The Parma (tomato sauce, cheese, thick bacon, prosciutto, arugula, apple & balsamic vinegar) is an unlikely champion. I'd go as far as saying it's the best pizza in NYC.
Great place to get a glass of wine – also has a spectacular vanilla ice cream w/strawberries and balsamic vinegar dish.
This place is DELICIOUS! Try southern hospitality and the mint one w/ the brownie pieces! They use real fresh mint, not the green artificial stuff! Great for breakfast, lunch and dinner...and dessert.
The tap list is overwhelming with some of the best craft beers a gal could as for, so don't be afraid to ask for a recommendation.