherita was better than their signature square
Onur Avcı: Sıcak, samimi atmosfer eşiliğinde napoliten pizza seviyorsanız eğer margherita denemeye değer. / If you like napolitan pizza, you should try margherita with warm friendly atmosphere.
6. Saraghina
9.2
435 Halsey St (at Lewis Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Bedford-Stuyvesant · 208 tips and reviews
Decor Musings: You MUST have the Margherita pizza. And beware, it's a cash-only kind of place.
Liza Dye: From brunch to dinner, everything on the menu is great. Margherita pizza is the best...brush up on common Italian dishes before looking at the menu or just ask for help - friendly wait staff.
Michelle C: My margherita pizza was delicious. My friends raved over their risotto and spaghetti. The sole disappointment was the painfully slow service. We were never checked on from the waiter's own initiative.
8. Table 87
8.6
473 3rd Ave (at 10th St), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Gowanus · 35 tips and reviews
Behrad Eats: The infamous coal oven margherita slices is what you come here for!
Rich Foster: Nothing special here. I ordered a margarita pizza with sopressata for takeout. I had to wait, so I watched them make it. They basically laid the meat on the pizza after it came out of the oven.
Hannah Nicdao: Delicious delicious margherita. Fresh ingredients, coal oven cooked, and not greasy. One of the best quality single slices in the area.
9. Forcella
7.5
485 Lorimer St (btwn Grand & Powers St), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · East Williamsburg · 93 tips and reviews
jessica m. hintermeister: here's the deal. order the following & thank me after: insalata caprese, marinara pie, margherita pie, & montanara pie (fried Margherita)
Daniela Asaro: Try the fried pizza (Montanara) at least once but don't make that your main meal. Their Margherita Regina is amazing, and their rice ball is the best I've had ever. Try to save room for dessert! BYOB
Tasting Table: Get the can't-beat lunch deal: $10 for a Margherita pizza and a soup or salad: Read more.
Jackie Margol: Margherita pizza is amazing! Also the tartufo for dessert is fantastic. Great service. Great atmosphere. Check out the back deck!
Janis Huang: Margherita pizza is fantastic. Great oysters, perfect al dente pastas. Cute patio, very friendly staff. A great addition to the neighborhood. Byob until they get their liquor license.
Rick Nelson: Delicious coal-fired pizza that’s crust is thinner, soft and chewy, and has just the right amount of charring. The margherita is classic and tasty
13. Speedy Romeo
9.1
376 Classon Ave (at Greene Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Clinton Hill · 225 tips and reviews
Jenn Allen: I had a margherita with pepperoni and sausage. Delicious!!! Hubby had the Saint Louie and loved every bit of it!!!
Erin Lee: Had the Marinara & Margherita. Trés delicious. But don't recommend the cocktail, it's liquid jolly ranchers. No bueno.
Graham Gnall: Dangerfield, Margherita
14. La Villa Pizzeria
8.5
6610 Avenue U (at 66th St.), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Mill Basin · 40 tips and reviews
sadtt: When you go to La Villa on Avenue U, sit at the bar for friendly service and free appetizers: gorgeous onion focaccia and rice balls. The pastas: perfect, but the pizzas: excellent. Hello Margherita!
Steve Liverpool: Everything is tasteful and delicious here to eat. Love there Margarita pizza. This is one of the best places that makes it in Brooklyn. If in the area try them.
Joe Esposito: Gotta get the sottosopra square pizza and the chicken caeser wrap
15. Ogliastro Pizza Bar
8.6
784 Washington Ave (Sterling Pl), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Prospect Heights · 46 tips and reviews
Hector: Margherita pizza (12 inch) is delicious - and they stay open til 1
Matthew Schmohl: The margherita pie offers a saucier alternative to neighbors Barboncino and Emily. I was really surprised by this place; a real sleeper. Ogliastro salad is great, too.
Q: Sit outside in the back during the summer and get any of the signature pizzas. A really good dinner decision, always.